I’m play Uncharted Lost Legacy and I’m having a ton of fun. It’s a real joy to play and I like the tone, feels like Indiana Jones, nice characters too, Chloe is so far from a boring toned down 2022 creation, I really like the open driving map too, pleasant surprise all around for me. Still looks amazing.
So from that perspective I would say Naughty Dog is the best.
BUT…. Lost Legacy is an old game now. The current dark mode ND is not my thing at all. Not sure if the same writers are there anymore and I read somewhere that Druckmann wanted to kill off Elena for some reason and we all know what happened in TLOU. I don’t know, they’ve started walking a path I can’t walk, I don’t need more darkness in my life.
And I’ve still not finished a single FROM game.
So I’m going with Insomniac. Ratchet was awesome, #3 for me last year, best localization ever too, voice-acted to perfection in swedish, loved it from start to finish, played it with the kids beside me and it was very likely the best family play-throughs I’ve ever done. Amazing dev!