• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Adobe is suing Forever 21 for pirating Photoshop

Status
Not open for further replies.
Should've used Gimp.
It's exactly like Photoshop, but is free and totally shitty and impossible to figure out how to use why are there so many windows what the fuck
 
I know, I was remarking on why would you even need to pirate WinZip.

WinRar is the well known extractor that works forever but bothers you to death to buy a copy. No one has used Winzip in like 10 or 15 years and someone dumb enough to try surely wouldn't be able to track down a cracked copy.
 
WinRar is the well known extractor that works forever but bothers you to death to buy a copy. No one has used Winzip in like 10 or 15 years and someone dumb enough to try surely wouldn't be able to track down a cracked copy.

Ah, thanks. I was close, they both start with "Win", despite not being winners.
 
They should have used GIMP so that their artists could be confused, irritated and learn about how fun it is to see one application endure seven different crashes in one session. Meanwhile someone who has never used Photoshop could tell them it's identical to Photoshop while also insisting they should use the cmd line interface.

My man

brofistcover.jpg
 
So they bought licenses, found the means to abuse, got responses from the licensees, ignored them and now this.

Forever21 is shady so it is what it is.

maybe if you dont like how they price something they develop you should fuck off? they made it, they can price it however the fuck they please.
.

Unfortunately in this world and whether you like it or not, the options and means exist.
 
I don't know what's more surprising, 1/ that there are people who pirate WinZip, or 2/ that Corel actually makes money from WinZip (enough that they're actually going after Forever 21 for the loss of profit).
 
A more probably explanation is that IT people are simply lazy. When I was in the Army I was my unit's "computer guy" who was the intermediary between them and the S-6s aka the actual computer geeks and I know for a fact that half the software we used were pirated, especially while deployed. It wasn't a lack of $$, we got plenty of that (thanks tax payers <3) but when you have that many computers to take care of and a low chance of being caught well.. The actual people in charge probably didn't even know all the pirating was going on.
 
WinZip pirating?

Why would you need to even? Isn't that the extractor that you can use a trial version for as long as you want because even once the trial period is over you can keep using it but it tells you the trial is over?

You're thinking of WinRAR.

Not sure why ANYONE would need winzip actually... the functionality to zip and unzip files is built into both windows and OSX.
 
As part of my job, I handle a lot of people's laptops and computers. Whenever I warn them over the risk of data loss the first thing a good 80% of them they say is "does that mean my programmes will be lost". Not their pictures, or documents.

CAD Autodesk, Creative Suite, Microsoft Office etc.

So I ask myself... if they were legitimate copies would they be asking this question? Because yeah, I know it's a bit of a hassle to re-download and install it but the software vendors have made it as easy as they can.
 
pLle9Dc.gif

College student who purchased the academic version.
That was what I did. Although I don't know how to use it and I don't care about drawing anymore. I would say it was a waste of money but I have used it to make avatars and stuff and I've spent more on textbooks that I ended up hardly needing so oh well.
 
As part of my job, I handle a lot of people's laptops and computers. Whenever I warn them over the risk of data loss the first thing a good 80% of them they say is "does that mean my programmes will be lost". Not their pictures, or documents.

CAD Autodesk, Creative Suite, Microsoft Office etc.

So I ask myself... if they were legitimate copies would they be asking this question? Because yeah, I know it's a bit of a hassle to re-download and install it but the software vendors have made it as easy as they can.

It is also a PITA to set-up everything up again just the way you like it.
 
I love how it says they pirated Autodesk. Autodesk is a company, not a software title.

I did IT for a small company a few years ago. I ended up finding out that all the computers were running the same OEM version of Windows off one CD key. Not only that, but it was a pirated key. Same went for office.

To get them legit I was quoted $30,000. And they balked at the price.
 
When I was at college, every Windows 7 PC had the message on it "This is not a genuine copy of Windows. Please..." and I forget the rest. Probably something about registering a key.

We're talking thousands of computers.
 
Damn, id have jumped on that right away.
http://slickdeals.net/f/3977588-80-off-adobe-student-and-teacher-edition-software-acrobat-x-pro-24-photoshop-cs5-extended-40-creative-suite-5-5-master-collection-180-amp-more
Yeah it was a crazy day on slick deals when it was posted. It was the 5.5 version.
It was the Student/Teacher version, but as someone pointed out from the Adobe faq it can be used commercially.

From the FAQ [adobe.com]
"Can I use Student and Teacher Edition products commercially?
Yes, Student and Teacher Edition products can be used commercially."
 
Haha. Fuck them. I hope they lose the lawsuit.

I use Adobe, AutoCAD and Revit nearly every day in the office. Great software that deserves to be paid for.
 
I dont really think the IT Guys are in charge of these things nowadays. My dad is a systemadministrator and he has a budget and can buy things for his company.
But he told me nowadays companies try to save money on everything.

"Oh. You need this for work? Maybe we can buy it used somewhere."
"Your PC is broken? Maybe we still have another one in the basement from 10 years ago."
"You need this programm? It is on the server called WINRAR 5.xx Cracked exe.7zip"

I am the sole IT guy for my workplace and would not allow any cracked or illegal software on any of our managed computers.

People bringing in their own illegal software on their own computers and using them on our network is much more difficult to stop, however as soon as you get that letter from the company you know exactly who is doing it and you go and stop them.

This is probably a situation where someone needs photoshop etc but the company they work for is reluctant to pay for it. They have in turn took it upon themselves to use a cracked version.

IT budgets are shrinking every year and in general software gets more and more expensive so it's hardly shocking to see this happening.

Non IT people in a company don't see the merit in spending money on IT if everything is running smoothly. Only when things start going wrong will anyone notice the IT department has been lacking in funds for years. It's a catch 22 situation, if you run your department well people think you are doing nothing, if you run it badly people think you are constantly busy.
 
When I was at college, every Windows 7 PC had the message on it "This is not a genuine copy of Windows. Please..." and I forget the rest. Probably something about registering a key.

We're talking thousands of computers.

IT sounds like someone in the IT department fucked up the activation, when creating windows images to be rolled out to thousands of computers there are certain things you must do to prevent this issue.

It sounds like they have cloned the OS without removing certain info which would in turn make windows think that each computer is the same one and hundreds then fail activation.

Could have been a myriad of other issues as well but it's bad practice and something that in my last job I would never have got away with if I had made such a huge mistake in my job.
 
When I was at college, every Windows 7 PC had the message on it "This is not a genuine copy of Windows. Please..." and I forget the rest. Probably something about registering a key.

We're talking thousands of computers.
My girlfriend gets same message after I changed hard drive to her laptop and re-installed windows 7 using cd that was provided with laptop.
 
There are alternatives, but none have the combination of power, ease-of-use, plug-ins, and support that Photoshop combines. Hence, the asking price.

The things you listed shouldn't mean the price should go up. It means the price should go down. Some people, which you guys seem to be happy to ignore are not rich and can't afford to pay extortionate prices for software, yet to actually get anywhere in the world they need the software to work.
 
The funny thing to me is that if you're running any decent sized business Adobe's products in the creative cloud are now cheap as fuck in the grand scheme of things.

They're really quite reasonable. And because of the way they're priced, it's easy to make the case to your employer to get the full suite instead of just a handful.

Once you get Creative Cloud in your company's annual budget you're good to go. You'll never have to fight your boss to purchase CS upgrades again because you'll always have them.
 
That's a good point actually. It seems like the ubiquity of pirated Photoshop is what's preventing GIMP from taking hold so I guess it's working. You can't sue your way to that kind of mindshare amongst hobbyist creatives.

Yep, that's how Adobe gets to have their cake and eat it too.

Making their software affordable for hobbyists would hurt their enterprise revenue while hunting down non-enterprise pirates would increase demand for cheaper/free alternatives and the likelihood of said alternatives becoming viable for enterprises.
 
Photoshop must be the most pirated software out there for hobbyists just indulging in casual design every now and then. I've never really understood why Adobe hasn't attempted to capitalize on legitimizing that demographic by just offering outdated legacy versions at a steep discount. The subscription model is terrible value for someone that'd use it maybe once every two weeks just to make a meme image or forum signature or whatever.

