• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Bruce Springsteen vs. Neil Young

Status
Not open for further replies.
Since someone made a Joni Mitchell vs. Stevie Nicks thread, I thought this one would be a fun debate.

Whom do you prefer? Both have been working for over 40 years now, and are accomplished singers as well as songwriters.

I would have added Bob Dylan to this discussion, but that would not have been fair to everyone not named Bob Dylan.

So, who is better? Springsteen or Young?
 
Young is good but I have to give this one to Bruce. I mean making the Born to Run album should be enough, but he's got the Born in the USA album too. Plus his live shows are amazing, I mean damn son.

Obligatory Jungleland link.
 
You know what, fuck it! Spec is right! This thread is now for posting awesome Springsteen and Neil Young songs!
 
Jeez, this is tough. I guess Young? I consider "After The Gold Rush" an almost perfect album. I really can't give an honest answer. I could say the opposite answer tomorrow.
 
Young. His music has just touched me deeper. The entire Harvest album is one of my favorite albums of all time. There's a simplicity in his music that just works.
 
Young. His music has just touched me deeper. The entire Harvest album is one of my favorite albums of all time. There's a simplicity in his music that just works.

Young is incredible when acoustic. The Live at Massey Hall album from a few years ago was brilliant. He sounds so great when stripped down to the barest sound.

Springstein is such a cornball, Young is timeless.

Both are timeless.
 
How can you even say that? Cream? Derek and the Dominos? Several excellent solo albums? More amazing renditions of classic blues songs than anyone can count?
Exactly. Although, Clapton never kept up the same level over the decades as well as Young and Springsteen have. And Clapton's best work is always fueled by drugs/booze and or grief. But when he is on, he is fucking on.
 
clapton is awful

Your face is awful.
I'm too tired to act like a mature adult right now.

How can you even say that? Cream? Derek and the Dominos? Several excellent solo albums? More amazing renditions of classic blues songs than anyone can count?

Not to mention his time in The Yardbirds, Blind Faith, and Delaney & Bonnie & Friends. Dude's been amazing in every venture of his, and I can say without a doubt that he's my favorite guitarist.
 
Your face is awful.
I'm too tired to act like a mature adult right now.



Not to mention his time in The Yardbirds, Blind Faith, and Delaney & Bonnie & Friends. Dude's been amazing in every venture of his, and I can say without a doubt that he's my favorite guitarist.

Don't forget John Mayall and the Bluesbreakers!
 
Where the FUCK is the second set of Neil's Archives coming out? I've been waiting for a long time for that to see if a remastered version of Zuma or Tonight's The Night will be a part of it. Seriously guys, listen to Tonight's The Night. It's brilliant.

Or if his holy grail is actually gonna be on it in CD form, Time Fades Away...
 
Where the FUCK is the second set of Neil's Archives coming out? I've been waiting for a long time for that to see if a remastered version of Zuma or Tonight's The Night will be a part of it. Seriously guys, listen to Tonight's The Night. It's brilliant.

no kidding

this part excited me about archives 2

On his on-line newspaper, Young has stated that "four unreleased albums from this period are being rebuilt [...] Chrome Dreams, Homegrown and Oceanside-Countryside are the three unreleased studio albums. Also from this period is the unreleased Odeon-Budokan live recording produced by David Briggs and Tim Mulligan".

chrome dreams (rust edition) is amazing.. google that shit if you dont have it
 
Absolutely! Mick Taylor was in the Bluesbreakers right after Clapton. And IMO, Taylor is a better guitar player than Clapton!

Peter Green also joined right after Clapton left and John McVie was an original member, which brings us back to Fleetwood Mac and the Stevie Nicks vs Joni Mitchell thread.

For me though, only one artist can compare to Clapton as a guitar player and that man is B.B. King.
 
Your face is awful.
I'm too tired to act like a mature adult right now.



Not to mention his time in The Yardbirds, Blind Faith, and Delaney & Bonnie & Friends. Dude's been amazing in every venture of his, and I can say without a doubt that he's my favorite guitarist.

Clapton's kinda like Tim Horton's coffee. Sucks without Cream
 
I've never, ever liked Neil Young. Sorry.

Springsteen dudes need to download this bootleg from Boston, 1977. It is unreal. Even today -- not having listened to one of his releases since... Christ, the early '90s, I think -- I'd flip my shit to the man live.

https://rapidshare.com/files/2943544518/770323_JEMS.rar
Night two of what I call Springsteen's greatest concert stand ever brought with it some setlist changes. "Incident on 57th Street" replaces "It's My Life," and while I am admittedly something of an "Incident" apologist, it will grow to be a stronger performance nights three and four. "Action in the Streets" takes a seat on the bench in favor of a lively "Growin' Up." And "The Promise" departs to make room for the debut of "Little Latin Lupe Lu," giving us an encore that is truly a non-stop party.

"Don't Look Back" is even stronger this night and its lyrics are further cemented vs. night one. And like night one, the show is again peppered with moments where Bruce is pushing his performance to staggering heights. He even changes his vocal delivery in "Thunder Road" as the moment moves him. Our friend Mr. Hopkins switched sides of the house for the this and the next two shows, sitting 5-10 rows back of the stage left PA stack. As good as his recording of 3/22 was, this might be just a tiny bit better. Every second Steve recorded, including the applause breaks, has been preserved.

As folks who have recorded so many shows ourselves and mastered many recordings from the original tapes, I can't tell you how fantastic Steve's actual masters are. First of all, the sound in the venue must have been incredible to begin with. You can hear each instrument with uncanny clarity even when they are all blasting away together. And Hopkins' location, mic, recorder and taper acumen are all dialed in perfectly to capture that majestic sound. We often say things like, "It would be difficult to record a show this well today." I'm here to tell you that you couldn't. I couldn't. It can't be done. Despite all the improvements in technology and theoretically in live-sound reinforcement, too, ''77 sounds way better than 2012. Samples provided. The Boston '77 run will return.

01 Night
02 Don't Look Back
03 Spirit in the Night
04 Incident on 57th Street
05 Thunder Road
06 Mona > She's the One
07 Tenth Avenue Freeze-out
08 Growin' Up
09 Backstreets
10 Jungleland
11 Rosalita
12 Born to Run
13 Quarter to Three
14 Little Latin Lupe Lu
15 You Can't Sit Down
 
I've made a couple Neil Young covers this summer where I played all the instruments and this seems like a good enough thread to post them in I guess.

The first one is a song called L.A. from Time Fades Away, one of my personal favorites L.A.

This next one is a electric version of a song called Campaigner. Originally an acoustic song from his album Decade. I found a version on youtube he did during the Weld tour that I thought was a great take on a old classic. Campaigner

Don't mind the singing though, I not very good at it. I'm working on another great old Neil Young song called Winterlong right now. Just need to find the time to work on it some more.
 
My heart says Bruce, but it's really a touch choice. I think Young might actually be a better artist, in the purest sense... but, honestly, I could listen to The Wild, The Innocent, and The E Street Shuffle, Born to Run, and Darkness on the Edge of Town for the rest of my life and never grow tired of them.
 
Young hands down.

I grew up listening to Springsteen, but Young's music and lyrics are on a totally different level.
 
I do like Springstein. But there is one man gaf always forgets, and doesn't give attention to, and this is;

hotpinkmohawky.jpg


He is Jared Leto. Currently in the most talented and creative band
 
I never had a use for The Bruce but I did like the Manfred Mann covers of his songs.

I like Neil Young though. If nothing else I feel like I can sing his songs better than he does.
 
I always though Springsteen was one of those regional guys - huge in the Northeast, but not so much outside of it.

Not quite on how Sammy Hagar is super popular here in St. Louis but basically nowhere else, he's still a well known and liked musician, but just not huge.

Neil Young might not be super popular anywhere (maybe Seattle?) but he's like a worldwide guy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom