• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Next-Gen PS5 & XSX |OT| Console tEch threaD

Status
Not open for further replies.
Guys, what do you think about the last update in the PS5 page and the removal of the backward compatibility stand... Do you think there is something to fear for?
WilpfqD.png

I'm taking it with a grain of salt, I am sure it is still going to have BC so no real worries.
 

Corndog

Banned
You have splash screens, messages, contacting servers, safety pages, all sorts of crap of course.

But we have had 2 demos from Ps5, Spiderman and UE5

We have had 2 demos from MS, State of decay and fast resume demos (5 or 6 games ?).

There is a gulf so far more than 2 x the bandwidth specs, add in latency and difference is massive (so far).

Balls in MS court.
Hellblade 2. If that was real-time graphics it was pretty impressive.
 

geordiemp

Member
Compression takes a very long time (much longer than decompression), therefore I'm certain quick resume game data is not compressed.

Quick resume demo on YT shows Xbox One X games build to run on 12 GB RAM (9.5 GB game data + 2.5 GB for system data), not 5 GB. 5 seconds for 12 GB transfer correspond exactly with XSX SSD RAW speed and proves there are no SSD bottlenecks. Games build with XSX hardware in mind will load even faster, because BCpack (4.8-6 GB/s) will fill 13.5 GB in around 2.5-3 seconds. It will be awesome speed, but of course PS5 will move data even faster (9-20 GB/s) and load entire game in about one second.


Nope those games chosen were current games that run on 5 GB RAM or 8 GB if we think its got Xb1X texture enhancements (and thats pushing it).

So 5 seconds.,,,, what is 8/5 ? or 5/5 as there was 6 last gen games shown.

A 5 GB RAM game should be 2 seconds if the raw speed was really 2.4 without any obstructions, but there are other latency things arent there,,,,?

Did you look at the resume games ? Did they all have extra 4K textures ? mmmm

Hellblade 2. If that was real-time graphics it was pretty impressive.

I saw nobody controlling movement, its called a trailer. Unless I see someone controlling the character from the players viewpoint,,,,,,its a trailer.

We want to see NO TRAILERS otherwise its a game that is likely long way a way - same goes for Sony, .....

Trailer says here is a game announcement for 2 years time..fine but I dont get excited .....at all.
 
Last edited:

IntentionalPun

Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
Man some of ya'll or so weird... Sony could easily detail their BC plans more AND.. get this.. still talk about and largely focus on new games lol.

Like they can have someone in charge of BC write a blog post and take away NOTHING from new game announcements.

As a consumer.. give me the damn info.
 

Jaxx_377

Neo Member
They probably just want to focus on what’s new and keep it simple
Or perhaps they removed the reference to ps4 only because they figured out how to support ps3 and beyond but haven’t announced it yet


Also maybe they are trying to sell you TLOU 2 and Ghost of Tsushima and dont want you to think you can just wait for the new system. They are in a business to make money afterall
 

jose4gg

Member
Also maybe they are trying to sell you TLOU 2 and Ghost of Tsushima and dont want you to think you can just wait for the new system. They are in a business to make money afterall


Yea, so I lost my PS4 due to a robbery, but I know they would LOVE to sell me a new PS4 instead of waiting for the PS5 😂
 

IntentionalPun

Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
Also maybe they are trying to sell you TLOU 2 and Ghost of Tsushima and dont want you to think you can just wait for the new system. They are in a business to make money afterall
Errr.. they've already discussed BC on PS5 though. Why would that particular sentence matter to TLOU2 and GoT compared to the fact Cerny already talked about BC?

And why is everyone ignoring the weird "with system update" thing?

That seems like the thing to note to me.

Knowing I can play TLOU2 and GoT on PS5 will actually guarantee a purchase from me not the other way around lol
 
Last edited:
See the OP screenshot.


It's the company's official website. I'd take it with a grain of salt if it came from an insider or someone else, but man... this is really Sony shooting themselves in the feet.

The marketing team is probably just streamlining the info on the PS5 page, I highly doubt they are removing BC from the PS5...having BC is part of their game plan to transition everyone to the next gen so no need to read into it.
 
That effects CPU time not frequency.

It does not do anything remotely like downclocking does. I have my doubts that would be useful for BC in the same way as matching clocks is...

(I could be wrong though, but I thought it was the frequency that was important to some games as they expect a given piece of code to execute in an exacting amount of time, not get a certain amount of threads scheduled per second which is what I believe HperV does.)
I have curiosity about how XSX will just increment the framerate for all the games if some games has attached
many of his logic and animations to the framerate, I know is not the best practice but happens a lot.
 

DaGwaphics

Member
That effects CPU time not frequency.

It does not do anything remotely like downclocking does. I have my doubts that would be useful for BC in the same way as matching clocks is...

(I could be wrong though, but I thought it was the frequency that was important to some games as they expect a given piece of code to execute in an exacting amount of time, not get a certain amount of threads scheduled per second which is what I believe HperV does.)

True. Limiting CPU time can really help with things moving too quickly. Run an old game like sims 1 or a DC emulator in VMware, as you decrease the percentage of compute available to the VM you can get the game speed to run more in line as it should. Without doing this, everything moves too fast in some games. This might not be something that they use at all on Xbox, but it can help with old games on PC. :messenger_beaming:

This was just a random thought, not a reflection of something would absolutely be done. I think only MS and developers know exactly how the system works at this point.
 

IntentionalPun

Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
I have curiosity about how XSX will just increment the framerate for all the games if some games has attached
many of his logic and animations to the framerate, I know is not the best practice but happens a lot.
I believe games like that generally lock framerates though; I think that's why they mention some games can be doubled from 30 to 60 selectively. If they can double the locked framerate and somehow get the game to do those calculations based on the doubled framerate, the game would work fine.

Some games they can't unlock the framerate on but can improve in other ways.

There are PC games with locked framerates that hackers un-lock and fix for instance.
 
Last edited:

kuncol02

Banned
So you’re saying BC games don’t require decompression?
Thast's oposite of what I said. They not only require decompresion, but it can't use hardware, because way game data have to be decompressed is hardcoded into game itself.

Guys, what do you think about the last update in the PS5 page and the removal of the backward compatibility stand... Do you think there is something to fear for?
WilpfqD.png
Looks like BC could not be available on launch
 

geordiemp

Member
BC

BC is there but they need to stop to talk about BC and start to put fire with new games.

With system update, so why would Sony say you have to update your Ps5 to latest firm ware ?

I can only think that maybe because they are still optimising BC......and there are some ps5 that are already in boxes and have been made using an OS that is already outdated ? Or maybe you have to download some minor patch details for each game by connecting to servers.

I guess each game needs checking and some optimising at least.
 
Last edited:

Corndog

Banned
Eh does really Microsoft or anyone else other than Sony know if/when/to what extent the PS5 will downclock or boost? Isn't it really, really silly and desperate to ridicule details about a console that is not yet released, based on assumptions and rumors with no real facts or real-life examples? 🤔

At least the "used game thing" really was a thing, back in the days.
Like another poster said read the actual article. It is about bc, not new games.
 

ethomaz

Banned
With system update, so why would Sony say you have to update your Ps5 to latest firm ware ?

I can only think that maybe because they are still optimising BC......and there are some ps5 that are already in boxes and have been made using an OS that is already outdated ? Or maybe you have to download some minor patch details for each game by connecting to servers.

I guess each game needs checking and some optimising at least.
I believe there is a day one firmware update where all features are unblocked.
PS4 had the same.
 
Last edited:
With system update, so why would Sony say you have to update your Ps5 to latest firm ware ?

I can only think that maybe because they are still optimising BC......and there are some ps5 that are already in boxes and have been made using an OS that is already outdated ? Or maybe you have to download some minor patch details for each game by connecting to servers.

I guess each game needs checking and some optimising at least.
Maybe they decided that statement might confuse people currently. BEFORE they have more chances to talk about the PS5.
 

IntentionalPun

Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
With system update, so why would Sony say you have to update your Ps5 to latest firm ware ?

I can only think that maybe because they are still optimising BC......and there are some ps5 that are already in boxes and have been made using an OS that is already outdated ? Or maybe you have to download some minor patch details for each game by connecting to servers.

I guess each game needs checking and some optimising at least.
I mean.. the PS5 is going to have a day one patch regardless.. I don't know why they'd need to be so specific about BC.

To me it reads like they don't expect BC to actually be ready at launch and that it will be coming in a future patch. Otherwise I don't know why marketing material would need to mention it. All online/media features for any game/console generally require day one patches and I don't see warnings like that being listed in basic marketing blurbs. They put them in fine print.
 

pixelguy

Member
With system update, so why would Sony say you have to update your Ps5 to latest firm ware ?