I seem to recall Gabe Newell actually talking to Adobe about this and potentially putting their products on Steam, and he thought they were out of touch with reality.
 
Adobe's subscription based software is annoying. Luckily I managed to purchase an older and quite capable version. We need better alternatives to Adobes Suites.

Forever 21 slipped up and got caught. Ha!
 
I tanked a a Fedex Office (Kinkos then) interview years ago, and one of the interview questions was, "How familiar are you with Photoshop?" I explained I had used it for school, church, and family and friends projects, mostly self taught.

She then asked how I was able to pay for it on my own as I was still in school and young. My dumbass said "Oh, I just downloaded it off the internet."

Needless to say didn't get the job.
 
Start charging thousands of dollars for college education and govt can tell you to fuck off? Right?

Everyone was born with a gold spoon in hand?

Don't like something, fuck off? Fuck off from this country as well? That's the solution?

How old are you?

You have to be born with a "gold spoon in hand" to afford Photoshop? When you're a huge company like Forever 21?

If nothing else, Adobe has done a great job making Photoshop pretty affordable, I think. Especially for students.
 
The things you listed shouldn't mean the price should go up. It means the price should go down. Some people, which you guys seem to be happy to ignore are not rich and can't afford to pay extortionate prices for software, yet to actually get anywhere in the world they need the software to work.

You can get Photoshop + Lightroom for $9.99 a month.
 
The Autodesk programs are crazy expensive. 3DS Max alone will cost you ~$1500 per year for one license. I'm not sure why they would need that kind of stuff, though. Maybe they were using it to design floor displays or something.
 
Adobe's subscription models sucks, but it absolutely brilliant in its execution. For one, they continue to slowly roll out new features, so that every new update is more akin to an expansion pack than a bug squash. So, even if I wanted to stop my CC subscription and buy CS6, I'd be buying a gimped version of most of the products. And I use Photoshop, Bridge, Muse and Lightroom just about every single day.

I didn't start out this way, but unless I change careers entirely, I'm Abode's cabana boy for the foreseeable future. They're on a level of evil infiltration into their niche that nobody can really touch.
 
... he's saying that if you make that much money why the fuck are you pirating.


I'f love to see how their legit adoption rates have been since the ÂŁ8.50 Lightroom & Photoshop CC bundle they started a year ago. I'd love to be able to add Premier to that for a few quid.
Oh ok my bad. I was tired.
 
a professional photographer that I interned for during college actually owned pirated copies of PS and all sorts of photo editing software. it was pretty pathetic. if you use it for professional work, buy the damn software.
 
They're really quite reasonable. And because of the way they're priced, it's easy to make the case to your employer to get the full suite instead of just a handful.

Once you get Creative Cloud in your company's annual budget you're good to go. You'll never have to fight your boss to purchase CS upgrades again because you'll always have them.

That's what's brilliant about it. You argue for something you legit need, and then it's just there in the budget forever. You don't have to bring it up every year or upgrade and make a case that somehow this small feature will totally be used.

Plus having the whole suite is so nice for a designer in a smaller business. They can branch out and try different things. The business can experiment with something and not have to pay thousands for that program to maybe do a one-off video or whatever it is. You already have it.

And as I said, 50 bucks a month is like nothing unless your business is really really tiny.
 
Adobe's subscription models sucks, but it absolutely brilliant in its execution. For one, they continue to slowly roll out new features, so that every new update is more akin to an expansion pack than a bug squash. So, even if I wanted to stop my CC subscription and buy CS6, I'd be buying a gimped version of most of the products. And I use Photoshop, Bridge, Muse and Lightroom just about every single day.

I didn't start out this way, but unless I change careers entirely, I'm Abode's cabana boy for the foreseeable future. They're on a level of evil infiltration into their niche that nobody can really touch.

It's actually quite the opposite, because of the subscription model they can squash bugs way more easily than before, just because every update doesn't have to have a new killer feature like during the CS era.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom