Riky
$MSFT
Last edited:
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF - Assassin's Creed Valhalla: PS5 vs Xbox Series X/ Series S Next-Gen Comparison!
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
AgentP
Thinks mods influence posters politics. Promoted to QAnon Editor.
Wrongly? If they need more than 10GB, then it was just bad system design. I guess the devs can make special stripped down version with lower res assets and smaller frame buffers, but then the XBSX will just lose on IQ. Pick your poison.
ToadMan
Member
I don't notice much difference until someone sticks graphs under the footage, already bought the XB version and I have 25 hours on it. I'd rather continue to have fun with it then trading it in and rebuying it on another platform.
But as I said, it gives me something to keep an eye on for future purchases. Right now it is looking like PS may be better going forward for third party stuff if the current trend continues.
This is the key point.
Back in the dark days of PS3 I played games and didn’t know whether they looked better or worse on 360 apart from reading about it.
However, if my 360 hadnt RROD’d and I could have looked at the same game on PS3 and 360 side by side I would have definitely noticed.
This gen if you do the same test with xsex and PS5 you won’t notice.
Just play all the games where you prefer to play them.
This stuff is just war fodder.
Last edited:
PaintTinJr
Member
I wonder what the real performance would look like if the XsX view turned as sharply as the PS5 one. I suspect the frame-rate drops much harder.Bloody Microsoft shills!
Despite them claiming the visual makeup is the same, you have to wonder why they haven't been able to perfectly align these two shots. it looks like they've zoomed the Ps5 shot slightly to get it close, because the first footage comparison footage in the next-gen speculation thread looked like the frustum setup was slightly inferior on the XsX, and this sort of confirms it IMHO.OOOFF! DOF is less quality on ps5.
edit : its not about the dark vs light there is clearly more banding, more blobbiness in the ps5 screen. thats a lesser DOF setting.
Self
Member
This Alex guy was very clear and straightforward in my opinion. He clearly stated that the XSX version of AC was inferior in a few departments.
ethomaz
Banned
I don't know if it is because he is outside MS but I don't remember he being a bad PR guy and he continue being more senil with the subject.
Looks at his reply to Panello.
I agree 100% here... even if PS5 had the worst performance in games.... what Sony delivered with Astro Playroom, Demon's Souls, Miles Morales, etc already set them apart from any other competitor and something that can't be mimicked.
Well looks at Switch success.
Last edited:
Vognerful
Member
?
Maybe we are reading or watching a different video? his message was that except overall performance, there is still issues here and there.
IF you read his part about PS5, would you say that the game ran bad on PS5?
And it seems when he say it need more work, he is directing it at ubisoft, not microsoft since the game has issues in tearing on both versions and bugs.
Slothbeing1209
Member
The animation in this game is outdated.
assurdum
Banned
The level of idiocy of this twitter is something else. The more worrying thing is coming from a person who theorically should have a minimal knowledge of what he talking about but seems the exact opposite.
Last edited:
a multicultural team of v
Member
Yeah I was thinking the same - maybe it's not an issue of wrongly, it is an issue of they have to tap that slower RAM. Which might even be worse than just having slower RAM only because now you have part of your frame coming at one speed and part of it coming at another.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
It's by design. He's a marketing bullshitter through and through.
He was even torn to shreds by other developers for his comments in the past.
cyber_ninja
Member
Damn that Xbox SeX doesn't look too SeXy right now.
Jigsaah
Gold Member
Yea well, I don't have a VRR TV so yea, while I don't really notice the frame drops or the stutters in the cutscenes as DF describes, the screen tearing is absolutely unacceptable.
Jigsaah
Gold Member
Oh noooo, if Astral had any credibility before this....it's gone now.
SkankHunt420
Neo Member
You are asking for a miracle if you think a patch will give you 12fps more
vito_don_corleone_
Banned
1080p on the next gen console
Ha
Ha
Ha
Ha
Ha
Ha
BlueXImpulse
Banned
Bitmap Frogs
Mr. Community
This post is a work of art. I shall hang it on my wall.
Colteastwood is hurting.
Oh colt, you poor soul. I'm sure he came to this 50% number because of the warzone fps difference, completely ignoring it's because how BC works. Is colt that bittermuch guy that keeps spewing that same line on here?
Md Ray
Member
Just speculation on my part. I'm trying to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Wandering Leopard
Member
He's a marketing person so it kind of makes that he doesn't know the specifics.
I think Tom Warren, who's supposed to be some kind of tech journalist, should have the capability to do the research before making those kinds of tweets.
Last edited:
Aceofspades
Banned
If you want truly next Gen experience (controller, UI, SSD): Get PS5
If you want best performing multiplat: Get PS5.
If you want industry leading exclusives: Get PS5
If you are poor and needs some NextGen action in your life? Get PS5DE
If you want best performing multiplat: Get PS5.
If you want industry leading exclusives: Get PS5
If you are poor and needs some NextGen action in your life? Get PS5DE
free advertising 
Coulomb_Barrier
Member
Md Ray
Member
Colteastwood is hurting.
Straight up delusional.
Some of the most prominent posters here say stuff more conspiratorially paranoid than this on a daily basis.
You can't laugh at this without laughing at a very prominent part of GAF culture.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
I don't want VRR being the end all be all fix either. Work on proper vsync, the tech is old and matured.
Reason, VRR lifts black gradient levels, so if you are sensitive to seeing a picture one way, then notice the shift in tones and gradients, it does stand out. Some displays worse than others, but even in the mighty CX, it lifts the blacks there as well.
Reason, VRR lifts black gradient levels, so if you are sensitive to seeing a picture one way, then notice the shift in tones and gradients, it does stand out. Some displays worse than others, but even in the mighty CX, it lifts the blacks there as well.
Monkeygourmet
Banned
Ayyy
Popup
Member
Last edited:
ethomaz
Banned
That is a issue on TV side, no?
It is immature yet.
Probably only TVs from 2022 and up will do VRR like it is intended because now it is really being tested (before the TVs supported hdmi 2.1 but there is nothing to use it so a new batch of TVs will fix these things).
Last edited:
Md Ray
Member
2060S?
Good luck finding a PS5DE
Jigsaah
Gold Member
I saw this video and here's my take on it. Even if Colt is right, how many games do I have to experience that were developed with non-current GDKs. It's not optimal either way. The games are coming out now!
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
I believe TV side, yes. Most gamer's are on TVs.
And agreed, I don't expect it to mature until 2022+.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
reinking
Gold Member
I don't know. Generation wait and all going on over at team Xbox.
RPSleon
Member
Dude its just blown out because the snow isnt in shadow and the grass against it is higher contrast than the sx shot. Youre reaching so fucking hard for something that isnt there.
FALCON_KICK
Member
Colteastwood is hurting.
For xbox fans, if you can verify these claims? What reduced the gap between PS4 and Xbox One? Was it dropping Kinect within a year or better APIs?
Neko Mimi Mode
Member
In fairness, Colt got his XsX sent to him for free but actually paid money for his PS5 - and his PS5 videos have been pretty glowing.
He's a fanboy but this video is actually just a rehash of what we already know, from Quantic Dream no less, about machine learning
Xbox Series X's Advantage Could Lie in Its Machine Learning-Powered Shader Cores, Says Quantic Dream
Looking at the hardware of Xbox Series X and PS5, Quantic Dream believes Microsoft's advantage could lie in the console's ML-powered shaders.
wccftech.com
Last edited by a moderator:
Yeah but I was just reading on MisterXMedia and they make a good point - you get 30 1080p frames in one second so it is basically running at 32,400p.
FrankWza
Member
its principalities