I can only think that maybe because they are still optimising BC......and there are some ps5 that are already in boxes and have been made using an OS that is already outdated ? Or maybe you have to download some minor patch details for each game by connecting to servers.

I guess each game needs checking and some optimising at least.

They have a built in CELL CPU for PS3 BC an Raytracing.
And they just don't want to tell you about that CELL inside... :messenger_beaming:
So they have to talk about BC later.

And yes, I have no sources for that.
 

Corndog

Banned
Aren’t a lot of 360 games recompiled for X86? As in you bollock your 360 disk in and it downloads a patch?
That would be running natively rather than emulated, and is much easier on the CPU, and much better full-stop.
The code isn’t recompiled. There are some articles about it but I don’t know them off hand.
 

DrAspirino

Banned
having BC is part of their game plan to transition everyone to the next gen so no need to read into it.
Exactly. That's why I said it's Sony shooting themselves in the feet: BC it's one of the key features that they should advertise just as much as everything else as a part of their transition plan. They have to lure the 100M PS4 users (most of them casuals) to become 100M PS5 users. The core base will get the PS5 anyway (which are something like 30-40M or so), but I wouldn't be so sure about the rest.
 
Last edited:

Corndog

Banned
For example I have two Xbox 360 just in case the old one dies XD

Is shit doesn't matter who said it, specially from a company who love to say everything is love and they don't considered Sony as its competition (when is Sony and Nintendo which can say that).

That is all my impartial friend.
Come on. Both companies have thrown crap around. Xbox 1.5 ring a bell.
 

Jaxx_377

Neo Member
Errr.. they've already discussed BC on PS5 though. Why would that particular sentence matter to TLOU2 and GoT compared to the fact Cerny already talked about BC?

And why is everyone ignoring the weird "with system update" thing?

That seems like the thing to note to me.

Knowing I can play TLOU2 and GoT on PS5 will actually guarantee a purchase from me not the other way around lol

I get that BC has already been talked about but most of those that are goign to buy these games arent as vigilent as Gaffers and hardcaore gamers are about the latest info on next gen and you dont wan tto tank any sales
Errr.. they've already discussed BC on PS5 though. Why would that particular sentence matter to TLOU2 and GoT compared to the fact Cerny already talked about BC?

And why is everyone ignoring the weird "with system update" thing?

That seems like the thing to note to me.

Knowing I can play TLOU2 and GoT on PS5 will actually guarantee a purchase from me not the other way around lol

I dont think it would hurt ps5 sales I just think they dont want to hurt the games ps4 launch sales with those who are willing to wait out a possible PS5 version so just be vague about it for now and clarify it at a later date
 

Gamernyc78

Banned
After giving it a little bit more thought, there is something i just don't like in the way that Microsoft is conducting their business.

A while back Microsoft were telling everyone that Sony were not their competition.

We keep getting shitty twitter comments or cheap jabs from people lately associated with Microsoft always trying to downplay or throw shade in the PlayStation's direction of late.

Microsoft said they are confident in their machine and their games so why not just let that do the talking instead of the constant smear campaign they are trying to run.

Things like Phil the other day with the unreal engine bit, trying to squeeze abit of positive pr out, it feels so desperate.

I keep going back to people like Dealer and colteastwood and the way they act and the way guests talk on their podcast. They have Microsoft executives on that show and that type of fratboy behavior is now seemly rubbing of on the way Microsft conduct themselves.

You sleep with dogs you get fleas is the expression i believe.

Is this really how Phil Spencer wants his gaming division to be run.

I do want to buy an xbox console to go alongside my ps5 but this kinda of shit is starting to really put me off.

Of late, whenever i see something about xbox, i am starting to feel like i need to go and take a shower.

They really need to be better than the way they are acting.

Happens all the time even when Phil comes with tht pr narrative that all companies should work together or Sony isn't the competition right after his interviews someone from Microsoft's twitter pages or social media says some dumb shit or jabs at Sony. It's all pr nonsense and trying to be ninjas but it's very transparent.
 
Hellblade 2. If that was real-time graphics it was pretty impressive.
Was in engine running to 24 frames also below to 4k, if a tech demo running in a some device is like "yeah maybe in the future a game can looks like that"
the trailers in engine are "wow I wish my hardware will be enough powerful to be able of run that" similar but not the same.
 

IntentionalPun

Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
I get that BC has already been talked about but most of those that are goign to buy these games arent as vigilent as Gaffers and hardcaore gamers are about the latest info on next gen and you dont wan tto tank any sales

I dont think it would hurt ps5 sales I just think they dont want to hurt the games ps4 launch sales with those who are willing to wait out a possible PS5 version so just be vague about it for now and clarify it at a later date

"This game will also work on your PS5" makes me buy a game, not the other way around. I can see how SOME would take it differently, but I feel like it's not something that tanks sales as there are different viewpoints on it.
 
Exactly. That's why I said it's Sony shooting themselves in the feet: BC it's one of the key features that they should advertise just as much as everything else as a part of their transition plan. They have to lure the 100M PS4 users (most of them casuals) to become 100M PS5 users. The core base will get the PS5 anyway (which are something like 30-40M or so), but I wouldn't be so sure about the rest.

That is exactly why we will still have BC, Sony isn't stupid by any means and I highly doubt they would make such a horrible decision like that, I wouldn't sweat it, we will still get BC just like they said we would.
 
“with system update” is also clunky English. I think they mean some games themselves might need patches to work, as mentioned by Cerny and as done by Microsoft.
I think it was pulled because it was confusing, and whatever they have lined up will probably explain what they mean by it.
The chances that PS4 backwards compatibility has been removed after how much the GDC talk went over it, and how much work they’ve done to get up to speed on it is zero percent.
My bet is we might see that line returned—perhaps worded better—after a PS5 event where they demonstrate its features.
 
Maybe it won’t be ready for launch so they don’t want to promise something until they can deliver.

This could be the reason as well. I know before it stated with firmware update, so I guarantee the day 1 firmware update for the PS5 it will have BC...now how many games it will support will be the question, I know they are probably constantly checking compatibility of PS4 games up until launch so that is probably why it was stating after a firmware update because from the date of manufacture to launch there are going to be games that have been added to the list that weren't at the beginning of production. People need to relax about that, we will be getting BC...
 

Moses85

Member
They have a built in CELL CPU for PS3 BC an Raytracing.
And they just don't want to tell you about that CELL inside... :messenger_beaming:
So they have to talk about BC later.

And yes, I have no sources for that.
No problem :) there enough others around here, which guessing daily. Nobody knows anything, they know a shit.
 

pawel86ck

Banned
Nope those games chosen were current games that run on 5 GB RAM or 8 GB if we think its got Xb1X texture enhancements (and thats pushing it).

So 5 seconds.,,,, what is 8/5 ? or 5/5 as there was 6 last gen games shown.

A 5 GB RAM game should be 2 seconds if the raw speed was really 2.4 without any obstructions, but there are other latency things arent there,,,,?

Did you look at the resume games ? Did they all have extra 4K textures ? mmmm



I saw nobody controlling movement, its called a trailer. Unless I see someone controlling the character from the players viewpoint,,,,,,its a trailer.

We want to see NO TRAILERS otherwise its a game that is likely long way a way - same goes for Sony, .....

Trailer says here is a game announcement for 2 years time..fine but I dont get excited .....at all.
Xbox One X patches DL automatically on Xbox One X, and I have no reason to think it's different on XSX. Also I expect XSX must load entire 12 GB RAM (not just 9.5 GB game data) from quick resume save state. MS is emulating BC games, not running them natively.
 

DaGwaphics

Member
Xbox One X patches DL automatically on Xbox One X, and I have no reason to think it's different on XSX. Also I expect XSX must load entire 12 GB RAM (not just 9.5 GB game data) from quick resume save state. MS is emulating BC games, not running them natively.

Wouldn't resetting the system memory turn back the clock on your OS, you'd be going back to an exact memory image (including downloading that game you were downloading yesterday when you switched states). I would think they'd leave the OS memory out of the equation, you don't want to reset that.
 
Why has this picture become a ''thing''? Context? I think Dictator is great in what he does.

The guy is a glorified pixel counter and that’s it, he may know some stuff about tech but mostly talks out of his rear.

He tends to downplay a lot of Sony stuff and not long ago he said the SSD tech won’t help game design going forward apart from loading things faster and was called out for it, he’s not a game dev so he clearly didn’t know, but then again he talks like he know what he’s on about.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom