Blargonaut
Banned
ewww, I'm not avatar-quoting that
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Call of Cthulhu Mafia |OT| Nuts on this island taste insane! Yum Yum!
- Thread starter Zatoth
- Start date
ewww, I'm not avatar-quoting that
He should still be 4 or 5 votes away from ending the day.
If I understood the other threads correctly, if someone has the power to override that means they can, 1 time, end a day immediately by killing the person they override. The danganronpa thread has already used this jokingly once and I suspect it is the same situation here.
You've already manipulated me in photoshop, there's no going back now.
To counter that, I trust Darryl about as much as I do Neuromancer.
I trust Neuromancer more than I trust Darryl.
This would be an amazing twist. Unfortunately, I don't believe you either.
Lord of Castamere
Member
Oh look, more insanity. Put no you're just a poor misunderstood soul. )':
Ahh ok. I assumed it was more a "swing vote" type thing where he makes you vote along with him. Either way, 4 or 5 away is plenty for me to vote this way and keep pressure on him.
Vote: Blargonaut
Yeah, I'm not really sure I have much trust in Darryl (granted I'm biased since he's trying to kill me). He hasn't posted much and when he has it's either been some information on the cultist orb or EXTREMELY outwardly aggressive. That may just be his playstyle, and I'm not prepared to pass judgement on him fully, but he is one of those players who's hiding in broad daylight right now.
Blargonaut
Banned
You see this, Darryl?
Regard my ultimate puzzle, my ultimate creation. Simply fearless. Simply flawless. Immune to chaos.
I have raised him, trained him, perfected him; solely to hunt you down, and destroy you.
Gaze upon my champion, Darryl. Behold your downfall.
Gaze upon Sorian.
Regard my ultimate puzzle, my ultimate creation. Simply fearless. Simply flawless. Immune to chaos.
I have raised him, trained him, perfected him; solely to hunt you down, and destroy you.
Gaze upon my champion, Darryl. Behold your downfall.
Gaze upon Sorian.
Blargonaut
Banned
The override was a joke, btw
I'm not your creation. I'll take into consideration the things you've said because I do think you had town's best interests in mind (since you wanted to kill cultists too). You've been fucking with Coppa but you had a real bone to pick with Darryl, i'll figure out if that was just you raving again or if there was actually something worth investigating there.
Blargonaut
Banned
ScraftyDevil
Banned
If Darryl turns out to be the Big Bad again this season, I'm not playing next season.
I'll moderate instead.
Nah, he doesn't strike me as the card-holding type. Heck, there's a chance the one behind all this hasn't even made their presence known yet.
He is very much the card-holding type. He held his cards amazingly well in the past.
Am I the only one who is dying to see what Blarg does with his Avatar when he goes?
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
No it wouldn't. Sorian's not a Cultist. Vote for Cultists.
I'll drop whatever you'd like but I need to know what you're curious about first. I'm not role-claiming and past that the only thing I feel shitty about is Tucah.
This though, I know we're all having fun but don't try to push someone "just because" lest they reveal something that hurts town over all.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
Seriously Flame, I don't know what the fuck you've been doing all day, but I haven't liked one bit of it. I read you as a solid Tourist on Day One but it's easy to play solid Tourist on Day One. I'm watching you.
Lord of Castamere
Member
Goodbye Blarg
So long and thanks for all the fish
So sad that it has come to this
Your puzzles surely will be missed by no one
We may not share your intellect
Which might explain the disrespect
For all the clever ways that you confused us
So long, So long and thanks for all the fish.
So long and thanks for all the fish
So sad that it has come to this
Your puzzles surely will be missed by no one
We may not share your intellect
Which might explain the disrespect
For all the clever ways that you confused us
So long, So long and thanks for all the fish.
johnnyquicknives
Member
Right, my earlier post I somehow missed that Blarg was to outlive cultists. Presuming most stuff that has been role claimed is true this is how I think things sit and will shake out.
That rids us of 2 distracting roles and gives us a pretty quiet night.
Looking to dig out cult members today only really helps if they have a power role, since a Blarg lynch will neutralise regular culties for tonight anyway.
Tomorrow if Matt is alive and in the game we really need to look at him and whether his role makes more sense as town or cult aligned. Right now I find it very hard to choose because I really feel like he'll flip neutral and leave the game.
None of the alternatives are as compelling to me as putting all of this behind us.
VOTE: Blargonaut
- Blarg and Matt are both straight-up neutral. Both have pro and anti-town traits.
- If we kill Blarg tonight we will get cult immunity tonight, meaning one less death.
- Matt will likely hit his win condition, and if so get removed from the game by morning
That rids us of 2 distracting roles and gives us a pretty quiet night.
Looking to dig out cult members today only really helps if they have a power role, since a Blarg lynch will neutralise regular culties for tonight anyway.
Tomorrow if Matt is alive and in the game we really need to look at him and whether his role makes more sense as town or cult aligned. Right now I find it very hard to choose because I really feel like he'll flip neutral and leave the game.
None of the alternatives are as compelling to me as putting all of this behind us.
VOTE: Blargonaut
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
It makes perfect sense as Tourist. If Blarg were playing to win, his goal would roughly line up with the Tourists', except for the fact that he wants to avoid being lynched. Matt's role is there to sniff him out and stop him from leaving the game before he helps us as much as he can. I think they've both been completely honest about there roles.
