• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter 2012 Anime Thread of Roundcats Up in This

Status
Not open for further replies.
Does the Lost Canvas OVA have an actual ending, or is it one of the anime OVAs that just stop? I'm kind of wondering if I should watch it, but I know it didn't animate all of the source material, and I don't want to watch it if there's no actual ending.

Wiki still says it's ongoing, so I'm at least somewhat confident that there will be another OVA "season". I mean the 26 episodes available are technically 2 seasons already with a 10 month gap between episode 13 and 14. It still hasn't been 10 months since episode 26, so I doubt we have to worry about a continuation. Saint Seiya Omega might help it as well.

But to answer your question, it's more like an ending of a portion of the holy war. Really all that's left to do is fight Hades. I think another OVA would probably be only like 6 episodes or so similar to the other Hades OVAs.

Either way, it's definitely worth watching even if it has yet to be concluded.
 

Dresden

Member
Episode 4, while interesting enough were it to be on its own, was a case of complete tone whiplash when coming off of ep 1-3. I didn't care for it either when watching, tbh.

It was good, though.
And the end of it was consistent with the tone set by the rest of the series.
Best episode by far.
 
Episode 4, while interesting enough were it to be on its own, was a case of complete tone whiplash when coming off of ep 1-3. I didn't care for it either when watching, tbh.

That's too bad. I loved episode 4 and how different it was from the preceding three episodes. There were already a fair amount of mood shifts going on there anyway.

My opinion on Level E in ranking form: 4 > 10 > 1-3 > 12-13 > 11 > 5-7 > 8-9
 

Jex

Member
[Panda! Go, Panda!]

In the very early 70's Isao Takahata directed two short films (written by Miyazaki) about a little girl who becomes adopted by a family of talking Panda's because she has no parents. The plot never really gets more complicated than that and as you might expect from such a premise the tone is very light and silly. In fact, the amount of silliness feels much more like Miyazaki than Takahata, especially a sequence near the end of the second movie involving a runaway underwater train.

pandagopanda1.png


Whatever scenes your coming up with in your head when you read the present are probably present in Panda!. Yes, there's a sequence where the papa panda sits on a chair and it breaks, and another scene where the baby panda is supposed to be acting good but ends up causing a ruckus and there's even a scene where Mr. Zoo Keeper (name unknown) attempts to recapture the renegade pandas.

pandagopanda3.png


There's not really a plot to either of the movies either - they kind of meander around from scene to scene with no real logical reason guiding the story forward. Which is fine, because this is just meant to be taken as bit of light-hearted entertainment. Unfortunately, that doesn't make it very memorable either. While the direction is fine and animation is nice in places, the works as a whole just aren't that memorable. They feel too loose and unfocused - a collection of good ideas that haven't been worked into a coherent whole.

pandagopanda2.png


What's probably the most interesting thing about these movies is how Papa Panda is very clearly a proto-Totoro figure. He's asthetically very similar to Totoro, in particular his wide face, small feet, and his distinctive wide toothy grin, whiskers and nose. His face as a whole, and the expressions he puts on are pretty much identical to those Totoro has. He's even fond of forming the very same T shape with his body that Totoro does. Thankfully Totoro doesn't feel the need to speak all the time. Mimiko, the little girl adopted by the Panda's, can also be seen as a proto-Mei/Satsuki figure.
 

Erigu

Member
I was just kidding around, I don't really care about how ghost-rules work in this show, it was purely a reference to the many long discussions we had about Ano Hana.
My bad, Nisemonogatari gets such a bad rap around here that I can't tell anymore!


The hardest part about watching -monogatari is figuring out which parts are SHAFT trolling, which parts are Nisioisin trolling, and which parts happen to be both.
It's pretty faithful to the novel, so far, so...
 

Jex

Member
The hardest part about watching -monogatari is figuring out which parts are SHAFT trolling, which parts are Nisioisin trolling, and which parts happen to be both.

I think the fact that they show two extreeeeeeeeemmely long shots during a couple of earlier conversations is actually a joke about how often they've used that technique throughout the series to save money on animating characters. It's the director is saying "how can I make those long shots even more preposterous?"
 

Jex

Member
That's too bad. I loved episode 4 and how different it was from the preceding three episodes. There were already a fair amount of mood shifts going on there anyway.

My opinion on Level E in ranking form: 4 > 10 > 1-3 > 12-13 > 11 > 5-7 > 8-9

For me it would have to be 1-3>4>10>5-7>12-13>8-9>11

Episode 11 was quite bad and I derived absolutely no enjoyment from it. I may have actually erased my memory of the incident because it wasn't until I went back to check on Wikipedia that I was sure that I had seen it.
 
What is this, a Final Fantasy ranking thread?

Mouryou no Hako 3

This just isn't interesting. I can see what they're trying to do with the atmosphere, but the presentation and content aren't there to match it. It just comes off as incredibly dull. Not everything needs to be fast-paced, but a lot of the dialogue just comes off as time wasting and the small amounts of information that come trickling in aren't very meaningful without seeing the bigger picture.

I have no desire to continue. Sucks because the premise is typical interesting dismembering serial killer stuff.
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
Ranma 27

Finally, the worst arc so far is over. The only good thing to come out of it was more Shampoo.

Shampoo >>>> Akane

I read Kizu recently and I'm imagining all that dialogue in her voice and I'm like FINISH THE DAMN MOVIE ALREADY SHAFT
Man, if shaft does it right, Kizu will be so awesome.
 
Mouretsu Pirates 6

Well that was pirating. Pretty epic. I hope theres more like it in the following episodes and the preview...those graphics, hot. Kane was pretty cool in his role.

Must be the most exclusive clothing store ever
tumblr_lz8uwwsREr1qfepvio1_500.png
 

Steroyd

Member
I was waiting for someone to mention that CCS Mei lin is the worst character ever.

Not even close (Yes I'm talking when she first arrived), hell she even mellows out before
she goes back to China.
There are definately a fair few worse, before I even consider Mei Lin.
 
I don't know if it'll be good... probably "good". lol
I'm hoping for it to be as good as the manga, at least, except with a LOT more details about the matches than the Achiga-hen manga has... it skips over too much. There is some hope for that though -- the original Saki anime expanded on a lot of things versus the manga version of those events, so I'd expect that to continue. Best case probably would it being as good as the first anime series, though even if it isn't (in part because I don't know if I like this cast quite as much as the main one), hopefully it'll be somewhat close.

Yeah, I was referring to the manga. The scene and subsequent result:
Cecily is taken out to a shack, beaten/sexually assaulted (and quite graphically at that), then decides, in turn that she need give up her womanhood for it is weakness incarnate--my paraphrasing of the sentitment. Of course, over even all of that shock-induced resolve, she finds that her love for Luke is too strong and decides to 'remain a woman for a bit longer.'
It's dumb, very dumb.

Oh, that. I sort of remember that first part and it was bad but wasn't quite as awful as it could have been, but the second one I certainly do greatly dislike. That whole chapter was awful and incredibly sexist.

That first part, with the assault, is ch. 21; the second, with the "giving up her womanhood" stuff, is the last one I'd read, ch. 23. For the first, while it was somewhat graphic and awful, in some ways it was less bad than such things sometimes are in anime/manga -- I mean, Cecily did NOT like it, and was pretty broken and nonfunctional in that chapter and the next one. Her reaction to the assault was reasonably realistic, which is something when so often even rape in manga isn't portrayed as a problem (and yes, this is one of the things I dislike most about this stuff!). Oh, and she wasn't raped; the guy says he physically can't do such things. She was attacked, stripped, and mentally hurt, though, for sure, so it was certainly pretty bad. But it wasn't physical rape, just probably emotional, not that that's much less bad. At least she had a realistic reaction to it though, even if it certainly is a very stereotypical and very negative scene ("the woman gets sexually assaulted" certainly is an ancient trope in stories). I went into this chapter having heard stuff like what you said there, but I didn't hate it quite as much as I expected to given what I'd heard. 21-22 is bad, in some ways, sure, but could have been a lot worse.

As for the second one, though, the "giving up her womanhood" chapter 23, there are no excuses for that. That was sexism of a very bad kind, and is exactly the kind of thing I'd have expected from the anime version. I mean, seriously, her reaction to the above of wanting to "give up womanhood" was really, really stupid -- as if only by that she could be strong, or something? On come on. And then it gets even worse when she challenges Sigfried (the guy who'd done it to her in ch. 21) to a duel at a party... only to get psyched out by his words in reaction to his response, at which point Luke shows up and fights him for her. Because, you know, she's a woman so she's too weak to do such things on her own and needs the guy to rescue her and save the day. It is just despicable writing and storytelling. In the end she decides she "doesn't have to abandon womanhood perhaps" or something, presumably meaning that she doesn't mind Luke protecting her, or something like that. This chapter indeed is the manga being as bad as the worst of the anime.
 

Jex

Member
[Moribitio 20]

Everyone in this episode is acting far too logically and sensibly to be characters in an anime. I mean, there's supposed to be endless misunderstandings and deep seated distrusts to stop this kind of thing from ever happening.
 

iavi

Member
It was good, though.
And the end of it was consistent with the tone set by the rest of the series.
Best episode by far.

That's too bad. I loved episode 4 and how different it was from the preceding three episodes. There were already a fair amount of mood shifts going on there anyway.

My opinion on Level E in ranking form: 4 > 10 > 1-3 > 12-13 > 11 > 5-7 > 8-9

Yeah, it was just me in the mood for comedy, really.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom