Hours Left
Member
Personally, I think Akane didn't plan on any of the core 9 characters dying. I think she expected Ace and the 9th Man to work together in sabotaging the game, and that's probably why she chose Gentarou and Teruaki to be part of the main group, and have the other two Cradle execs contained. Gentarou is the only one that makes use of the 9 bracelet in the whole game on the True End path, so whether it was attached to Teruaki, or stolen from his corpse, the outcome would have been the same. (Especially since 9 doesn't make any impact on any digital roots, so if Teruaki was alive, they still could have all gone through the same door up until Gentarou kidnaps Lotus.)RedSwirl said:We still don't know that those men actually had to die for her to survive. Akane's first headache struck immediately upon seeing the 9th man's corpse. Those three men also didn't really have any impact on what went on.
Maybe Snake did have to disappear for most of the second half of the game but did that have to involve a murder? Maybe Junpey did have to find those items he did in the captain's quarters, but did he HAVE to find them on Cap's corpse? Furthermore, why bring someone like Ace there who they knew might try to sabotage the game? Why bring any of the four men there if they might try to do that? At least they could just have them locked away and then given to the authorities for their crimes after the time loop has been completed.
I guess that's the morally ambiguous part of the resolution for you then.
You'll notice that during the True End path, that's the only time she had a fever, so that was the only hitch in her pulling off her required time line successfully, and that it wasn't enough of a hiccup to render the scenario to be a failure. (Which results in her either dying or disappearing.)
Could there have been a situation that resulted in no one dying? It's possible, but Ace decided to take things into his own hands and kill his other three colleagues. And while that might not of been what Akane wanted, she was still able to close the loop and so she went forward. (Stopping wasn't really an option.)
As for why the Cradle execs had to be there, remember that in order for the Morphogenetic Field to work, the element of danger had to be present. Since I believe she wouldn't be comfortable with implanting bombs on innocent people, she had to have people there that were actually putting there lives on the line. And since Cradle had previously put herself in that same position, she retaliated and turned the tables on them. (While still giving them a chance to repent.) As she has access to all the information of the different possible scenarios, she saw that the only people that ever were at risk of having their "bombs" detonate were the Cradle execs. If she didn't actually plant a bomb in them and they broke the rules, then all the atmosphere of danger would be lost and Junpei wouldn't be able to tap into the Morphogenetic Field.
Akane had to cover her bases, and that involved putting their lives at risk. But as I said before, this was all an act of self defense. If Junpei wasn't at the incinerator with the feeling of a life or death situation intact, he wouldn't have been able to connect with young Akane. Do I think Akane is an innocent, gentle flower? No. But I don't think she's a murderer either. (Kidnapper though? Very much so.) But the very fact that she had a fever when Teruaki exploded is indicator enough to me that she didn't want/plan for him to die.
Personally, I think the events that happened in the True End are the only ones that actually happened in real life. I'm not a proponent of the alternate realities theory. I believe all the information that Akane transmitted to Junpei through the Morphogenetic Field was learned by her seeing the possible futures, not by experiencing them all together in tandem. So when they were doing the "real thing", she was trying to use all that she had learned to achieve the desired result. And while there was a least one mistake, (Teruaki going boom), she had to keep going or she was done for.