-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Best Halo campaign level? The Ark.
- Thread starter StoppedInTracks
- Start date
Spartan+Shotty+Flood= Good Times
Long Drong
Member
I want to share some love for Exodus on Reach.
Urban combat with jetpacks, and love how you can sneak the ending.
Urban combat with jetpacks, and love how you can sneak the ending.
PooBone
Member
Hard to argue with anything you're saying here. Nothing in ODST or Reach are as good as anything in 1 or 3. ODST has some really cool and different atmosphere though.What is the best Halo campaign level ever created?
IMO it is The Ark from Halo 3. The Ark takes everything that was near perfect from Halo 1 levels (Silent Cartographer) and Halo 2 levels (the Scarab fight) and mixes it into one perfect journey. Like any worth Halo level it has everything within it:
- open areas
- long range tank fights
- close quarters
- escape part
- boss fight (Scarab)
- the most beautiful vistas since Halo 1
- a desert setting which usually is quite boring but some games nail the fuck out of it (Uncharted 3 comes to mind). For some reason it works so well in this level.
- Hunters
If I were to sell the whole Halo universe with one level, if I have to force a person that doesn't know what Halo is to play one level it would had to be The Ark.
Note: finished H1, H2, H3, 30% H4 (boring levels). Did not play Reach or ODST. Are there any quality levels in Reach/ ODST? Better than H1 and H3 ones?
My favorite level always has been and remains: Halo from Halo CE. When the game opens up, you had this freeform battle going on with dropships all around you, and THEN they give you a warthog and let you go tackle more groups of enemies in any order..... it seriously blew my mind the first time I played it, especially because I was playing co-op. That hog became a rolling death machine. It quickly cemented my love for the game.
EDIT: I forget which level from Halo 4 I'm thinking of, but the one with the Elephant is legitimately awesome.
PooBone
Member
Halo, Truth and Reconciliation, Silent Cartographer, AotCR, 343 GS, Two Betrayals, The Maw... all fantastic maps on Halo CE.
Outskirts/Metropolis and Delta Halo are really the only ones I enjoyed in H2. The one where the covenant splits is kinda fun too.
The Ark and The Covenant are fantastic on H3.
Halo 4 was decent but nothing too memorable.
Halo Reach was pretty complete IMO. I really enjoyed that campaign. Halo ODST was very MEH aside from Rain which fit perfectly with that map setting.
Outskirts/Metropolis and Delta Halo are really the only ones I enjoyed in H2. The one where the covenant splits is kinda fun too.
The Ark and The Covenant are fantastic on H3.
Halo 4 was decent but nothing too memorable.
Halo Reach was pretty complete IMO. I really enjoyed that campaign. Halo ODST was very MEH aside from Rain which fit perfectly with that map setting.
This is, of course, true.
My faves have been Silent Cartographer, Assault on the Control Room, and yea, The Ark would be up there too.
Cyrus_Saren
Member
The Silent Cartographer has always been my favorite level in the series. Everything about it just signifies the perfect Halo level to me.
User 73706
Banned
I feel like Shutdown is one of the only environments that actually justifies the Prometheans having a veritable fuckton of health. It's almost like they built a campaign level channeling New Alexandria with the concept "what if you could actually put a dent in Promethean Knights instead of wasting a good dozen or so Battle Rifles on them?"
SAW / Railgun combo is amazing, too, because you can usually rail Watchers without fail, mow down Crawler packs with the SAW, and then use a rail to down Promethean shields and mop up with the SAW again. It almost struck me as a Two Betrayals sort of environment where you could essentially cherry tap your way through the battles using only your Plasma Pistol and Shotgun.
Twilight Gap
Member
blew my mind when i discovered the sniper balcony on this level.
StoppedInTracks
Member
Halo 4 campaign is such garbage.
Anyway, what are the worst Halo levels around?
Cortana comes to mind... what an unnecessary disaster. System Shock 2 did this level 10x better (The Rickenbacker). Halo 4 levels are so uninspired/ or cluttered that I cannot even call them "bad levels". They are just there. Soulless. Haloless.
Anyway, what are the worst Halo levels around?
Cortana comes to mind... what an unnecessary disaster. System Shock 2 did this level 10x better (The Rickenbacker). Halo 4 levels are so uninspired/ or cluttered that I cannot even call them "bad levels". They are just there. Soulless. Haloless.
ebullientprism
Member
Bad levels?
343 Guilty spark was a terrible level. The only redeeming factor was the flood intro, which was spectacular.
Almost all Arbiter levels in Halo 2 once you start fighting brutes. The combat is terrible with those bullet spongy bastards. I love the Arbiter as a character but he definitely got the shittiest levels in the game. Probably the reason why people disliked playing as him so much.
Cortana from Halo 3 is probably the worst of the bunch.
The space flying level from Reach was terrible too. I know people love this but it never jammed with me.
Halo 4 was mostly ok. No real spectacular levels but nothing offensive either.
343 Guilty spark was a terrible level. The only redeeming factor was the flood intro, which was spectacular.
Almost all Arbiter levels in Halo 2 once you start fighting brutes. The combat is terrible with those bullet spongy bastards. I love the Arbiter as a character but he definitely got the shittiest levels in the game. Probably the reason why people disliked playing as him so much.
Cortana from Halo 3 is probably the worst of the bunch.
The space flying level from Reach was terrible too. I know people love this but it never jammed with me.
Halo 4 was mostly ok. No real spectacular levels but nothing offensive either.
You might want to check the OP.The level you're thinking of is The Ark
Yeah, thanks guys. I felt like an idiot going back to check, but yeah that's the one.Its pretty obvious, and not very tactful in my opinion.
gollumsluvslave
Member
Attack on the Control Room for me.
So much this. Brutes suck.
So much this. Brutes suck.
Xcell Miguel
Gold Member
I love The Ark level, in Halo 3, my mate and me did the whole level with a Gauss Warthog, then we did it again in MCC, we had so much fun squeezing it in tight close-quarter rooms
And at the end of the level, you can even finish with it, and it falls to death : http://xboxclips.com/Xcell+Miguel/8372849e-30ac-4b98-95a5-1e0564921e0c
Old screen from Halo 3 :
And at the end of the level, you can even finish with it, and it falls to death : http://xboxclips.com/Xcell+Miguel/8372849e-30ac-4b98-95a5-1e0564921e0c
Old screen from Halo 3 :
All of the replies in this thread are wrong grrrrrr
The actual answer is the Silent Cartographer.
A lot of the stuff in the aforementioned missions was either done better in other levels (e.g. AotCr did the sandbox thing better). The Ark has a very boring environment and the close quarters areas are nothing special in terms of combat.
Worse still, the vehicular combat is more bullshit than Jackal Snipers than Halo 2 on Legendary. A Ghost should not be able to kill a Scorpion easily.
----
The Silent Cartographer combines a large arena with asymmetric objective design, as well as an interesting plot based objective that is reliant on player presence based triggers (as opposed to button pressing). It has a fair share of bright and sunny areas, large AI battles, vehicular exploration, as well as the creepy tunnels that will later become all too common in CE. The encounter design is great, and a certain degree of stealth can be used. And unlike the other Halo CE missions, a Silent Cartographer is the perfect length, not too long or short.
This right here. Trying to get a Warthog through most of the level is a lot of fun.
Grenades and/or rockets are needed at certain points.
The Silent Cartographer is by far the best level in Halo history in my opinion. One I've completed a lot of times, and will probably do so in the future too.
Twilight Gap
Member
i decided to boot up the library thanks to this thread and i must say i'm disappointed with the way they remastered this level. the atmosphere is completely gone. aside from the repetitive textures, the lighting and depth in the classic version looks more modern than the remastered one, which feels flat.
StoppedInTracks
Member
Just a heads up: ODST is going to be free for the owners of The Master Chief Collection (me).
Hell yeah, after Halo 4 mediocrity I need a quality single-player Halo game again!
Hell yeah, after Halo 4 mediocrity I need a quality single-player Halo game again!
Navidson REC
Member
The one-two punch that is The Ark and The Covenant is nothing short of amazing. God, I really should continue my MCC run!
Titanfall, Forza Horizon 2 and Sunset Overdrive are more than enough valid reasons to own an Xbox One, IMO. And I'm not even a huge racing fan!
Titanfall, Forza Horizon 2 and Sunset Overdrive are more than enough valid reasons to own an Xbox One, IMO. And I'm not even a huge racing fan!
I really liked Composer, personally. And Midnight was cool, too. The opening was incredible, partially because of the soundtrack, and the finale was neat to (also largely because of the amazing soundtrack), despite the lack of a proper boss fight.
StoppedInTracks
Member
I have only 4 Xbone games: Diablo 3, GTA5, Halo: Collection and Dance Central. That's right, only 1 exclusive and it's a Kinect game.
It was worth it. Pity that I played H1 and H2 back in the day, ehh. Luckily there will be ODST in 2015 :hype
Perfect List!
Nothing in Halo 3 is "the best hing in Halo ever." Everything that appears in Halo 3 is some washed down crappy derivative of what appeared in the previous two games. In fact halo 3 is a crappy remake of Halo: CE. Whether its the campaign missions, level designs, maps or music. The only exception may be Avalanche as a remake but I never played the original map so I can't confirm.
Obviously, the best Halo campaign is Combat evolved. And the best levels appear at the end of the game. Such as Two Betrayals and Keyes which are classic. Night time open combat in the snow. Pure Halo bliss.
Obviously, the best Halo campaign is Combat evolved. And the best levels appear at the end of the game. Such as Two Betrayals and Keyes which are classic. Night time open combat in the snow. Pure Halo bliss.
