I can't help but feel though this stuff is down to the individual.
Of course it is. However, I feel like some people are more in love with the idea that they can fuck with the lighting and camera settings than they are with the final result. Blurry, awful DoF, chromatic aberration, crushed blacks, etc.
I mean, it's pretty cool that we can remove the color grading from some games with the most extreme examples. But color grading is a big part of a game's visual design and mood and the same goes for film and television. I mean, what would Terminator 2 be without all of those blue night scenes?
The modded shots are fun but I just wish they had their own thread instead of taking over what originally started as a way to see a game the way the developer intended.