I want to know who you think the second Night 1 killer is? We can all agree it's probably someone who had a beef with LP, but who, in your opinion, stuck out as someone with that kind of power, and willing enough to act on it on Day 1. I also want to see if you think that there's another protection role out there, one who is willing to protect Blarg?
If you do think there is a role to save Blarg, then who do you think we should lynch today?
Not Coppa
If you don't think there is a role to save Blarg, then we're in agreement that it's best to lynch him right now, likely giving Matt the win?
I agree with you that it is likely if the Cultists kill Blarg they get a second kill, which is obviously bad.
UNVOTE: Sorian
VOTE: Rats off to Ya
I can't understand someone who is happily willing to risk giving the Cultists two night kills.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
*their
FUCK. I'm not stupid, I promise.
FUCK. I'm not stupid, I promise.
What makes the free night more valuable later on in the game?
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
Because I don't think we're risking that, and even if I did, this is a game all about taking risks.
Now go vote for a Cultist. Jesus Christ.
Werewolf Jones
Member
Well I'm going to sleep soon so you'll have to wait until tomorrow.
Y'all sure are going in circles right now, vicious circles I might add. I'll see what happens tomorrow.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
There are far too many variables right now for an extra day to be of much use. Too many people to read, too many targets to examine, not enough scummy behavior to comb through. We kill Blarg, our possible third party kills someone else, in all likelihood our investigative roles don't turn up anything interesting, and then tomorrow we're playing Day Two all over again.
So you're saying we shouldn't lynch Blarg today, instead lynching someone like Coppa, who will flip town on us. Then night time rolls around and Blarg dies + someone else from the third party killer. We maybe get someone on Day 3, maybe not, then on Night 3, there's 3 kills. One for normal cultist, one for their bonus, one for the third party. On the start of Day 4, we could be down 6 people if the theory is correct. Or we can get rid of Blarg now and not worry about that.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
If you're scared of losing Tourists just vote No Lynch every day until you're dead. I won't judge.
Lord of Castamere
Member
A giant game of chicken. No way Cultists kill Blarg after all of this that would be dumb.
I'm fine slaying tourists, so long as we have good reasoning. I'm not fine with us losing 6 tourists in 2 days however.
Why would they not kill Blarg, don't you think they might want to take a shot at getting a double kill or at least stopping us from preventing a night of sacrifices. I don't understand your reasoning, perhaps you can convince me.
johnnyquicknives
Member
But Matt's role is specifically to kill Blarg before we hit 3 dead cultists?
Matt claims his role is not that of a lyncher, he simply searches for Lovecraft each night and has all the information on his character.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
Right. We've theorized that Blarg's win condition is to outlive three Cultists. Can't remember if Blarg confirmed that or not.
johnnyquicknives
Member
I also think the free night is more useful in the early/mid game. Later on it might be a useful block (although it would mean putting considerable effort into keeping him alive) but the early kills are much easier for the cult to get away with without drawing suspicions, later in the game they're much more likely to leave a trail.
Lord of Castamere
Member
Because as you just said they're not stopping anything, the kill gain is speculation, and there might be power roles that can watch/protect him. No sense.
Who specifically? I don't know. I think we have a vigilante with us who is tourist aligned. While I have no clue exactly who it is, I have suspicions about how to find them but I don't want to reveal that. They are a role I think is important to protect and I'm not offering that in open discussion for cultists to read.
I don't think there is another protection role out there. Maybe we have a switcher but I'm not willing to gamble on that because I'm leaning towards we do not. So yes, that is why I am in favor of killing Blarg.
I quoted this because I am curious. I read Flame as possible cult on day 1 and I still read him kind fo sketchy today. Why were you so sure of him on day 1?
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
He talked a lot and didn't say anything I disagreed with. It was a Day One read, so it wasn't worth much, but he seemed like a Tourist to me.
I think if they get a double kill or some other bonus then they already know about it. If we let Blarg stay alive and they don't kill him then that would prove to me that he does not give them any bonus. Like I said though, I see no reason to take that risk. I'd rather kill him and let the killer take out someone tonight, we still get info from a night kill and my suspicion is they are going to kill someone we've argued about anyway: Coppa, Charleston, Darryl to name a few.
Blarg did confirm this.
johnnyquicknives
Member
Ah OK, so Blarg wins when he gets 3 kills and matt knows that this will lose us our free night.
That does make me think Matt is more likely town.
Fair enough, was just wondering if you saw anything specific that I missed, carry on.
We may be at an impasse where either Blarg or Matt wins.
Lord of Castamere
Member
Does it matter if Matt Attack wins though?
johnnyquicknives
Member
Maybe, but a neutral win doesn't really effect the game much. I still think that our best move is to kill Blarg and try and move past this.
Blargonaut
Banned
They grow up so fast :')
btw you got max LCK but I had to min CHA, it's useless anyway
starting area gear was skipped because I speedran you, you can always go back anyway so ehhh
It doesn't matter if either of them win.
Seriously Flame, your arguments are going in circles. Take a breather, figure out what you want to say, and come back and say it when you've reasoned out what you want.
Blargonaut
Banned
ugh, but he doesn't "win" tho
Blargonaut
Banned
Wait, are people actually still considering my 800 feet plan?
This is disgusting, I want in on this.
This is disgusting, I want in on this.