• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Dirt 5 next gen upgrades may miss PS5 launch, saves won't transfer from PS4 version

D

Deleted member 775630

Unconfirmed Member
It's weird those save games can't transfer. Is this for all games?
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
Maybe a little extra TLC for the new controller?

A bit of a double loss on this one. Dirt 5 looks fun (not brilliant, but fun), and the saves thing seems anachronistic with how well the consoles and their upgrades this gen handle things, as well as Series X carrying that forward, or even something like like One being able to pull a Bioshock save from the cloud from over a decade ago.

Definitely an interesting generation. We’re starting to see the battle lines, priorities, strengths, and weaknesses drawn between the two.
 
I wonder why this seems to be an issue, is it because of technical/infrastructural stuff (which would be weird since sony already "running" their onlineservices on azure), is this on the devs or on sony?

Anyway personally i couldn´t care less, because i wont be affected of this, since i´ll just play cross gen titles on the new machines anyway.
 
  • Thoughtful
Reactions: Isa

MoreJRPG

Suffers from extreme PDS
It’s beyond ridiculous at this point. Good job Jim Ryan, I wonder if he’s a double agent for Microsoft because he’s doing everything he can to tear down everything Yoshida, House and Layden built.
 
What's up with saves not transferring?! This isn't the first game. Yakuza too.

Always online bullshit I'm betting. Lost some progress a few times because of "discrepancies" between the online and local save files On Dirt Rally 2. So I'm not surprised they can't make it work cross gen. They can't get it to work on one console.
 
Last edited:

cragarmi

Member
It appears the save transfer function was a late addition to the SDK, the PS5 save states may work differently to allow functions to jump straight to a particular boss, or level etc.. I believe Sony have a solution, but there have been a few compatibility issues. Id wait a few weeks, thing may change 🤞
 
We need a third case to be sure.


Maneater saves don't transfer between PS4 and PS5 either.
 

Night.Ninja

Banned
WgLmzaS.gif


Microsoft money hatted cross gen saves.

Some one make a thread
 

Three

Member
maybe theres a new save psn save system that new games like MM are using since spirderman definitely does not transfer.
Maybe, might have something to do with being able to share saves and people jumping in where you left off. I remember there was a patent for this.

My guess is that PS4 BC is emulated on PS5 rather than how Xbox One games are native like on XSX

That doesn't make sense. Why wouldn't it be able to use the PS4 save file then?
 
Last edited:

McCheese

Member
I always thought smart delivery was a fancy name for "well obviously that's how it'll work" delivery. But nope, sounds like Sony really dropped the ball compared to Microsoft here.

I presume saves are encrypted and the keys are stored on the hardware, so they can't decrypt and transfer in the cloud. But surely they could allow a direct transfer from PS4 to PS5, even the PS4 to PS4 transfer also did the encryption keys.

My guess is they could do it, but don't have the time to get it into the firmware before release.
 

Andodalf

Banned

Maneater saves don't transfer between PS4 and PS5 either.

Wow, so there's definitely something going on.
 

Neo_game

Member
My guess is that PS4 BC is emulated on PS5 rather than how Xbox One games are native like on XSX

Microsoft is using software emulation, PS5 has 2 HW BC modes for PS4 and Pro. It also have boost mode but I think that is so far limited to 100 games I think ?
 

G-Bus

Banned
Don't play these games but I'm really baffled about this save game thing.

Even a first party studio and game (spiderman) is having this save file issue.
 

Snake29

RSI Employee of the Year
Don't play these games but I'm really baffled about this save game thing.

Even a first party studio and game (spiderman) is having this save file issue.

It's not. The remaster is not the "same" game as the original. The PS4 version will transfer the saves over to the PS5 if you playing it on the PS5.
 
Last edited:

DavidGzz

Member
What about my Demon's Souls saves?

On a serious note, I wonder what's up. I guess BC is more complicated than you'd think. MS makes it look easy.
 

Neo_game

Member
Software emulation for Xbox One games? lmao no chance

It does not make any difference whether it is SW or HW mode. Only limited BC games will get some advantage from the next gen console. Better to wait and buy next gen version only IMO
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom