Biggest-Geek-Ever
Member
Where are the irritating filters? Or the subtle graininess?Please tell me honestly, GAF, are these good enough for Tumblr?
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Captain America: Civil War Review Thread
- Thread starter Jigorath
- Start date
- Status
Holundrian
Unconfirmed Member
It's because of the salad.
AyaisMUsikWhore
Member
What's an IGN?
No seriously, I don't really care for what IGN thinks... Their reviews are jokes.... literally.
I'm not that advanced in my gif making abilities. ;P
The way I'm cackling at these flawless reviews
halo thar
Namerson23
Member
People go to IGN for movie reviews? I'm pretty sure the same guy gave Man of Steel a 9.0 and BvS a 6.8 saying it was a "ok to good movie" and that "it's too competently made to be a disaster"...how do I know all this? I go to IGN for movie reviews.
ratcliffja
Member
Man how many secret comic book movies are there? Blade, Men In Black, The Mask, Ninja Turtles... I know there are a lot I'm forgetting.
Edit: Wrong thread yet right thread. Weird because I never do that.
Edit: Wrong thread yet right thread. Weird because I never do that.
Please tell me honestly, GAF, are these good enough for Tumblr?
Holy shit. I thought I've seen the worst tumblr has to offer. I guess I was wrong. *shudder*
Zeyphersan
Banned
I was wondering what the hell you were talking about
Please tell me honestly, GAF, are these good enough for Tumblr?
Bump up the saturation and contrast by twenty notches and you're gold for 10,000 notes.
Discotheque
Banned
They doing screenings tomorrow tho right? Prolly get reviews during the weekend
-Plasma Reus-
Service guarantees member status
I think Winter Soldier is probably the best superhero movie next to Avengers and Watchmen. And I think the Russo's are the best at this kind of thing.
However, I am nervous about the lack of Black Panther talk, compared with the Spiderman impressions. This either tells me BP is portrayed boring/badly, or there just isn't a big role for him in this movie, or that these people who got to see the movie first care more about Spiderman.
However, I am nervous about the lack of Black Panther talk, compared with the Spiderman impressions. This either tells me BP is portrayed boring/badly, or there just isn't a big role for him in this movie, or that these people who got to see the movie first care more about Spiderman.
BronsonLee
Member
Don't worry fam I got u
Discotheque
Banned
You one of the real boys of comic book movie gaf. Speak your mind man...
Vault Dweller 111
Member
He's either anazing or not mentioned at all. I wouldn't worry. He's still just a secondary character.
Coogler will give you what you want though.
BronsonLee
Member
I'll pop in here tomorrow and do a similar thing like I did for BvS, then hide in the Spoiler Thread forever
I've already told them to keep an eye out for someone named Einchy
They told me to stop calling them
DedalusJoyce
Member
reviews won't matter tomorrow half of gaf will have it by this time tomorrow
StopMakingSense
Member
Nm I misunderstood
AquaWateria
Member
It seems to me these critics have a huge hard on for Spidey. Fucking Spiderman Chills.
Joking aside people from Collider in their spoiler free review talked about how important T'Challa's plot point is in the story. That Chadwick Boseman nails Black Panther's character and how great his accent is. Heck, one of them even said Black Panther's introduction was more impressive than Spidey.
You have nothing to fear. There's just as much praise for Black Panther as there is for Spider-Man.
I so don't want to be the DC Cinematic Universe guys to bring the news for the big boss right now xD
Marvel's the Potato indeed
Marvel's the Potato indeed
Don't know if this was posted. Inside The Magic video review.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LIX0PT9yCNc
Never seen a video review by the channel before (they cover mainly Disney stuff, I think) but the reviewer says he is self-admittedly not a huge fan of Marvel, yet this film won him over to where he is now excited about Infinity War.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LIX0PT9yCNc
Never seen a video review by the channel before (they cover mainly Disney stuff, I think) but the reviewer says he is self-admittedly not a huge fan of Marvel, yet this film won him over to where he is now excited about Infinity War.
bananafactory
Banned
I think at this point I'm more excited to read BronsonLee's review than watch the movie
Hah! He did give Man of Steel a 9. Not that that's invalid, everyone is entitled to their opinions, but that at least shows me our tastes don't align.
BronsonLee
Member
CUT THE CHECK
Zeyphersan
Banned
Those clips made me forever love Anthony Mackie
Primethius
Banned
ratcliffja
Member
Man Rudd really phoned it in. That was brutal.
IGN's review seems off not because of the score but because it kind of assumes that you need both a bombastic 3rd act (which Marvel would have gotten grilled for anyways for being structured too much like past films) and expecting the villain to be a traditional villain when that's never been the presumption anywhere.
They're totally entitled to their own opinion and blah blah blah but I don't hold it against them for trying to keep most of the action in the 2nd act, and I certainly can't figure out why anyone would expect Zemo to take a Loki or Malekith or Ronan type of role in this. That's part of what I'm interested in, actually; how, amid internal conflict, they are vulnerable to external threats in general that don't have to be world-ending things.
They're totally entitled to their own opinion and blah blah blah but I don't hold it against them for trying to keep most of the action in the 2nd act, and I certainly can't figure out why anyone would expect Zemo to take a Loki or Malekith or Ronan type of role in this. That's part of what I'm interested in, actually; how, amid internal conflict, they are vulnerable to external threats in general that don't have to be world-ending things.
I look forward to not reading it
George Oscar Bluth II
Banned
#SupportJustinHammer
BronsonLee
Member
Don't act like you know how to read anyways you punk
Eventually you'll accept my status as the one true god of song and stage
Wow. That was harsh. Hype is gone
AlfredX1990
Banned
Goddammit, this is going to be done a few more times right?
Zeyphersan
Banned
I knew it was only a matter of time, it couldn't have stayed at 100% forever
BronsonLee
Member
I'm now 50/50 on whether I want to actually do it
Colonel Nasty
Member
Geez his positivity just drops off a cliff moments in.
You know, I wonder if we will see more director teams on these big spectacle movies. It seems like the Russos are able to make these films without killing themselves the way Whedon or Snyder seemed to have. With movies this big and complicated two people to share the main load seems like its not a bad idea.
ratcliffja
Member
I think I had to sit down after watching.
- Status