• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Ars Technica: Retail Patapon 2 IS UMD-free

Blu_LED said:
Exactly. I find it funny that Locoroco is $22.99 on PSN, but Locoroco 2 retails in stores for $19.99. It makes absolutely no sense.

Similarly, GT5P was on PSN for £24.99 for the longest time, whereas you could purchase it from numerous retail stores from release for just £19.99. £5 more for no physical copy, no nice art, case, booklet, HD video content on the disk etc...

And the other "crazie" thing about not being served by a human or helping out the retail channel.
 
Tiktaalik said:
That's a bit of a contrived scenario don't you think? If a family is poor enough to not have internet how on earth is the kid getting a PSP and games? More and more this scenario just seems unbelievably unlikely.

Due to their limited use, memory sticks are still mildly expensive, but mass market media such as flash drives are getting unbelievably cheap, I bought an 8 gig one yesterday for C$20. If the PSP switched to using memory sticks much more heavily, they'd become much more mass market and drop in price even further.

That's quite an assumption you're making don't you think? Not having the internet is not the same as not being able to afford it. Plus what if a random poor kid gets a gift from someone not as poor?

Also, just because someone has a wireless network set up, doesn't mean they automatically want to give their kid full access so they can log in and get into the store. Even if they did, that's still an added process to go through to play the game you just bought. Same with getting onto a pc, and using the store interface there.

Yes, memory sticks are relatively cheap, but they're not free.

My point is that if you get a box that just has a coupon in it, it's a little misleading that you'll automatically be able to play when you get home and open it.
 
The part of digital distribution that worries me the most is the fact that I might not be able to play those games in the future. I still play some NES games from time to time, that stuff is over 15 years old now. How do I know that the servers to download those games will still be online in 15 years?

When the system breaks or your account is damaged everything is gone. You could argue that if a CD/DVD/Cartridge breaks you have the same problem, but that would just be a single game or a system that could be easily replaced. Both are connected when it comes to DLC, so when your system breaks your games are gone too. Maybe not today or tommorow but in four to five years I doubt that these companies would bother to replace your downloads, let alone 15 years.
 
nib95 said:
Similarly, GT5P was on PSN for £24.99 for the longest time, whereas you could purchase it from numerous retail stores from release for just £19.99. £5 more for no physical copy, no nice art, case, booklet, HD video content on the disk etc...

And the other "crazie" thing about not being served by a human or helping out the retail channel.

So you listen to music on cds? And refuse to use Netflix or Redbox? Or do you just go to the movies, since that would technically be the most humans employed per viewing?
 
[Nintex] said:
The part of digital distribution that worries me the most is the fact that I might not be able to play those games in the future. I still play some NES games from time to time, that stuff is over 15 years old now. How do I know that the servers to download those games will still be online in 15 years?

When the system breaks or your account is damaged everything is gone. You could argue that if a CD/DVD/Cartridge breaks you have the same problem, but that would just be a single game or a system that could be easily replaced. Both are connected when it comes to DLC, so when your system breaks your games are gone too. Maybe not today or tommorow but in four to five years I doubt that these companies would bother to replace your downloads, let alone 15 years.


you back them up to your PC like you do with your app store applications, or itunes purchases.
 
mrklaw said:
One billion app store downloads. In ten months. On a userbase probably smaller than the current PSP installed base.

Suggests DD is a workable solution.


And how many of those apps were priced at $30-$40 like PSP games?
 
rainking187 said:
And how many of those apps were priced at $30-$40 like PSP games?

And who says all PSP games will continue to be $30-$40 dollars? The ratio of smaller games will increase dramatically.
 
shattyboombatty said:
That's quite an assumption you're making don't you think? Not having the internet is not the same as not being able to afford it. Plus what if a random poor kid gets a gift from someone not as poor?

Also, just because someone has a wireless network set up, doesn't mean they automatically want to give their kid full access so they can log in and get into the store. Even if they did, that's still an added process to go through to play the game you just bought. Same with getting onto a pc, and using the store interface there.

Yes, memory sticks are relatively cheap, but they're not free.

My point is that if you get a box that just has a coupon in it, it's a little misleading that you'll automatically be able to play when you get home and open it.

That situation is not really any different than if someone gave you an SNES game when you had a Genesis.
 
rainking187 said:
And how many of those apps were priced at $30-$40 like PSP games?


doesn't matter. It means DD is viable. That takes millions of people to go online with their iphones and ipod touches. How many PSN users are there? How many Xbox live users downloading demos? How many Steam users for that matter?

You don't need a retail store anymore for software.
 
Tiktaalik said:
That situation is not really any different than if someone gave you an SNES game when you had a Genesis.


Soccer Mom: "Do you guys have Mario Kart for the Playstation?"
 
YagizY said:
The biggest gap in reasoning for NeoGaf and the claim that the new PSP will have no UMD drive is that I think people are forgetting about the current PSP library. What happens to all the old games? Do you guys think that Sony will come out with the PSP-4000 and it only have the ability to play games on the PSN service? Does everyone wait while Sony attempts to put all the old PSP games onto PSN (you'll be waiting a long time if their rate of PS1 games on PSN is any indication)?

This week's UK top 40 said:
1 1 WII FIT WII NINTENDO NINTENDO
- 2 THE GODFATHER II XB360 EA GAMES ELECTRONIC ARTS
15 3 MARIO & SONIC AT THE OLYMPIC GAMES WII SEGA SEGA
- 4 THE GODFATHER II PS3 EA GAMES ELECTRONIC ARTS
3 5 PROFESSOR LAYTON AND THE CURIOUS VILLAGE DS NINTENDO NINTENDO
8 6 WII PLAY WII NINTENDO NINTENDO
5 7 MARIO KART WII WII NINTENDO NINTENDO
2 8 RESIDENT EVIL 5 XB360 CAPCOM CAPCOM
7 9 DR KAWASHIMA'S BRAIN TRAINING DS NINTENDO NINTENDO
13 10 CLUB PENGUIN: ELITE PENGUIN FORCE DS DISNEY INTERACTIVE STUDIOS DISNEY INTERACTIVE STUDIOS
4 11 GRAND THEFT AUTO: CHINATOWN WARS DS ROCKSTAR TAKE 2
6 12 RESIDENT EVIL 5 PS3 CAPCOM CAPCOM
32 13 RAYMAN RAVING RABBIDS TV PARTY WII UBISOFT UBISOFT
10 14 MY FITNESS COACH WII GAMES FOR EVERYONE UBISOFT
12 15 STREET FIGHTER IV PS3 CAPCOM CAPCOM
14 16 KILLZONE 2 PS3 SONY COMPUTER ENT. SONY COMPUTER ENT.
25 17 NEW SUPER MARIO BROS. DS NINTENDO NINTENDO
23 18 MARIO KART DS DS NINTENDO NINTENDO
9 19 WHEELMAN XB360 MIDWAY UBISOFT
11 20 CALL OF DUTY 4: MODERN WARFARE XB360 ACTIVISION ACTIVISION BLIZZARD
24 21 FIFA 09 XB360 EA SPORTS ELECTRONIC ARTS
21 22 CALL OF DUTY: WORLD AT WAR XB360 ACTIVISION ACTIVISION BLIZZARD
19 23 PUZZLER COLLECTION DS GAMES FOR EVERYONE UBISOFT
20 24 WANTED: WEAPONS OF FATE XB360 WARNER BROS. INTERACTIVE WARNER BROS. INTERACTIVE
17 25 WHEELMAN PS3 MIDWAY UBISOFT
18 26 STREET FIGHTER IV XB360 CAPCOM CAPCOM
16 27 CARNIVAL: FUNFAIR GAMES DS 2KPLAY TAKE 2
34 28 TOM CLANCY'S H.A.W.X. PS3 UBISOFT UBISOFT
33 29 CARNIVAL: FUNFAIR GAMES WII 2KPLAY TAKE 2
28 30 MARIO & SONIC AT THE OLYMPIC GAMES DS SEGA SEGA
- 31 KUNG FU PANDA XB360 ACTIVISION ACTIVISION BLIZZARD
27 32 SONIC AND THE BLACK KNIGHT WII SEGA SEGA
- 33 MYSTERY CASE FILES: MILLIONHEIR DS NINTENDO NINTENDO
- 34 LEGO INDIANA JONES: ORIGINAL ADVENTURES XB360 LUCASARTS LUCASARTS
38 35 CALL OF DUTY 4: MODERN WARFARE PS3 ACTIVISION ACTIVISION BLIZZARD
35 36 TOM CLANCY'S H.A.W.X. XB360 UBISOFT UBISOFT
30 37 GRAND THEFT AUTO IV XB360 ROCKSTAR TAKE 2
- 38 GEARS OF WAR 2 XB360 MICROSOFT MICROSOFT
22 39 SCRABBLE INTERACTIVE: 2009 EDITION DS GAMES FOR EVERYONE UBISOFT
- 40 GUITAR HERO: WORLD TOUR WII REDOCTANE ACTIVISION BLIZZARD

Notice what's missing?
Hint: Control + F "PSP"

Sony doesn't give a fuck about the current PSP library, because PSP users (outside of Japan) aren't buying games. That's why the re-launch is corresponding to a re-launch of sorts of Western 3rd party support.
 
Sho_Nuff82 said:
Notice what's missing?
Hint: Control + F "PSP"

Sony doesn't give a fuck about the current PSP library, because PSP users (outside of Japan) aren't buying games. That's why the re-launch is corresponding to a re-launch of sorts of Western 3rd party support.

If you think that DD is going to push games into that list you are crazy.
 
Tobor said:
So you listen to music on cds? And refuse to use Netflix or Redbox? Or do you just go to the movies, since that would technically be the most humans employed per viewing?
I rip my CDs and listen to MP3s like everyone else, but I have complete control of my MP3s. I can put them on any number of devices or computers or web services, I can burn them to disc for archiving or whatever I want. How could I do any of those things if I purchase a DD version of Patapon 2? And what if in 30 years I want to show my grandkids how awesome the game was but the PSN has turned into the next Sega Channel?
 
I'm guessing that next gen, the psp2 will be DD only, and the PS4,720,DS2 will have DD of games day one as retail.
 
YagizY said:
If you think that DD is going to push games into that list you are crazy.

It won't (they won't be tracked).

But it's certainly a better business model than sending every game not named Final Fantasy/GTA/God of War to die, and it offers more potential for PSP developers to profit as they aren't sharing a cut with Gamestop/Amazon/TRU.
 
kenta said:
I rip my CDs and listen to MP3s like everyone else, but I have complete control of my MP3s. I can put them on any number of devices or computers or web services, I can burn them to disc for archiving or whatever I want. How could I do any of those things if I purchase a DD version of Patapon 2? And what if in 30 years I want to show my grandkids how awesome the game was but the PSN has turned into the next Sega Channel?

Your grand kids don't want to see your shitty old games, don't worry about it.

My Dad hooked up his 8-track for the first time in 30 years not long ago. The tapes all started snapping from age. Why didn't anyone tell him he was only renting those tapes, not buying them!!!111!!!!
 
YagizY said:
If you think that DD is going to push games into that list you are crazy.

That list itself is 'retail', so doesn't include DD.

I'm flabbergasted by the move, since this is something Nintendo won't be copying (yet), but it's still inevitable. That said, when Nintendo does go DD-only and piss off all their retail base, call me.
 
there better be a physical copy. Im still one of those "dinosaurs" who likes to hold a hard copy of a game in my hand. PSN downloads for PSP usually force you to upgrade to the latest firmware, and as a person who uses CFW alot, thats a route I dont want to deal with
 
Tobor said:
Your grand kids don't want to see your shitty old games, don't worry about it.
So that's it? I win? Thought you guys would have put up more of a fight considering how the thread's going
 
kenta said:
I rip my CDs and listen to MP3s like everyone else, but I have complete control of my MP3s. I can put them on any number of devices or computers or web services, I can burn them to disc for archiving or whatever I want. How could I do any of those things if I purchase a DD version of Patapon 2? And what if in 30 years I want to show my grandkids how awesome the game was but the PSN has turned into the next Sega Channel?
you can, just back it up on your comp/burn it on a disk/upload it to what ever site you want. DD is more secure then a disc, I'm sure you scratching or losing your disc is much more likely then sony shutting down psn
 
This is a given, it's going to happen sooner rather than later with the big 3.

What bothers me is this:

1) I don't think we're going to save any money. I see no evidence that now or in the long run we're going to see significantly reduced prices because the "middleman" has been cut out.

2) I like being able to resell items I don't like or am not using any longer. That's gone. That changes ownership significantly, and it is like renting.

3) I don't trust the big 3 (as opposed to the Steam situation where the Windows architecture stays similar) to keep my purchases available or playable to me in the future. The 360 has spotty to crap back library compatibility, the PS3 has taken a dump on arguably the best back catalog of all time, Nintendo just looks for ways to sell me the same games again and again.

4) Outside of Microsoft, I see no real mandate to offer us demos before making digital purchases.

I'm not trying to be debbie downer either, I like the convenience, I hate GameStop, etc. But it's going to change a lot of gaming ownership issues for the worse.
 
Tobor said:
So you listen to music on cds? And refuse to use Netflix or Redbox? Or do you just go to the movies, since that would technically be the most humans employed per viewing?

Music, I'm about 50/50. I prefer to buy the best stuff on CD just for the quality and CD art etc. Though I do often burn over to my HDD using LAME MP3 variable 320kbps or FLAC (lossless) (for use with my Shure SE530 headphones). I always draw a line of difference with music though, since tracks are infinitely shorter and smaller. I wouldn't need 50 games on my portable/console system (I only really ever play 2-3 games at any one time) but I might have 100+ songs on my MP3 player and listen to any one of them.

I currently don't use Netflix or Redbox (watch TV/BBCi instead). In regards to movies, yes, I have an Unlimited Cineworld Cinema card (£11 a month) and buy/rent DVD's/Blu-ray from retail stores (better quality that way too). I'll often buy online, but most times you can get similar deals in certain retail stores if you look around. Gamestations recent Blu-ray's for £10 retail offer for example.

Don't get me wrong, I won't exclusively shop retail, but most times I prefer/try to. If the price is right. But retail/etail is one thing, DD is different, since the physical medium itself is lost. I'd always want hard copies of my games. Not only is it good for the re-sale market, but sharing, lending, gifts wise, convienience outside of personal use and all the rest. It's just easier and imo safer. Gives companies less chances to screw us around. It also gives me more control over my own content.
 
kenta said:
So that's it? I win? Thought you guys would have put up more of a fight considering how the thread's going

Read my edit. But yeah, basically that's it. We are entering an age of universal information and access. My honest answer, if Patapon 2 is interesting to your grandkids, they will play it on their brain implant chips.

And judging from your stance on this issue, and the obvious realities ahead, you lose.
 
Memory sticks are still too expensive to make DD viable for handhelds. I'm assuming the next PSP will have AT LEAST 2gigs internal memory or come with a stick at no extra cost. Or, if you want me to pay $40 for a 4 gig stick, make all games $15-20..this means God of War, Crisis Core, all triple A titles since they no longer have box/manual/disc costs.
 
Guled said:
you can, just back it up on your comp/burn it on a disk/upload it to what ever site you want. DD is more secure then a disc, I'm sure you scratching or losing your disc is much more likely then sony shutting down psn
So, in order to combat piracy, Sony is going to have me digitally download an ISO which I can then distribute freely? You're saying they're just saving pirates time by ripping the ISO for them?

But let's say you're right, if Sony has me just download a simple ISO onto my PSP and I can get it off by just plugging my PSP into my PC, then that works for the PSP method. But what about the DD games I bought on my PS3? Same situation, how do I have control of them? In another 5 years I will have needed to delete some older PSN games from my PS3 to make room for new ones, but in 30 years if I'm feeling nostalgic and want to play Wipeout HD and PSN is the new Sega Channel, what do I do?
 
I am all for every game on a system being available as a digital download, but I also would like to see retail disc/cartridge SKUs remain. There are definitely enough people who lack the ability to download games or like to collect their games to make this viable. As for new systems in the future and people like me holding back systems with no disc drives, I would be quite happy to pay a premium for a system that had a drive over one that did not.
 
kenta said:
So, in order to combat piracy, Sony is going to have me digitally download an ISO which I can then distribute freely? You're saying they're just saving pirates time by ripping the ISO for them?

But let's say you're right, if Sony has me just download a simple ISO onto my PSP and I can get it off by just plugging my PSP into my PC, then that works for the PSP method. But what about the DD games I bought on my PS3? Same situation, how do I have control of them? In another 5 years I will have needed to delete some older PSN games from my PS3 to make room for new ones, but in 30 years if I'm feeling nostalgic and want to play Wipeout HD and PSN is the new Sega Channel, what do I do?
you can only play them on the system your account is activated on. In the second situation your sol, but if sony were to shut down psn, why not just get a bigger harddrive for your ps3 and download your games on it before it goes down. Its not like they take up a ton of space. A digital copy of a game is much more secure then a physical copy. I'm sure there is a much greater chance of your disc breaking then PSN becoming the new Sega channel
 
kenta said:
but in 30 years if I'm feeling nostalgic and want to play Wipeout HD and PSN is the new Sega Channel, what do I do?

play one of your blu-ray disc games that has lasted for 30 years on your ps3's 30 year old but still working blu-ray drive?

i too lament the fact that i likely won't be able to play my ps3 games in 30 years time, whereas i imagine my n64 will still be working (although probably sans compatible display by then anyway...). but to make out that DD is going to completely destroy this is silly, because really its already like that anyway. sure it doesnt help but there are plenty of other things to worry about if you go looking.

how about playing 360 games in 30 years time? think microsoft will fix your RROD then?
 
nib95 said:
I'd always want hard copies of my games. Not only is it good for the re-sale market, but sharing, lending, gifts wise, convienience outside of personal use and all the rest. It's just easier and imo safer. Gives companies less chances to screw us around. It also gives me more control over my own content.

I completely agree, well said.

This isn't a trend I welcome at all. Granted, I've stepped my toes into the pool with iPhone purchases, but I would have gladly paid more if hard copy option were available/possible on the platform.
 
Tobor said:
But yeah, basically that's it. We are entering an age of universal information and access.

So why am I getting those error messages when I try to download something off the US video marketplace at Microsoft (Sony is hiding that entire section from me), that's why I can't watch some stuff like TV shows that are availble for free on the internet from outside the US, that's why can't watch certain clips on Youtube, that's why can't download many of the iPhone games some people are raving about? The "universal" angle you champion doesn't exist for many people.

And the "we're getting there" excuse doesn't cut it if Sony plans to release a dl only device this year and they want me to buy it.
 
Guled said:
you can only play them on the system your account is activated on. In the secound situation your sol, but if sony were to shut down psn, why not just get a bigger harddrive for your ps3 and download your games on it before it goes down. Its not like they take up a ton of space
To your first response: Again, that means nothing if the PSN is non-existent in 30 years. Can't activate my account on the PSP, can't play the game even if I have it backed up

To your second response: You're saying the burden is now on ME to buy a bigger hard drive at comparatively exponential price and archive this stuff on my own? As opposed to letting me purchase a physical copy of the game in the first place?
panda21 said:
how about playing 360 games in 30 years time? think microsoft will fix your RROD then?
You're talking about hardware, that debate is nothing new to people who own Atari 2600s and NESes and heck, even original PlayStations. Being inconvenienced into buying a working system off of eBay is one thing, being 100% categorically unable to play games with no alternate course of action because a service shut down is something different
 
Tiktaalik said:
That situation is not really any different than if someone gave you an SNES game when you had a Genesis.

Seriously?

the difference is you're buying a psp game for your psp... which may require buying additional hardware (mspd) and services(internet) to play it. If the aditional hardware you're getting is an entirely different system, you're doing something wrong.
 
I prefer physical copies for games but I agree this was inevitable. The retail box, while lame, is to throw a bone to Gamestop so they don't raise a stink over it. I wonder how long before they get cut out of the picture on some games. It already technically happened with Siren, can't see why it wouldn't for games with smaller budgets.
 
kenta said:
To your first response: Again, that means nothing if the PSN is non-existent in 30 years. Can't activate my account on the PSP, can't play the game even if I have it backed up

To your second response: You're saying the burden is now on ME to buy a bigger hard drive at comparatively exponential price and archive this stuff on my own? As opposed to letting me purchase a physical copy of the game in the first place?
You're talking about hardware, that debate is nothing new to people who own Atari 2600s and NESes and heck, even original PlayStations. Being inconvenienced into buying a working system off of eBay is one thing, being 100% categorically unable to play games with no alternate course of action because a service shut down is something different
1) if you keep your old games, surly you still keep around your own consoles

2) a harddrive is not that much, it will be even less expensive in the future if this were to happen. Plus keeping physical copies have a cost (cd cleaner, shelves)

if you have the console you will still be able to play the games 30 years from now.
 
The only thing that bothers me is I feel like so many MORE games could be on PSN yet aren't, and I'm left wondering WTF not?

Plus there's a bunch of fucking puzzle games now thanks to DD, I want some damn decent RPG.
 
Guled said:
1) if you keep your old games, surly you still keep around your own consoles

2) a harddrive is not that much, it will be even less expensive in the future if this were to happen. Plus keeping physical copies have a cost (cd cleaner, shelves)

if you have the console you will still be able to play the games 30 years from now.
1. You're assuming things. I just found a stash of old NES games in my attic a couple months ago but there was no sign of the actual NES. My mom must have done something with it over the years, or heck maybe I lent it to a friend when I was well into the SNES era and never got it back, who knows. There are millions of variables that could cause someone to keep games around without a console, or keep consoles around without the games.

2. There's no way you're going to convince me to spend any money whatsoever on a hard drive and go through the hassle of backing up my DD-purchased games when the alternative is simply letting me purchase physical copies of the games in the first place. There is no way, that's not an acceptable solution
 
Musashi Wins! said:
This is a given, it's going to happen sooner rather than later with the big 3.

What bothers me is this:

1) I don't think we're going to save any money. I see no evidence that now or in the long run we're going to see significantly reduced prices because the "middleman" has been cut out.

2) I like being able to resell items I don't like or am not using any longer. That's gone. That changes ownership significantly, and it is like renting.

3) I don't trust the big 3 (as opposed to the Steam situation where the Windows architecture stays similar) to keep my purchases available or playable to me in the future. The 360 has spotty to crap back library compatibility, the PS3 has taken a dump on arguably the best back catalog of all time, Nintendo just looks for ways to sell me the same games again and again.

4) Outside of Microsoft, I see no real mandate to offer us demos before making digital purchases.

I'm not trying to be debbie downer either, I like the convenience, I hate GameStop, etc. But it's going to change a lot of gaming ownership issues for the worse.

This hits the nail on the head for me.
 
i'm beginning to see a pattern here

if you actually intend to attempt to maintain a working ps3/psp (or dare i say it 360) for the rest of your life then good luck with that...

in actuality i doubt any of you will, and are just pissed about a challenge to your delusion :lol

(not trying to be rude to anyone who actually makes the effort to collect games/systems, i just think the majority of people complaining 'oh what will i do when psn is dead!!!' are forgetting that their ps3 will break sooner or later anyway and chances are they won't bother hunting a down a surviving one on ebay...)
 
http://arstechnica.com/gaming/news/...less-even-in-retail-stores-new-sony-trend.ars

Update: Sony has just confirmed the story with a statement to Ars Technica. The statement reads:

"We're considering a digital only format for the Patapon 2 release as a one time test case as we continue to explore consumer preferences for digital content," Patrick Seybold, Senior Director of Corporate Communications at SCEA said. "The downloadable game will be available on May 5th at both retail and via the PlayStation Store. We remain focused on providing superior games and entertainment experiences in both the UMD and digital formats and are working closely with our partners to deliver the best PSP line up in our history."
 
Top Bottom