• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Bar soap or body wash

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually it's the truth. Bacteria very rarely exists on a bar of soap. It exists in the bubbly/slime that may be on your soap dish, holder, or on the surface itself if someone just showered, but a quick rinse under your shower water and it's literally gone. It's just too inhospitable of an environment, especially if it dries completely before the next use. Several studies have been done where researchers even put E. Coli, and other bacteria on soap and told people to wash their hands with it. None of them tested for any trace of the bacteria on their hands. Definitely some false fear mongering going on. Whereas, bacteria love and cling to plastic surfaces. No matter how well you rinse your loofah or scrubber, there are still dead skin cells and organisms growing as it dries in a humid environment. The very next time you use it, you're just spreading it all over your body. That same bacteria is also what starts to degrade the plastic itself. Ever seen your loofah start to get thinner or ragged if you don't throw out? It's not just because you use it all the time.

People recommend replacing loofahs and scrubbers routinely, either bleaching it, microwaving it. Think about how wasteful they are made of plastic or rubber components. Think of all the people who don't recycle their body wash cartons that they probably go through every 3 weeks or a month if they are using it daily.

Now there is nothing wrong with body wash. But to say it has any clear benefits over a quality bar of soap are negligible in terms of actual cleaning. We came from living in caves and jungles, never bathing, and now some people are worried that because they washed their balls with a bar of soap, they're going to die the next time they use it.

Google it yourselves as well, bacteria on a bar of soap, bacteria on loofahs, scrubbers, etc. If you use just your hands to apply body wash, great, but wouldn't the bar of soap be better then? Same cleaning ability if you get quality bars, but not only will they last longer, but because it's a tangible item beyond your hand, you can actually scrub better.

jENRrEi.png
You know your stuff ! Which bar soap you use?
 
Have used body wash for as long as I can remember, I think I prefer it. That said, I'm almost out and one of my friends makes soap now and gifted me a couple bars. I think I might try to use those up before buying any new body wash. I've been alternating and it isn't bad, the bar I'm currently using was made using only goat milk, olive oil, coconut oil, lard, lye, grapeseed oil, and honeysuckle essential oil. It's pretty nice and smells amazing.
 
Bar of olive oil soap. Cheap as fuck. Lasts. Is great for my skin. Ecological as fuck. And it washes off easily in contrast to every body wash I've ever used that leave my skin feeling slimy.
 
Bar soap. Seems more efficient. Not a fan of all the moisturiser in liquid soap. Takes more time, water, and money. All that marketing into liquid soap has made it more expensive and so bar soap is just way cheaper. Also, greener. At least I'm not using any of that antibacterial triclosan soap crap.
1) The average body wash is more chemically loaded than the average bar soap. It's one thing to use chemicals to clean your body; it's another to use chemicals that only serve to create cute ribbon patterns in the bottle and bright colors.

2) Body wash tends to be more expensive.

3) Body wash is incredibly wasteful. To saturate a loufa with body wash requires way more of the stuff than you'll actually be using to clean your body.

You're also forgetting the sheer fact that the plastic bottles of body wash are rarely ever recycled like water bottles or soda bottles are. Impacts the environment far more than a simple bar of quality soap. Plus, a loofah or scrubber also retains more bacteria than a bar of soap ever could.

Make this point five and six. Leaving me:

7) Liquid soaps uses up more water than a quality soap bar.
8) Liquid soaps are generally bigger and have clunkier packaging so they pollute more under transport.
9) Bar soaps are usually longer lasting
10) If you really think bacteria growth is a problem you can run it trough a cheese garter and it will never have to get wet.

This said I'm still on liquid soap, but I will get onto point 10 and get grinding, or whatever verb is used with a cheese garter, in the near future. Just gotta get over to Lush first.

Edit: About point 8, lush soaps are generally big and clunky. But apply it to rectangular shaped soap bars.
Good points, too.
 
Every bar soap I used makes my skin feel rubbery, like the sensation of your hand squeaking on a balloon, or warm pepsi on your teeth. Can't stand that feeling, so I use body wash
 
Liquid soaps, I tend to fine the bathtub gets dirty faster using bar soap then when using liquid gel. Thank and the bar soap dries out my skin and I find doesn't work as much.
 
Only the last two or three years I've started using body wash with a loofah as I was originally a bar soap person because that's how I was brought up at home to use.
 
While I'm certain that liquid body-wash is a marketing ploy to get people to spend more money on soap than is necessary, once I made the switch from bar soap, I haven't looked back. It's just so convenient.
 
That lush stuff is eight bucks for a 3.5 oz cake. I'd like to be more environmentally conscious and everything but I've got a budget for everything. Can I expect one of those bars to last me longer than the 17oz bottles of goo hanging in my shower caddy (at least five weeks of daily showering)?
 
Bar soap of course. Body only, have a special scrub for my face (you're not even supposed to use soap on facial skin).

Do you shower gel users who think bar soap is so gross also use a loofa or shower rag with your liquid soap or whatever they are called to clean your ass then wipe it all over your body? >_< You know bar soap rinses off clean right?
 
Bar soap with a wash cloth.

Switched away from liquid soap and would never go back.
 
Old Spice Dry Skin Defense body wash for me.
 
Dove Men+ bar soap. I used to use the liquid variety but it would leave my skin very oily.
 
Bar soap of course. Body only, have a special scrub for my face (you're not even supposed to use soap on facial skin).

Do you shower gel users who think bar soap is so gross also use a loofa or shower rag with your liquid soap or whatever they are called to clean your ass then wipe it all over your body? >_< You know bar soap rinses off clean right?

And those loofah or shower rags probably suck in all that stuff more so it's there forever eww :P
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom