• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Captain America vs. Master Chief

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's kinda funny if you think about it. Iron Man's armor was built in our modern time (unless by comic book fiction says otherwise), while Spartan armor is over 500 years ahead haha

I'm not addressing your exact point here, but on the subject of Tony Stark and the level of technology in the Marvel Universe, dude is currently in the process of creating a Dyson Sphere.

NewAvengersv3004-007.jpg

sols-hammer.jpg


Food for thought.
 
Um... Technology in Halo the Forerunners developed many Dysons Spheres, one that is 300,000,000 km or 2 AU.

http://www.halopedia.org/Trevelyan

In fact Halo 4 took place in a Dyson Sphere.

http://www.halopedia.org/Requiem

I'm not disputing any of that, I'm just illustrating the level of technology Stark has access to in 2013. Though it is neat that it's just on a much, much smaller scale than what a precursor race in the Halo universe accomplished however many centuries ago. Thanks for pointing that out.
 
I'm not disputing any of that, I'm just illustrating the level of technology Stark has access to in 2013. Though it is neat that it's just on a much, much smaller scale than what a precursor race in the Halo universe accomplished however many centuries ago. Thanks for pointing that out.

Ah, yeah if you do compare it, what Stark has in the 2013 compared to what the UNSC has in 2558 is staggering. Since while I think the UNSC could make a Shield World, I'm not sure they could have before they got access to Forerunner technology.
 
I'm not addressing your exact point here, but on the subject of Tony Stark and the level of technology in the Marvel Universe, dude is currently in the process of creating a Dyson Sphere.

NewAvengersv3004-007.jpg

sols-hammer.jpg


Food for thought.
Oh god.. This is.. Hilarious.

Hopefully he doesn't make it self aware and it starts transforming itself.

Unicron + Ultron = ?
 
Cap stops alien invasions before breakfast on the regular. Not only would he smack chief he'd make it look completely inconsequential.
 
I'm not addressing your exact point here, but on the subject of Tony Stark and the level of technology in the Marvel Universe, dude is currently in the process of creating a Dyson Sphere.

NewAvengersv3004-007.jpg

sols-hammer.jpg


Food for thought.

Let's not even ask where the materials comes from and where they are manufactured. I guess they come from Plot Factory. Even with as much as good Stark and company are, they don't have the industrial capacity of the Galactic Empire (Star Wars). 2% of a SPHERE around the sun? Even the Second Death Star is a puny thing in comparison. This is completely ludicrous.
 
I'm not addressing your exact point here, but on the subject of Tony Stark and the level of technology in the Marvel Universe, dude is currently in the process of creating a Dyson Sphere.

http://i156.photobucket.com/albums/t28/D-O-L/New%20Avengers/New%20Avengers%2004/NewAvengersv3004-007.jpg[IMG]
[IMG]http://journeyintocomics.files.wordpress.com/2013/04/sols-hammer.jpg[/MG]

Food for thought.[/QUOTE]
Why can they just stand around in space while the workers have to wear spacesuits?
 
Why can they just stand around in space while the workers have to wear spacesuits?

I guess it's some sort of ''holographic/virtual/something'' thing that let them be there without being there without needing any Physical bridge. Seems like Star Trek Holo tech logic.
 
Let's not even ask where the materials comes from and where they are manufactured. I guess they come from Plot Factory. Even with as much as good Stark and company are, they don't have the industrial capacity of the Galactic Empire (Star Wars). 2% of a SPHERE around the sun? Even the Second Death Star is a puny thing in comparison. This is completely ludicrous.

The tech and workers come from and alien race called the Shi'ar in exchange for Earth based precious metals as Stark explains in the page above. The benefits of coming into contact with alien races and beating the crap out of several of them.

I guess it's some sort of ''holographic/virtual/something'' thing that let them be there without being there without needing any Physical bridge. Seems like Star Trek Holo tech logic.

Basically.
 
Let's not even ask where the materials comes from and where they are manufactured. I guess they come from Plot Factory. Even with as much as good Stark and company are, they don't have the industrial capacity of the Galactic Empire (Star Wars). 2% of a SPHERE around the sun? Even the Second Death Star is a puny thing in comparison. This is completely ludicrous.

Personally, the fact that Captain America went from a puny 100-pound sorry sack of bones into someone who can spar with Hulk, Thor, and probably Galactus (because why not?) after drinking a special sauce offends me far more.

*shrugs*

#salty
#whereismysecretsauce
 
The tech and workers come from and alien race called the Shi'ar in exchange for Earth based precious metals as Stark explains in the page above. The benefits of coming into contact with alien races and beating the crap out of several of them.

So.. those Shi'ar are able to make such a structure in a month?

Sci fi writers have no sense of Scale

I don't really mind, really, I've seen worse in Marvel/DC/Manga/etc.

It's just that sometimes they put those as such extreme that my sense of disbelief is completely destroyed. Cap America being able to lead and win wars against supreme intelligence? Ok, Whatever, that's classic.

Making a kinda Dyson Sphere in a month? Eh, just no.
 
So.. those Shi'ar are able to make such a structure in a month?

Sci fi writers have no sense of Scale

I don't really mind, really, I've seen worse in Marvel/DC/Manga/etc.

It's just that sometimes they put those as such extreme that my sense of disbelief is completely destroyed. Cap America being able to lead and win wars against supreme intelligence? Ok, Whatever, that's classic.

Making a kinda Dyson Sphere in a month? Eh, just no.

Two percent of a dyson sphere in a month, from an empire that measures its territory on the galactic scale.
 
Two percent of a dyson sphere in a month, from an empire that measures its territory on the galactic scale.

The Galactic Empire made a second death star, didn't even finish it, in 6 Years. A 900km wide Station. Not a ... thing that is larger than 1.4Million kilometers. In a month.

(And the Galactic Empire as at least a ''million'' worlds in it's grasp)
 
The Galactic Empire made a second death star, didn't even finish it, in 6 Years. A 900km wide Station. Not a ... thing that is larger than 1.4Million kilometers. In a month.

(And the Galactic Empire as at least a ''million'' worlds in it's grasp)

I'm not sure how that's relevant.
 
I'm not sure how that's relevant.

I'm comparing 2 Galactic Empire right? I mean, we are talking about a industry level that must be really high. It's not like I want to pull off numbers, but to make such a structure in month they would need to do at least 40,000 square kilometers per SECONDS. And they show us dudes doing it by hand? Where are the Millions of ships with the materials? The Billions of people that would be needed for that? See what I mean by ''scale''?
 
The Galactic Empire made a second death star, didn't even finish it, in 6 Years. A 900km wide Station. Not a ... thing that is larger than 1.4Million kilometers. In a month.

(And the Galactic Empire as at least a ''million'' worlds in it's grasp)

You're comparing one imaginary race's technological capabilities to another imaginary race's technological capability.

Basing one universe's capacity to build by comparing to another universe's is somewhat nonsensical, especially since they might have different bases to work off.

Considering some of the technologies that have been invented in the Marvel universe, the production of a small part of a Dyson sphere constructed that quickly is one of the more believable aspects. Also, it's a comic book shot, they aren't going to show every little bit of process. Hell they might even be doing the Protoss thing and just warping the necessary matter into place!
 
Wow, just saw this. Craptain America beating Master Chief? What bullshit. Also, I'm shocked MS allowed Master Chief to get decapitated.
 
Aw yiss, everyone knows that the production capabilities of the Galactic Empire in Star Wars are both meticulously researched and true to life, therefore being not just the best, but the only true measure for what any civilization, fictional or not, could construct in a given period of time.
 
Personally, the fact that Captain America went from a puny 100-pound sorry sack of bones into someone who can spar with Hulk, Thor, and probably Galactus (because why not?) after drinking a special sauce offends me far more.

*shrugs*

#salty
#whereismysecretsauce
whatcaptainqizi5.jpg
 
Let's not even ask where the materials comes from and where they are manufactured. I guess they come from Plot Factory. Even with as much as good Stark and company are, they don't have the industrial capacity of the Galactic Empire (Star Wars). 2% of a SPHERE around the sun? Even the Second Death Star is a puny thing in comparison. This is completely ludicrous.

Stark mentions in that scan that he's using Shi'ar contractors.

Though the empire has grown to include hundreds of thousands of different sentient species and worlds, the Shi'ar race controls and governs the empire. Its central base of power is located on the "throneworld" Chandilar, while the Shi’ar homeworld is called Aerie (it is unknown if the planet still exists). The leader of the empire is given the title Majestor (male) or Majestrix (female) and is a hereditary position, occupied by members of the royal family of the Shi'ar. Formerly, the Neramani family represented the royal bloodline.

The Shi'ar Empire is one of the most advanced and expansive civilizations in the universe, spanning entire galaxies. It is mainly an economic co-operative, where trade with other galactic powers is its driving force. Not all races have the same rights in the Imperium, as the Shi’ar appear to have a disproportionate influence on its governance.

The Shi'ar empire spans galaxies. plural. And there are at least two other empires (Kree and Skrull) that are on somewhat equal footing. Marvel science is so advanced and ridiculous it smokes just about everything easily, INCLUDING star wars.
 
No weapons for either, Captain can have his shield = Master Chief wins. That's all I'll say.

haven't been reading the thread? With no weapons MC has no way to take down a shield equipped Steve Rogers.

Rogers is significantly faster, and has beaten the holy hell out of opponents more skilled and with higher strength levels than an armored MC, and the spartan armor will not stand up to that shield used offensively.

Here's a fun scan I haven't posted yet- occurred in a daredevil book.

3517819-8728365515-dared_zps0d6d522e.jpg


Cap is hunting daredevil here, basically playing with him. He's moving so fast he's barely perceptible to daredevil's super senses, and though DD can't locate him, he can determine that cap's body is under no strain at all from moving this fast.
 
How do we know that Rogers has faught tougher opponents?

Basic familiarity with the opponents Cap has fought, combined with the information provided on MC within the thread.

Maybe a Covenant Grunt would be all-powerful in the MU.

We're assuming that all opponents would basically function at the strength levels they typically display within their own respective continuities, and combat takes place on neutral ground.
 
My hypothesis is that the MU is a miniature parallel universe, hence ridiculous unarmoured strength and resistance. Cap would be the size of an ant in the Halo universe. :p
 
My hypothesis is that the MU is a miniature parallel universe, hence ridiculous unarmoured strength and resistance. Cap would be the size of an ant in the Halo universe. :p

Hypothesis debunked.

The marvel U is not one universe, but an infinite number of parallel worlds of varying scope. It's crossed over with continuities OUTSIDE of it on a number of times as well- other comic companies such DC, Valiant, and Archie, and traditionally NON comic properties such as Star Trek, Transformers, Conan, Army of Darkness, and GI Joe. DC (which marvel has crossed over with numerous times) has done crossover events with the Aliens and Predator universes, as well as Masters of the Universe.

Unless there's some kind of muti universe theory within Halo that puts it at many times the size of the standard universe we all inhabit (and the use of standard weights and metrics such as "tons" and "light years" would seem to debunk this) your hypothesis holds no water.
 
haven't been reading the thread? With no weapons MC has no way to take down a shield equipped Steve Rogers.

Rogers is significantly faster, and has beaten the holy hell out of opponents more skilled and with higher strength levels than an armored MC, and the spartan armor will not stand up to that shield used offensively.

Here's a fun scan I haven't posted yet- occurred in a daredevil book.

3517819-8728365515-dared_zps0d6d522e.jpg


Cap is hunting daredevil here, basically playing with him. He's moving so fast he's barely perceptible to daredevil's super senses, and though DD can't locate him, he can determine that cap's body is under no strain at all from moving this fast.

DD was also amazed that a guy pushing 3 bills could movie like a ballerina.
 
A single one sure what about a whole army of them?

Cap fought and beat an entire army of those things and worse singlehandedly for ten years straight.


wades into a fight with hundreds of them, including monstrous clones of himself. His body was at the height of infection at this point, and his strength, speed, and stamina were average or worse.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom