• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

2000s Cartoon Survivor-- The Revival!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Kill: El Tigre -Just OK.
Kill: Zatch Bell! Needed to be killed a long time ago.
Kill: The Amazing World of Gumball- it's alright
Save: Avatar
Save: American Dad needs to stay a little longer.
 
kill: dbz kai - Overrated
kill: teen titans - Meh
kill: archer - nothing personal. strictly business
;_;
save: The Spectacular Spider-Man
save: the proud family
 
Round 11 Results

The three shows eliminated this round are:

eltigre1.jpg


El Tigre with 17 kills and 9 saves in 61st place!

The_Amazing_World_of_Gumball_title_screen.jpg


The Amazing World of Gumball with 8 kills and 2 saves in 60th place!

archer-post1.jpg
Click to expand...
Archer with 5 kills and no saves in 59th place!

Shows in Danger of Elimination

Net Vote of 4
Dragon Ball Z Kai
American Dad
Gravity Falls

Net Vote of 3
Zatch Bell!
The Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack

Shows in No Danger of Elimination

Net Vote of -4
King of the Hill
Teen Titans

Net Vote of -5
Avatar: The Last Airbender
Drawn Together
Megas XLR
The Spectacular Spiderman
Samurai Jack

Net Vote of -6
Pokemon


Full Spreadsheet here!

REMINDER! 789Shadow will be tallying the votes tonight. 3/20's round will have a midnight EDT deadline.


Well, since you insist and I was tallying the last round, might as well do it at least once to keep everything up to date (let me know if any show slipped past and still ended up on this list):

Shows Remaining


  • American Dad
  • American Dragon Jake Long
  • Avatar: The Last Airbender
  • Batman the Brave and the Bold
  • Batman Beyond
  • The Boondocks
  • Codename: Kids Next Door
  • Courage the Cowardly Dog
  • Clerks: The Animated Series
  • Danny Phantom
  • Dave The Barbarian
  • Dexter's Laboratory
  • Death Note
  • Drawn Together
  • Dragonball Z Kai
  • Duck Dodgers
  • Ed, Edd, n Eddy
  • FLCL
  • Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends
  • Futurama
  • Full Metal Alchemist
  • Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood
  • Frisky Dingo
  • Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex & 2nd GIG
  • Gravity Falls
  • Harvey Birdman, Attorney at Law
  • Home Movies
  • Invader Zim
  • Jackie Chan Adventures
  • Johnny Bravo
  • Justice League/Unllimited
  • Kim Possible
  • King of the Hill
  • Megas XLR
  • Metalocalypse
  • My Life as a Teenage Robot
  • Paranoia Agent
  • Powerpuff Girls
  • Phineas & Ferb
  • Pokemon
  • Samurai Jack
  • Samurai Champloo
  • Spongebob Squarepants
  • Sealab 2021
  • South Park
  • Static Shock
  • Star Wars: Clone Wars (2003)
  • Sym-Bionic Titan
  • Teen Titans
  • The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron
  • The Angry Beavers
  • The Fairly Odd Parents
  • The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy
  • The Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack
  • The Proud Family
  • The Spectacular Spider-Man'
  • The Venture Bros
  • Xiaolin Showdown
  • Xmen Evolution
  • Zatch Bell!
 
Kill: Gravity Falls - I believe these are the last two needing cleansing.
Kill: Sym-bionic Titan - Same as above.
Kill: American Dad - Early seasons were bad. Heard it gets better, but meh.

Save: South Park- Further padding.
Save: Dragonball Z Kai - How DBZ should have been.

You should start posting a list of the remaining shows next round.
 
Kill: American Dad: A Family Guy-esque show that clicked with me even less than FG did.
Kill: Zatch Bell!: It's an okay anime. It has some good points, and some bad points. But it's getting to the stage where I'm voting for shows I consider mediocre and kinda generic now.
Kill: Batman: The Brave and the Bold: In my opinion, it's the second weakest modern Batman cartoon, beating only The Batman in terms of quality. I ignored the existence of Beware the Batman when it aired, so it might be weaker, but it hasn't even finished a full season; at this point, it would be unfair to judge it against the entirety of the other entries. Between TAS, TNBA, Beyond, THE, and BaB, BaB comes in at fourth for me. Humorous takes on the Batman franchise have worked in the past, that's the entire appeal of watching the old Adam West version of Batman. Even some of the older cartoons had silly moments that are classic. I just didn't like what the Brave and the Bold offered as a Batman cartoon.

Save: Dragon Ball Z Kai: Living the dream
Save: Paranoia Agent: Shrimp Baby told me to. Especially since "never seen it" is an awful reason when the entirety of the show is free on Youtube.

That last minute Archer snipe
;_;
 
BinaryPork2737 said:
It's in the OP, it just needs to be updated.
Click to expand...
I mean a list of the remaining shows posted after each round, not what has been voted out. Saves people from having to check the OP if a show is still in.
Plus the spreadsheets are still available for viewing, so it would be a bit redundant. If anything, maybe add the remaining shows that haven't received a single vote either way to the remaining spreadsheets.
Click to expand...
TheAbsolution posted the list in the 90s thread during rounds. It's easier to view.
 
Kill: Gravity Falls
Kill: Sym-bionic Titan
Kill; Batman, Brave and Bold

None of these shows ever really appealed to me, especially Batman, maybe I'm to old for this stuff.

Save: American Dad - The bad episodes are really bad but the good are fucking hilarious, more than make up for the bad episodes.
Save: Pokemon, just in-case.
 
A Human Becoming said:
I mean a list of the remaining shows posted after each round, not what has been voted out. Saves people from having to check the OP if a show is still in.

TheAbsolution posted the list in the 90s thread during rounds. It's easier to view.
Click to expand...
I can start doing that again. It was more for my convenience because it's harder to post that on mobile.
 
Kill: American Dad (don't like MacFarlane)
Kill: Pokemon (this show needs 7 kills to get the equivalent of one kill now, and it's not even that great to begin with. there is no reason it should have this many saves. hell, any show shouldn't have this many. but now i have to waste a kill vote on it because apparently seeing it slide down to like -2 is unthinkable.)
Kill: Zatch Bell (mediocre)

Save: DBZ Kai (it's DBZ)
Save: Sym-Bionic Titan (because watch this)
 
Purification is going smoothly. Not sure if people aren't noticing or just don't care. 2 shows left!

Kill: Symbionic Titan-Purification
Kill: Gravity Falls-I love GF...but it must die for the greater good
Kill: The Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack: Never thought I'd see Code Lyoko and El Tigre go before this, those were kinda good and this ranges between average and mediocre.
Save: The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy-One of the funniest shows to ever grace CN
Save: Codename: Kids Next Door-Same as Billy and Mandy, just not quite as funny

BinaryPork2737 said:
That last minute Archer snipe
;_;
Click to expand...

Hank-Hill-Menacing-Life-Of-Fire-In-King-Of-The-Hill-Gif.gif
 
Kill: Avatar: The Last Airbender
Kill: Gravity Falls - I'll jump on board with this one. It's not that good.
Kill: Dragonball Z Kai

Save: King of the Hill
Save: The Venture Bros

Other vise this is Copy/paste round for me.
 
Kill: Zatch Bell! - Scary puppets from hell.
Kill: Pokemon - Waaaaaaaaay too many saves.
Kill: Dragonball Z Kai - It is a remake of a 90s show

Save: Batman The Brave and the Bold - Best Batman related thing ever.
Save: Gravity Falls - Other shows deserve to go before this does.
 
Time to make up from missing yesterday.
Kill: Dave the Barbarian- meh
Kill: Zatch Bell might as well kill it now.
Kill:Flapjack- the show started to grate me
Save: Sym-bionic Titan
Save: Gravity Falls. - Damn you purists.
LLShC.gif
 
Kill: Gravity Falls - For purity
Kill: Dave the Barbarian - Still not good
Kill: Pokemon - Too many saves
Save: American Dad
Save: SpongeBob SquarePants
 
Kill: Symbionic Titan (Purification... might as well)
Kill: Gravity Falls (see above)
Kill: The Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack (Sod off already)
Save: Dave The Barbarian (Underrated blah blah blah)
Save: DBZ Kai (The offence will come eventually.)
 
Kill: Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack
Kill: Paranoia Agent
Kill: American Dad

Never seen Paranoia Agent. I hate Stan's selfishness. Flapjack was sort of creepy to me.

Save: Pokemon
Save: King of the Hill
 
Kill: Gravity Falls
Kill: Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends
Kill: DBZ Kai
Save: Pokemon
Save: Zatch Bell!

Now that I rewatch Pokemon on netflix, I see its a really creative and a one-of-a-kind show. Underrated series.
 
kill: dbz kai - this will die
kill: teen titans - Mehhhhhh
kill: Johnny Bravo - Eh
save: pokemon - didn't care for the games, but liked the original show
save: the proud family
 
kill: dbz kai
kill: powerpuff girls
kill: Sym-bionic Titan
save: pokemon
save: Death Note

Pokemon is better than all these shows. Ash Ketchum is a well written character. DBZ Kai must die.
 
Round 12 Results!

The three shows eliminated are:

Gravity Falls in 58th place, with 16 kills and 8 saves (Net = 8)

220px-Gravity_Falls_logo.png


The Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack in 57th place, with 13 kills and 5 saves (Net = 8)

250px-Flapjack_logo_02.png


American Dad in 56th place, with 12 kills and 5 saves (Net = 7)
(Tied with Zatch Bell! at Net = 7, eliminated due to less saves.)

209px-American_Dad_Logo.svg.png


Shows in danger of elimination:

Net = 7
Zatch Bell!

Net = 5
Dragon Ball Z Kai

Net = 4
Sym-Bionic Titan


Shows in no danger of elimination:

Net = -8
Pokemon

Net = -6
King of the Hill

Net = -5
Drawn Together
Megas XLR
Spectacular Spiderman
Samurai Jack

Full Results Spreadsheet
Round 13 voting is now open!

Remaining shows:

American Dragon Jake Long
Avatar: The Last Airbender
Batman the Brave and the Bold
Batman Beyond
The Boondocks
Codename: Kids Next Door
Courage the Cowardly Dog
Clerks: The Animated Series
Danny Phantom
Dave The Barbarian
Dexter's Laboratory
Death Note
Drawn Together
Dragonball Z Kai
Duck Dodgers
Ed, Edd, n Eddy
FLCL
Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends
Futurama
Full Metal Alchemist
Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood
Frisky Dingo
Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex & 2nd GIG
Harvey Birdman, Attorney at Law
Home Movies
Invader Zim
Jackie Chan Adventures
Johnny Bravo
Justice League/Unllimited
Kim Possible
King of the Hill
Megas XLR
Metalocalypse
My Life as a Teenage Robot
Paranoia Agent
Powerpuff Girls
Phineas & Ferb
Pokemon
Samurai Jack
Samurai Champloo
Spongebob Squarepants
Sealab 2021
South Park
Static Shock
Star Wars: Clone Wars (2003)
Sym-Bionic Titan
Teen Titans
The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron
The Angry Beavers
The Fairly Odd Parents
The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy
The Proud Family
The Spectacular Spider-Man'
The Venture Bros
Xiaolin Showdown
Xmen Evolution
Zatch Bell!
 
I think that i'll institute my soft cap rule now. The soft cap is going to be -6 or higher net.
So for this round, the max for any show will be -6.
 
TheAbsolution said:
I think that i'll institute my soft cap rule now. The soft cap is going to be -6 or higher net.
So for this round you cannot vote to save Pokemon or KOTH.
Click to expand...

but people can still vote to kill Pokemon and KOTH?

So if a show reaches -6, we can't save show in the next round. But everyone else can still kill this show?
 
Kill: Pokemon
Kill: Zatch Bell!
Kill: Dragon Ball Z Kai

None of those shows should still be here.

Save: Batman the Brave and the Bold
Save: Dave the Barbarian

Two awesome underrated shows.
 
List the shows 789shadow!

Kill: Sym-bionic Titan - Once it is gone, we will have a pure list.
Kill: Batman: Brave and the Bold - I disagree with what someone said a few pages back; serious Batman is best Batman.
Kill: Powerpuff Girls - Top 10 in the 90s thread.

Save: The Boondocks - Further padding.
Save: Dragonball Z Kai - How DBZ should have been.
 
Kill: Zatch Bell!: It's an okay anime. It has some good points, and some bad points. But it's getting to the stage where I'm voting for shows I consider mediocre now.
Kill: Batman: The Brave and the Bold: In my opinion, it's the second weakest modern Batman cartoon, beating only The Batman in terms of quality. I ignored the existence of Beware the Batman when it aired, so it might be weaker, but it hasn't even finished a full season; at this point, it would be unfair to judge it against the entirety of the other entries. Between TAS, TNBA, Beyond, THE, and BaB, BaB comes in at fourth for me. Humorous takes on the Batman franchise have worked in the past, that's the entire appeal of watching the old Adam West version of Batman. Even some of the older cartoons had silly moments that are classic. I just didn't like what the Brave and the Bold offered as a Batman cartoon.
Kill: Pokemon: It should not have a net vote of -8. And we all know why it has a net vote of -8, and it's certainly not because it is an amazing show. That one line from one of the specials is pretty great though.

Save: Dragon Ball Z Kai: I'm thinking it's gone this round thanks to the Ham-Hams. But I might as well give it a save anyway, for old time's sake.
Save: Home Movies: I need another save vote, so I might as well give it to something I like.

The remaining shows list has been copied to the round post, so the list that this post originally was is now redundant.
 
GMN said:
sounds fair to me. if you don't want that to be a problem then don't raise the cap that high.
Click to expand...

If Pokemon/King of the Hill lovers (which there are many) knew this rule ahead of time, then maybe it wouldn't end up passing the -6 cap. It's not exactly fair to then pull out this new rule all of a sudden, which retroactively puts two shows in danger.

This danger is that people can no longer throw a save vote. And yet people can still add kills. Say theoretically, Samurai Jack has more than -6. Then a bunch of hateful Samurai Jack haters can vote to kill that show into elimination.

In fact such a rule could be abused. If Samurai Jack has -5. Some devious men could then purposely save Samurai Jack until it was past the cap. Then in the next round, Samurai Jack can no longer defend itself. And thus, it's eliminated into the ground.

That doesn't make sense.

Ham-Hams disapprove.
 
kingkitty said:
In fact such a rule could be abused. If Samurai Jack has -5. Some devious men could then purposely save Samurai Jack until it was past the cap. Then in the next round, Samurai Jack can no longer defend itself. And thus, it's eliminated into the ground.
Click to expand...

So unless this new rule is disavowed, the Ham-Hams are going to go after Samurai Jack?
 
Kill: Sym-bionic Titan - For purity
Kill: Dave the Barbarian - Still not good
Kill: King of the Hill - Too many saves

Save: Powerpuff Girls
Save: SpongeBob SquarePants




kingkitty said:
If Pokemon/King of the Hill lovers (which there are many) knew this rule ahead of time, then maybe it wouldn't end up passing the -6 cap. It's not exactly fair to then pull out this new rule all of a sudden, which retroactively puts two shows in danger.

This danger is that people can no longer throw a save vote. And yet people can still add kills. Say theoretically, Samurai Jack has more than -6. Then a bunch of hateful Samurai Jack haters can vote to kill that show into elimination.

In fact such a rule could be abused. If Samurai Jack has -5. Some devious men could then purposely save Samurai Jack until it was past the cap. Then in the next round, Samurai Jack can no longer defend itself. And thus, it's eliminated into the ground.

That doesn't make sense.

Ham-Hams disapprove.
Click to expand...

Hm... With the current amount of voters that's not gonna happen anyway...
 
MikeHattsu said:
Hm... With the current amount of voters that's not gonna happen anyway...
Click to expand...

All theoretical of course.

anyways #rethinkthesoftcap

#ihaveinsomnia

MikeHattsu said:
Maybe better if one could still vote to save, but as long as it goes over -6 total with both the kills and saves it just stays at -6.
Click to expand...

Although, I think there isn't a need for any additional rule changes, I do like the option you described.

Keep the show at -6. Still allow the show to be saved or killed. Tally the votes up. Even if the show ends up getting -7, revert it back to -6. Much better way to go about this I reckon.
 
Maybe better if one could still vote to save, but as long as it goes over -6 total with both the kills and saves it just stays at -6.
 
I think I'll go alphabetically this round. I don't have any big qualms with most shows on the list or I haven't seen them so it's hard to pick what to vote. I do some research for next round.

Kill: American Dragon Jake Long
Kill: Avatar: The Last Airbender
Kill: Batman the Brave and the Bold

Save: Ventrue Bros.
Save Paranoia Agent
 
789shadow you made an error in the vote tallies last round on your spreadsheet. You list "The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy" and "Billy and Mandy" as two separate shows and separated their votes, but they're actually the same show. "The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy" should have 2 saves -2 total, and "Billy and Mandy" should be deleted.

ЯAW;105252575 said:
I think I'll go alphabetically this round. I don't have any big qualms with most shows on the list or I haven't seen them so it's hard to pick what to vote. I do some research for next round.
Click to expand...

You should do more research into Avatar. Cause it's a top 10 show.
 
Crayolan said:
789shadow you made an error in the vote tallies last round on your spreadsheet. You list "The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy" and "Billy and Mandy" as two separate shows and separated their votes, but they're actually the same show. "The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy" should have 2 saves -2 total, and "Billy and Mandy" should be deleted.

You should do more research into Avatar. Cause it's a top 10 show.
Click to expand...
Done.
 
Kill: Dragonballz Kai
Kill: Batman Brave and Bold
Kill: Sym-Bionic Titan

Never really cared for DBZ Kai or Batman, never saw titan but youtube does not do it justice.

Save:Pokemon
Save: Avatar
 
Kill: Symbionic Titan-We can't let a non 2000's show into the top 50!
Kill: Pokemon-8 below is a bit ridiculous
Kill: The Spectacular Spiderman-I don't like this being so low
Save: Xiaolin Showdown
Save: Jackie Chan Adventures
 
Kill: Sym-bionic Titan (pure list... also haven't watched)
Kill: Batman: Brave and the Bold ("I disagree with what someone said a few pages back; serious Batman is best Batman." Gotta agree with this one)
Kill: Pokemon (Too many saves)
Save: Kim Possible (The one animated Disney show not screwed over)
Save: DBZ Kai (Things would not be as interesting if it leaves now)
 
Kill: Spongebob Squarepants
Kill: Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends
Kill: DBZ Kai
Save: Pokemon
Save: Zatch Bell!

Ash taught me about friendship, Goku taught me about shitty dads.
 
Kill: Pokemon (absurd number of saves)
Kill: Zatch Bell (mediocre)
Kill: American Dragon: Jake Long (did not watch)

Save: DBZ Kai (because DBZ)
Save: Sym-Bionic Titan (because the cutoff is 2012 and this is better than the majority of the shows on the list)
 
kill: dbz kai
kill: powerpuff girls
kill: Sym-bionic Titan
save: pokemon
save: Death Note

Ash is a role model for children. DBZ Kai sucks.
 
Kill:Xiaolin Showdown
Kill: Jackie Chan Adventures- Sorry Kids WB shows but that list has much better things
Kill: Dave The Barbarian- still meh
Save: Symbionic Titan- I don't like you if youdon't like this
Save: Batman Brave and the Bold- Best Batman show that premiered on cartoon network.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

  • Poll
people seemed so much happier in the 2000s
2 3
132
2K
mopspear replied
Scrubs Revival | Official Trailer
2
73
1K
RCX replied
Beavis and Butthead Revival Season 3
19
548
nush replied
Remember Elizabeth Smart? From kidnapping and sexual assault survivor to champion bodybuilder
3
185
Bojji replied
School Phone Bans Spark Analog Revival: iPods Return
43
1K
mitch1971 replied
Top Bottom