• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Carrie Underwood <-- gaf has no taste.

Status
Not open for further replies.
royalan said:
I mean, it's not much in the way of factual data, but I could post links to the dozens upon dozens of "World's Most Beautiful Women" lists she's topped or placed highly in over the years, links to celebrities (men and women) referring to her as one of the most beautiful people they've ever seen, links to studies demonstrating that men have a tendency to be attracted to symmetry, curves, and features they perceive to be "exotic" (things that Beyonce has in spades). I could do all of that, but it would really be pointless here, because your opinion is just so blatantly inflammatory.
Click to expand...

At the end, that's someone else's opinion on her. I can post quite a few links where she's seen as *ahem* (ugly). Unfortunately, I share a very unpopular opinion. I'm sorry if I hurt so many people by calling her ugly. My opinion is as valid as yours, just because it doesn't agree with the general population stance on her doesn't make my opinion inflammatory.

But I would never say she's ugly, because that's about as false a statement as you could make about something as subjective as this, regardless of how you feel about her or any other woman that strikes your fancy. It's especially shit-stirring when you constantly anchor your opinion in this thread with statements like "she just looks like an everyday black girl" that's just begging to start another GAF race war.
Click to expand...

So basically, what I get from this post is never call someone ugly. It's rude. And about the race war thing, that wasn'y my intention. People read into things so deeply. Even I wasn't thinking about that. I have been banned for that before and I know there are some very strict rules here regarding that.
 
I just wanna say, it was a mistake for Sara Jean Underwood to get implants.
She lost her cute, natural girl next door look because of it. Man, she must have gotten some bad advice.
 
MrCookiepants said:
Carrie is never doing this. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=juqws1LIH-I

0:30 Carrie am cry. :(

tumblr_m57q67DppT1rvmssro1_250.gif
Click to expand...

So she was hot 8 years ago? This I can agree with.
 
FortunateSon said:
At the end, that's someone else's opinion on her. I can post quite a few links where she's seen as *ahem* (ugly). Unfortunately, I share a very unpopular opinion. I'm sorry if I hurt so many people by calling her ugly. My opinion is as valid as yours, just because it doesn't agree with the general population stance on her doesn't make my opinion inflammatory.



So basically, what I get from this post is never call someone ugly. It's rude. And about the race war thing, that wasn'y my intention. People read into things so deeply. Even I wasn't thinking about that. I have been banned for that before and I know there are some very strict rules here regarding that.
Click to expand...

What do you expect? It's Neogaf. Quit while your ahead (Beyonce is hot btw).
 
blame space said:
no, there aren't explicit rules you dimwit. it's just stupid to call beyonce ugly when at least half of her popular appeal is looking nice. she's not ugly, and that's why you have people all but calling you a racist.
Click to expand...

Just because 90% of the world think she's nice doesn't mean the remaining 10% can't call her ugly or whatever other names. It's what they think and people can think whatever they want but that's it. It ends right there, that's how it usually works. Thank you for calling me a dimwit. Calling names is bannable no?

I think the lesson here is you can't force attraction.

So, the world will continue thinking Beyonce is beautiful while ignoring Carrie. And the OP and his weird friends can have their opinions too.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I think this post settles it then. I find her ugly and, what's the big deal? 90% of the world can find Beyonce beautiful and ignore Carrie. I'd rather have that than have people cutting out my throat for calling Beyonce ugly.
 
FortunateSon said:
At the end, that's someone else's opinion on her. I can post quite a few links where she's seen as *ahem* (ugly). Unfortunately, I share a very unpopular opinion. I'm sorry if I hurt so many people by calling her ugly. My opinion is as valid as yours, just because it doesn't agree with the general population stance on her doesn't make my opinion inflammatory.
Click to expand...

Yes it does, especially when it's so irrelevant to the point you were originally trying to make.

Also, I'd like to see these links of gathered opinion that Beyonce is ugly. Just curious,
and it might be useful for any future shade I throw in the PopGAF thread.



So basically, what I get from this post is never call someone ugly. It's rude. And about the race war thing, that wasn'y my intention. People read into things so deeply. Even I wasn't thinking about that. I have been banned for that before and I know there are some very strict rules here regarding that.
Click to expand...

Not exactly. If I were you I'd just really think about what it is you're trying to communicate before posting. Also determine if any statements you're about to make are being conjured in haste or just to be needlessly shocking (very few people out there think Beyoncé is someone who could be described as "ugly" and I'm sure you know that. Tying your opinion of her looks to her race is also asking for trouble, and I'm sure you know that, as well).

Judging by your last post, you've done just that. *.*
 
Sean! said:
Nope, I was already called a twit in here.
Click to expand...

Well, I thought that was the rule. Anyways, more Carrie Underwood though! Lets all just forget Beyonce and the talk. Whatever, she wasn't even worth the mention in this thread, I fucked up there. Should have exclusively made it about Carrie but I'm sure with gaf's obsession with Beyonce would lead to her being posted and me calling her ugly eitherway, lol. Live and learn.

2hdqiw5.gif
 
FortunateSon said:
I just find Beyonce extremely ugly.
Click to expand...

FortunateSon said:
She is. And Beyonce looks like any basic black girl. She has nothing unique about her.
Click to expand...

FortunateSon said:
Um. I'm not sure if Paula Patton is black but I find her hot as well. She's attractive as hell. I've liked her since I watched mission impossible 4.

2011-mission-impossible-iv-mission-impossible-4-wp_422_94936.jpg


I wouldn't say she's like a normal black girl. I like her looks, personality etc... She stands out. Beyonce on the other hand, just doesn't do it for me.

Sorry. But Paula man....
Click to expand...
KuGsj.gif
 
royalan said:
Yes it does, especially when it's so irrelevant to the point you were originally trying to make.

Also, I'd like to see these links of gathered opinion that Beyonce is ugly. Just curious,
and it might be useful for any future shade I throw in the PopGAF thread.
Click to expand...

Dude, let it go. And stop. Just google Beyonce is ugly and you'd get tons of links with people calling her that. Guess they all must have inflammatory opinions. Probably outcasts that don't deserve to live in this world because of such an unpopular opinion.

Not exactly. If I were you I'd just really think about what it is you're trying to communicate before posting. Also determine if any statements you're about to make are being conjured in haste or just to be needlessly shocking (very few people out there thing Beyoncé is someone who could be described as "ugly" and I'm sure you know that.
Click to expand...

I did. I never thought people would make it such a big deal. I did not do it for shocking value or to get attention. I have always found her unattractive.

Tying your opinion of her looks to her race is also asking for trouble, and I'm sure you know that, as well)/
Click to expand...

Wasn't intentional. But that was a bad idea. But some posters did say that Carrie Underwood looked like a run of the mill average white girl. So I'm not sure.
 
Sean! said:
Is the endgame here for one of you to prove your opinion factually correct or something
Click to expand...

I'm not out to prove anyone anything. I'm not jumping on people if they find Carrie ugly, fat, etc... Whatever you know. It's their opinion.

I have nothing to prove, I stated something. Got jumped with knife on my throat. Worse part..... I'm probably going to get banned but eh.
 
FortunateSon said:
I'm not out to prove anyone anything. I'm not jumping on people if they find Carrie ugly, fat, etc... Whatever you know. It's their opinion.

I have nothing to prove, I stated something. Got jumped with knife on my throat. Worse part..... I'm probably going to get banned but eh.
Click to expand...

The debates span 5 pages, and you already edited the OP. Switching the subject might be ideal
 
FortunateSon said:
Wasn't intentional. But that was a bad idea. But some posters did say that Carrie Underwood looked like a run of the mill average white girl. So I'm not sure.
Click to expand...
Only one poster. And it was an equally stupid/irrelevant comment (albeit not made to explain why a particular person is "extremely ugly").

FortunateSon said:
I'm probably going to get banned but eh.
Click to expand...
Not this time, I don't think. You're pushing your luck, though. Have you ever considered just not discussing black people at all? This would be the third time you'd be banned for such comments.
 
Maybe she (Pill) just isn't photogenic.
She was cute in Scott Pilgrimm, but some people just come off very wrong in a still pictures.
 
UrbanRats said:
Maybe she (Pill) just isn't photogenic.
She was cute in Scott Pilgrimm, but some people just come off very wrong in a still pictures.
Click to expand...

Here's a few shots from The Newsroom, which i think are much better. She does have a large forehead, sure. But i think the quoted picture, was just a particularly bad photo.

the-newsroom-alison-p3juo3.jpg


maggieccufo.png


tumblr_m7g9uy5vsv1qaxywu8u.jpg
 
haikira said:
Here's a few shots from The Newsroom, which i think are much better. She does have a large forehead, sure. But i think the quoted picture, was just a particularly bad photo.

tumblr_m7g9uy5vsv1qaxywu8u.jpg
Click to expand...

I've hooked up with a girl who looks just like her here, except redheaded, smaller forehead, and freckles. She's not bad.
 
Nub said:
There are literally millions of girls, and just because one isn't posted doesn't mean that no one finds her attractive.
Click to expand...

I was just representing her. Someone has to do it. Every girl has a representative on here so I might as well be Carrie's.
 
The more times I look at that Olloson Poll pic, the less jarring it is. She's pretty cute by now.
 
Menelaus said:
Carrie is a fine piece of flesh. As a leg man, there are few above her for me. Just making this post is killing me. Not sure why you'd even begin to compare her to Beyonce...different race and body types do not a good juxtaposition make.

sQ1Vw.jpg


CwwR0.jpg


VaT5f.jpg


70IV7.jpg
Click to expand...
Thanks for the save man.

Although I was kinda hoping it was going to be permanently derailed and full of Kelly Brook pictures. Damn that woman is something else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Most CEOs admit AI has brought no financial gain
News  2
98
2K
RCX replied
Is it just me or do most candies taste bad now?
48
1K
Mr Reasonable replied
Reading GAF 2025 |OT| Physical, Digital, But No Fabio
2
88
2K
NotMyProblemAnymoreCunt replied
SpaceX has acquired xAI
2
56
848
Mengy replied
  • Poll
Everyone on Earth has to press a button
8 9 10 11 12
584
844
Meicyn replied
Top Bottom