• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

2000s Cartoon Survivor-- The Revival!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Really quick update post.
Shows eliminated:
Zatch Bell! in 55th place!
Symbionic Titan in 54th place!
Dragonball Z Kai in 53rd place!

shows left.
American Dragon Jake Long
Avatar: The Last Airbender
Batman the Brave and the Bold
Batman Beyond
The Boondocks
Codename: Kids Next Door
Courage the Cowardly Dog
Clerks: The Animated Series
Danny Phantom
Dave The Barbarian
Dexter's Laboratory
Death Note
Drawn Together
Duck Dodgers
Ed, Edd, n Eddy
FLCL
Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends
Futurama
Full Metal Alchemist
Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood
Frisky Dingo
Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex & 2nd GIG
Harvey Birdman, Attorney at Law
Home Movies
Invader Zim
Jackie Chan Adventures
Johnny Bravo
Justice League/Unllimited
Kim Possible
King of the Hill
Megas XLR
Metalocalypse
My Life as a Teenage Robot
Paranoia Agent
Powerpuff Girls
Phineas & Ferb
Pokemon
Samurai Jack
Samurai Champloo
Spongebob Squarepants
Sealab 2021
South Park
Static Shock
Star Wars: Clone Wars (2003)
Teen Titans
The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron
The Angry Beavers
The Fairly Odd Parents
The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy
The Proud Family
The Spectacular Spider-Man'
The Venture Bros
Xiaolin Showdown
Xmen Evolution


Will update with full results later.
 
Kill: Batman: The Brave and the Bold: In my opinion, it's the second weakest modern Batman cartoon, beating only The Batman in terms of quality. I ignored the existence of Beware the Batman when it aired, so it might be weaker, but it hasn't even finished a full season; at this point, it would be unfair to judge it against the entirety of the other entries. Between TAS, TNBA, Beyond, THE, and BaB, BaB comes in at fourth for me. Humorous takes on the Batman franchise have worked in the past, that's the entire appeal of watching the old Adam West version of Batman. Even some of the older cartoons had silly moments that are classic. I just didn't like what the Brave and the Bold offered as a Batman cartoon.
Kill: Pokemon: -6 is too damn low. Ash taught me that abandoning all of my friends except Pikachu, and Brock a few times, was a great way to start a new adventure.
Kill: Dave The Barbarian: I kinda like Dave the Barbarian. It's an okay show. I even threw it a save vote in an earlier round. But I can't really think of anything else I want to kill right now. It never really made me think, "hey, that's a great cartoon," it was more of a "well, nothing else is on right now, so I guess I'll watch it" cartoon.

Save: Home Movies: It was a bit more okay than Dave the Barbarian.
Save: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood: I dunno, I want to save something different tonight.
 
Kill : Avatar: The Last Airbender
Kill : Danny Phantom
Kill : The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron

Save : Jackie Chan Adventures
Save : South Park

Lets face it, Danny Phantom and Jimmy Neutron were both worlds more inferior than half of the shows eliminated in the last few rounds.
 
And DBZ Kai is out. What a pity, things will be less interesting with it gone.

Anyway

Kill: Pokemon (too many saves for a show that hasn't been good since 2003.
Kill: King of the Hill (Not really hick enough to appreciate the show)
Kill: Batman the Brave and the Bold (meh)
Save: Dave The Barbarian (needs help)
Save: American Dragon Jake Long (Could have been so much better if Disney weren't being idiots with this show.)
 
Do you taste that? It's the taste of purity.

Kill: Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends - Bloo ruined the show.
Kill: Batman: Brave and the Bold - I disagree with what someone said a few pages back; serious Batman is best Batman.
Kill: Powerpuff Girls - Top 10 in the 90s thread.

Save: The Boondocks - Further padding.
Save: FLCL - Same.
 
Kill: Dave the Barbarian - Still not good
Kill: King of the Hill - Too many saves
Kill: Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends - Didn't like this too much

Save: Powerpuff Girls
Save: Billy and Mandy
 
Finally this is actually a 2000s list.

Kill: Clerks: TAS-Never seen it
Kill: The Spectacular Spiderman-Too many saves
Kill: Drawn Together-See above
Save: Xiaolin Showdown
Save: Jackie Chan Adventures
 
kill: FMA Brotherhoood
kill: powerpuff girls
kill: FLCL
save: pokemon
save: Death Note

DBZ Kai must die!

Oh wait.

Uh, I think FMA Brotherhood is the worst thing since Russia's annexation of Crimea.

And Pokemon is great too.
 
kill: FMA Brotherhood
kill: Dexter's Laboratory
kill: The Venture Bros - like Archer. Nothing personal, strictly business
;______________;
save: My Life as a Teenage Robot
save: pokemon
 
Kill: Pokemon - Too many saves
Kill: American Dragon Jake Long
Kill: Dave the Barbarian
Save: Xiaolin Showdown
Save: Teen Titans
 
kill: FMA Brotherhood
kill: Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends
kill: spongebob
save: pokemon
save: American Dragon: Jake Long

FMA is depressing, and the dub came out in 2010. PURIFICATION
 
Is this round over yet?
edit: If not.
Kill: Dave the Barbarian
Kill: Frisky Dingo- didn't watch
Kill: Jimmy Neutron- ok but not great
Save: Batman Brave and the bold
Save: The Boondocks
 
Skid 4 Dead said:
Have we given up completely on these survivor threads?
Click to expand...
I'll put up a results post for now and see if anyone's still interested in finishing it up.

Results for Round 13!

442821.jpg
Click to expand...
Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends in 52nd place!
250px-DavetheBarbCast.jpg

Dave the Barbarian in 51st place!
Villains_braveandthebold_01.jpg
Click to expand...
Batman: The Brave and the Bold in 50th place!

Shows in danger of elimination!
4 Net Votes
American Dragon: Jake Long
2 Net Votes
Danny Phantom
Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Shows in No Danger of Elimination!
-5 Net Votes
Drawn Together
Megas XLR
-6 Net Votes
Pokemon

American Dragon Jake Long
Avatar: The Last Airbender
Batman Beyond
The Boondocks
Codename: Kids Next Door
Courage the Cowardly Dog
Clerks: The Animated Series
Danny Phantom
Dexter's Laboratory
Death Note
Drawn Together
Duck Dodgers
Ed, Edd, n Eddy
FLCL
Futurama
Full Metal Alchemist
Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood
Frisky Dingo
Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex & 2nd GIG
Harvey Birdman, Attorney at Law
Home Movies
Invader Zim
Jackie Chan Adventures
Johnny Bravo
Justice League/Unllimited
Kim Possible
King of the Hill
Megas XLR
Metalocalypse
My Life as a Teenage Robot
Paranoia Agent
Powerpuff Girls
Phineas & Ferb
Pokemon
Samurai Jack
Samurai Champloo
Spongebob Squarepants
Sealab 2021
South Park
Static Shock
Star Wars: Clone Wars (2003)
Teen Titans
The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron
The Angry Beavers
The Fairly Odd Parents
The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy
The Proud Family
The Spectacular Spider-Man'
The Venture Bros
Xiaolin Showdown
Xmen Evolution

Full Spreadsheet Link
 
Kill: FLCL - I have no idea what this is.
Kill: American Dragon Jake Long - meh
Kill: Pokemon - Too many saves.
Save: Static Shock - This is a good show.
Save: Duck Dodgers - Same as above.

Everyone who voted to kill Batman is a poo-poo head and a bad person. :'(
 
kill: the proud family - sorry bill cosby, but i never watched this
kill: the angry beavers - most of this show aired in the 90s and most of this show was annoying as all hell
kill: american dragon jake long - i've never seen it but i bet he's a jerk

save: flcl - it's a top 10 show
save: home movies - why not
 
Kill: Frisky Dingo - Voting out shows I haven't seen
Kill: Sealab 2021 - Voting out shows I haven't seen
Kill: Drawn Together - Voting out shows I haven't seen
Save: Powerpuff Girls
Save: Dexter's Lab
 
Kill: American Dragon Jake Long - Haven't seen it.
Kill: Avatar: The Last Airbender - Not my cup of tea.
Kill: Codename: Kids Next Door - Haven't seen it.

Save: King of the Hill - I won't take my chances with snipers.
Save: Frisky Dingo - Sick show but in a good way.
 
Kill: Death Note (first half was good, everything after episode 25 killed it for me)
Kill: Frisky Dingo (getting to the point where votes are turning into those not watched)
Kill: Pokemon (too many saves)
Save: Proud Family (Again worse shows to kill)
Save: Danny Phantom (Better than Tuff Puppy if nothing else)
 
Kill: American Dragon: Jake Long - Never watched this.
Kill: Xiaolin Showdown - Ditto.
Kill: Powerpuff Girls - Top 10 in the 90s thread.

Save: The Boondocks - Further padding.
Save: FLCL - Same.
 
Kill : Danny Phantom
Kill : The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron
Kill : The Proud Family

Save : PPG
Save : Samurai Jack

I liked the The Proud Family, but just not as much as most of the shows left. Voting of PPG because its an awesome show, and had an awesome showing in the 90s thread is insane.
 
Kill: Frisky Dingo- Didn't watch
Kill: The Proud Family
Kill: Jimmy Neutron- I did enjoy this and PF, but there are better shows on that list.
Save: The Boondocks
Save: Samurai Jack
 
Kill: Proud Family
Kill: Powerpuff Girls
Kill: Pokemon

Three Ps. :0
Completely indifferent to, great show but it was #4 in the 90s thread so tbh I'd rather it not take a spot too high on the list (I guess that's a bit of a stupid reason but I'm sticking to it), too many saves.

Save: American Dragon
Save: Jimmy Neutron

I loved these shows.
 
Really busy tonight, short explanations.

Kill: American Dragon-Jake Long: Thought it was meh, might be better if I go back to it.
Kill: Proud Family: I didn't care for it, don't really want to go back to it.
Kill: Frisky Dingo: Didn't care for the humor.

Save: Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood: It was pretty awesome.
Save: FLCL: It's easily a top 20 show at least, probably even higher
 
Kill: FMA Brotherhood
Kill: Invader Zim
Kill: Spongebob Squarepants
Save: Pokemon
Save: American Dragon: Jake Long

Brotherhood dub was 2010, Purification is needed.
 
kill: FMA Brotherhoood
kill: powerpuff girls
kill: FLCL
save: pokemon
save: Death Note

Death Note is epic. I wish I had a Death Note. That would be neat.

Powerpuff Girls is too violent, has to go.
 
kill: FMA Brotherhood - its death will be a worthy sacrifice
;_;
kill: teen titans - meh
kill: Johnny Bravo -meh too
save: pokemon
save: the proud family
 
Kill: Clerks: TAS-Never seen it
Kill: The Spectacular Spiderman-Too many saves
Kill: Drawn Together-See above
Save: Invader Zim
Save: Avatar: The Last Airbender
 
i think the mistake is making these threads way too big. same rules but for shows that aired between 2000-2009 and another thread for those that came out between 2010-2014 would have made things tighter and more interesting. we're 40 shows dead and people are still talking about purification. i know it's cool to have a really great big epic definitive list, but people lose interest real fast. we could really be at the top ten by now, especially with so many repeats from the 90s thread.

and i know some people didn't like the frank underwoods house of carding it up with the 90s thread and the toonami thread, but that's really what kept discussion and interest moving. that sort of thing should be encouraged, not limited. i mean at the end of the toonami thread, purposely going after shows you like just to shit up a thread aint cool, but making factions to keep shows you do like around longer like in the 90s thread... that was gravy.
 
Dunno if this is still going, but I figure I'll go ahead and vote again just in case:

Kill: FMA Brotherhood
Kill: Megas XLR - I never got to watch this show because it aired in the daytime during the summer and I was always at summer camp. Still bitter about it.
Kill: King of the Hill
Save: Avatar The Last Airbender
Save: Invader Zim
 
AniHawk said:
and i know some people didn't like the frank underwoods house of carding it up with the 90s thread and the toonami thread, but that's really what kept discussion and interest moving. that sort of thing should be encouraged, not limited. i mean at the end of the toonami thread, purposely going after shows you like just to shit up a thread aint cool, but making factions to keep shows you do like around longer like in the 90s thread... that was gravy.
Click to expand...

I like alliances too, but it only really works when you have a large amount of voters per round with multiple factions fighting. This thread doesn't have a lot of voters and only one real alliance.

Also last night's round will end tonight at 9.
 
Kill: Full Metal Alchemist - The inferior FMA show
Kill: The Proud Family
Kill: Frisky Dingo
Save: Teen Titans
Save: Avatar: The Last Airbender
 
A Human Becoming said:
Yep. Don't know what happened in the Toonami thread, but it seems like TheAbbsolution has made some bad choices since the 90s thread concluded.
Click to expand...

the toonami thread was shut down because people were kinda/sorta shitting it up, but i think it should have kept going because it was an actual fight and people were at least paying attention somewhat.

i think theabsolution's schedule was the worst part. you can't really blame that on him. not everyone can have no life like me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

  • Poll
people seemed so much happier in the 2000s
2 3
132
2K
mopspear replied
Scrubs Revival | Official Trailer
2
73
1K
RCX replied
Beavis and Butthead Revival Season 3
19
549
nush replied
Remember Elizabeth Smart? From kidnapping and sexual assault survivor to champion bodybuilder
3
186
Bojji replied
School Phone Bans Spark Analog Revival: iPods Return
43
1K
mitch1971 replied
Top Bottom