• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

RUMOUR: Xbox One version of Call of Duty: Ghosts is 720p, PS4 version is 1080p?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hmmmmm.. tread lightly people, I never considered some mods may not be happy about this news.

Oh, I'm not commenting on the news itself at all. And this isn't any sort of warning. I'm just throwing out a different take to get on the record that banderas.gif isn't beloved by all. Any enjoyment I derived from it died a while back once I saw its 500th variant.

But don't mind me. Carry on.
 

Darknight

Member
QySDkvy.png

I love those #truthfacts.
 

Demon Ice

Banned
Wow, I have absolutely 0 faith in the XB1 and even I figured CoD Ghosts would be at 1080p60 on both XB1 and PS4.

It looks like a current gen game FFS.


If this rumor turns out to be true...wow.


The day fish AI killed the Xbox.
 
If it really is true that COD, a game based off a highly modified id Tech 3 Engine (came out in 1999), can't run better than 720p on a next gen console, then there is something really wrong with that console.
 

Faustek

Member
When does one give up to follow a thread and just wait for someone to boil everything down?

Or is it time for a script to pick posters and ignore the rest?
 

Skeff

Member
If titanfall is at or close to 1080p, shouldnt we be questioning IWs ability here?? If Respawn can make the same base engine run more shit better...this cant all be on the xb1? eh?

What makes you think it is 1080p? they've only shown the PC version.
 

TheFrza

Member
yea, for the consumers who do a little research. i willing to bet many people will just get an Xbone because that's what they had before.

Oh man, this is too true. My wife is still insisting on getting an xbone. I have no idea why, she just retorts to everything I say by saying that it is propaganda against the 'bone. Has me constantly saying "huh, wtf!?"
 

Mononoke

Banned
I'm not doubting that a significant power difference is there. My point is just that I don't think it's quite to this degree.

I mean, it's probably general consensus that Ghosts is the worst looking game on next gen platforms right? As far as I'm aware it's not doing anything overly impressive in any regard. It's a very, very average looking game. That's the reason why I have a hard time believing this rumor. Especially when you consider there are other games out there that look much more graphically impressive and are being presented at a higher resolution.

If this is true though, there's no doubt Microsoft is in for a PR nightmare regardless of whether it's the hardware itself or some kind of disconnection between Microsoft and Infinity Ward in terms of proper product support. I'm just very much skeptical at this point.




That's a fair point. I suppose it's a time will tell type of thing. First party games will generally look and run better, that's a given. I just think if some of the development teams on these games are able to churn out fantastic looking games at 720p/60 FPS, 900p or, in come cases, 1080p and/or 60 FPS I just have a hard time believing it's incapable of handling a mediocre looking game like Ghosts.

I mean, it's quite possible that we may see this kind of resolution gaps between Xbox One and PS4. As more news keeps coming out I'm generally coming to expect it as we get farther into these consoles life cycles and developers are tapping into all the power that these consoles are capable of. If this was a case of a game like BF4 running at 1080p on PS4 and 720p on Xbox One then I wouldn't have much trouble believing that. But Ghosts? I just don't know. Just seems too implausible to me.



I'm not sure on Ryse's FPS but I would assume 30, yes. I just making the point that Ryse's visuals blow Ghosts out of the water which makes me skeptical that the Xbox One can't handle Ghosts at 1080p. But then again, I'm not particularly well read in terms of hardware specs and what these consoles are doing under the hood. Just, from the outside looking in, I have a hard time believing that Infinity Ward has truly hit a brick wall with Ghosts on the hardware.

And yes, your point on Killer Instinct is well taken. I was just pointing out that the game is incredible looking and, really, Double Helix is doing some pretty awesome things with it. But the point remains, fighting games are generally less hardware taxing. I still just get the impression though that KI is doing so much more in terms of graphics and effects than Ghosts is. If Double Helix can get their game running great at 720p with the kind of visual fidelity they have then I just have a hard time believing that Infinity Ward is incapable of doing more with a worse looking game.

As I said though, I'm not exactly a hardware guru and will never claim to be. So in truth I could be dead wrong when comparing those two games. Regardless, I'm still skeptical about this rumor. There's no doubt the Xbox One is lagging behind the PS4 in terms of hardware but to this degree just seems unfathomable.

Er, wasn't the difference in power not as comparable last gen, because Sony used the Cell Chip? And that the "power" difference on paper was just that, on paper. Because no one knew how the performance of Cell would actually be. Whereas Xbox One and PS4 are now using very similar PC architects, and the difference is tangible this time. People actually can look at the specs, and see how much of a gap it actually is.

I don't really see how it's the same as last gen. Like, there is no reason for PS4 to NOT be more powerful (whereas the Cell was that reason for it not to be). I guess the only X factor this time, is in favor of Xbox One. How will the esram boost it? How will cloud processing bring it up to the same level?

I'm not saying those last two factors are legitimate, but it's my understanding of the only x factors we aren't really aware of, in terms of the gap being closed between the two. But in terms of hard specs, this gen it can be pinned down.

Unless I'm 100% wrong. And if I am, someone please correct me. Don't want to keep thinking something that isn't true.
 
Could this be why ea has been silent on resolution for bf4? Dat unprecedented partnership making them stay quiet and not wanting to reveal resolution for either?
 

viveks86

Member
Has anyone brought up in this thread, scott Lowe from IGN who tweeted about the video they put up today and all this week is running on PS4 1080p?

Just asking as this thread is moving to fast for me to catch up. It's like it's the Neogaf Megaton Train....choo choo...ALL ABOARD MELTDOWN CENTRAL!!!

There was a whole other meltdown thread on it yesterday! :)
 
Oh man, this is too true. My wife is still insisting on getting an xbone. I have no idea why, she just retorts to everything I say by saying that it is propaganda against the 'bone. Has me constantly saying "huh, wtf!?"
Who wears the pants in your house? Wait don't answer that :)
 
...and maybe you are wearing glasses smeared with vaseline....

I can see the aliasing on certain edges in Wind Waker HD from 8 feet away on a 1080p TV, and also I am not magical. People need to remember that a 1080p game needs a lot of anti aliasing etc to approach the IQ of a 1080p movie.
 
Oh man, this is too true. My wife is still insisting on getting an xbone. I have no idea why, she just retorts to everything I say by saying that it is propaganda against the 'bone. Has me constantly saying "huh, wtf!?"

Buy both that way you can have your cake and eat it to.
 

ironcreed

Banned
Anyone wanna place bets on the next bad Xbox One news/rumor. My bet is on that the OS won't be ready at launch and will have to updated shortly after.

Microsoft must feel like they are playing a never ending game of Whack a Mole. Every time they try to knock one down, two or three more pop up. Hell, I was warming up to their exclusives lately as well, but no way am I paying $500 for this system. Too much bad mojo.
 

Sanke__

Member
Honestly if someone doesnt understand the difference between 720p and 1080p, why the f*ck would they buy an xbox one OR a ps4 to play call of duty when its coming out on 360. The people in the market for a new system this holiday season definitely know the difference.

Didnt think of this:

My wife is still insisting on getting an xbone. I have no idea why, she just retorts to everything I say by saying that it is propaganda against the 'bone. Has me constantly saying "huh, wtf!?"

I feel bad now.

nevermind:

I guess I should have clarified and said not one xbone is pre-ordered and a PS4 is paid in full

I dont feel bad after all.
 

JaggedSac

Member
If it really is true that COD, a game based off a highly modified id Tech 3 Engine (came out in 1999), can't run better than 720p on a next gen console, then there is something really wrong with that console.

Very surprising they can only go from BO2 @ 880x720 on the 360 to 720p on the Bone.
 

Vire

Member
That's the real controversy here. For a game that looks so last-gen I am wondering how IW could potentially be running into this trouble.

Is it really the eSRAM causing this (potential) problem?

After seeing the PC minimum requirements, this news doesn't surprise me at all.

Dunno what's going on at Infinity Ward.
 
It will still have some great looking games, mainly on the exclusive side. It just sucks to see them trying to justify the $500 price because they had to design the system around Kinect. Many multiplats are going to be inferior as a result and that is just plain unfortunate.

It's not just kinect. The fact that games were not the absolute focus of the platform with everything built around that
 

ironcreed

Banned
That's the real controversy here. For a game that looks so last-gen I am wondering how IW could potentially be running into this trouble.

Is it really the eSRAM causing this (potential) problem?

The OS was apparently crashing on them when they pushed it. The inferior RAM solution probably has something to do with that, I would guess.
 

Eusis

Member
That's the real controversy here. For a game that looks so last-gen I am wondering how IW could potentially be running into this trouble.

Is it really the eSRAM causing this (potential) problem?
There's a reasonable chance that Microsoft isn't as far along with their development tools as Sony as, and therefore it's even harder to squeeze power out of the system. Ergo, even if next year's CoD is 1080p this one would be 720p whether or not it could be made to run at 1080p. Just look at something like Quake IV at the 360 launch, ran pretty badly while later id Tech 4 games ran pretty well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom