Support NeoGAF

[Kibbles]

Looks just as bad as the other versions not particularly worse.

 

[EnVy_CaLiBeR]

I don't blame the Xbox One for how ugly this game is at all. Obviously it's not as powerful as the PS4 but it's fully capable of producing good looking games.

Infinity Ward is just a joke.

Agreed. How they didn't get this game running at 1080p still baffles me. It looks bad on all platforms.

 

[ElTorro]

That gif is frame per frame the same as the original footage. (0:45)

May be just the conversion process from 60fps to 30fps, the footage has a shitty quality, but it looks like a dip in frame rate. If the PS360 version run smoothly, IW has fucked something up.

 

[Skeff]

Not really talking about this thread(should have stated that)

It's more about how you pretty much dump on anything Xbox. I just don't get it...If your not interested in the console, why wast so much time talking about how average everything is on it ?

I think you misunderstand, I am interested in getting an XB1, just not yet...

 

[BruiserBear]

I'm not making excuses, the fact that IW have said themselves it put a huge strain on development pretty much guarantees that's why both X1 and PS4 versions are suffering quite significantly with performance and graphical detail.

Every developer says making a game on multiple platforms is a strain. You are making excuses for them.

 

[madmackem]

Do we just give this guy a free pass and believe that its actually XB1 footage? How was he able to get footage before the other big sites?

This isnt some exclusive footage weve seen xbox1 footage before and there was a big ass stream last night that seemed to be xb1.

 

[robertsan21]

So I shouldn't have posted potentially the first CoD on XB1 footage, just because it was on youtube?

Dont worry about him, you did the right thing. sure its compressed but you can still see the game looks like ass.

 

[PorkFryRice]

seriously doubt a youtuber with more than a million subscribers would risk a fake. He doesn't need to, anyway.

The more than a million subscribers unfortunately answers your second question too.

Not really. there are way more 'gaming' sites on youtube with 3m+ subscribers. A guy with 1m subscribers who has no previous affiliation or recognition is suspect.

 

[MysticGoujon]

I think the lack of 1080p is a problem with the developer and not the Xbox One, despite what IW want us to think.

NBA 2k14 is running in 1080p and looks shit tonnes better than this. Same with Forza 5. Ryse is running 900p.

Yep, IW have done an appalling job on the next gen (X1, PS4, PC), but the attempt on the X1 version is beyond embarrassing. This game should run 1080p60 without even struggling on both X1 and PS4 yet it doesn't (reported slow down on PS4), the whole six gig ram fiasco on the PC is hilarious as well, this game reeks of rushed. Thankfully, despite being a day one Xbox One customer, I detest COD, so this has little interest to me, but as a developer, it makes me cringe how poor a job they have done.

 

[Macho Madness]

Not really. there are way more 'gaming' sites on youtube with 3m+ subscribers. A guy with 1m subscribers who has no previous affiliation or recognition is suspect.

You don't get to a million subscribers by posting fake videos.

 

[Dragon]

In single player. None mentioned in multi. Only the PS4 version was said to have it in both multi and single. I'll trade resolution for framerate any day of the week.

Already creating arguments based on little to no evidence. smh

 

[Sioen]

You don't get to a million subscribers by posting fake videos.

I wouldn't waste your time arguing with him, he won't believe it untill everyone starts uploading xbox one gameplay after the embargo.

 

[iJudged]

Shame on you IW, this is unacceptable.

 

[SEGAvangelist]

Well no, on the desert map when he's standing on the truck in the beginning the framerate drops really hard.

I'll wait for actual first hand reports before deciding.

 

[Magwik]

I don't blame the Xbox One for how ugly this game is at all. Obviously it's not as powerful as the PS4 but it's fully capable of producing good looking games.

Infinity Ward is just a joke.

Pretty much all there is to it. You can tell by their horribly un-optimized PC version.

 

[PorkFryRice]

You don't get to a million subscribers by posting fake videos.

i guess you guys answered my concerns. this is officially xb1 footage. proceed with the haterade.

 

[CREMSteve]

If you would have told me this was 360/PS3 footage, I would have believed you.

Youtube sucks as a measuring stick.

 

[shungokusatsu]

This was played at IW studio, so it's very likely it was once again PC running xbone spec.

 

[Jibbed]

Every developer says making a game on multiple platforms is a strain. You are making excuses for them.

Jesus, just think about it for a second right.

Infinity Ward started off developing Ghosts with 70-80 people. They then had to DOUBLE in size to ensure all six versions were ready on time. I'm fully aware that Activision puts everything it's got in to each CoD title, but this strain is clearly showing in all of the technical issues we're currently arguing over.

I think the current iteration of Infinity Ward is a pathetic shadow of their former self, so again I have no idea why you think I'm making excuses. I'm trying to get my own point across which you seem unable to process.

 

[deputyspade]

Not really talking about this thread(should have stated that)

It's more about how you pretty much dump on anything Xbox. I just don't get it...If your not interested in the console, why wast so much time talking about how average everything is on it ?

You must be new here!

 

[GlassCity]

I think you misunderstand, I am interested in getting an XB1, just not yet...

A person who can read between the lines will see different from your post history, but to each their own. It's no crime to hate Xbox, I just don't get how your able to spend so much time posting about a console you don't like.

 

[NoirVisage]

gies sessler keith dent defence force unite

Unite and become Shilltron!

 

[Rising_Hei]

Byebye COD, good luck these xmas with BF4 and KZ: SF out there

 

[Dukey]

Already creating arguments based on little to no evidence. smh

Yes, you're right, multiple reviews stating exactly what I said is little to no evidence.

 

[Dragon]

A person who can read between the lines will see different from your post history, but to each their own. It's no crime to hate Xbox, I just don't get how your able to spend so much time posting about a console you don't like.

If this is your way of getting around the fact this footage is a turd nugget surrounding by turd sauce, it's not very good.

Yes, you're right, multiple reviews stating exactly what I said is little to no evidence.

Link(s)?

 

[Maidenpool?]

Unite and become Shilltron!

Haha. I wish everyone would leave Sessler alone... but Shilltron has to become a thing, no matter what.

 

[GlassCity]

If this is your way of getting around the fact this footage is a turd nugget surrounding by turd sauce, it's not very good.

Nope, In fact I said it looked not much better than current gen and would wait for direct feed footage to judge properly, but i'm sure the PS4 version will look better.

 

[Masked_Ninja]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IyEjAS0kG0&list=PLVur7hQLBzELvkfAWp4lTE6IS97Uu2MD5&index=1
Single player PS4

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Cc6wiR1tC4
Side by side PS4 PS3

 

[Dukey]

If this is your way of getting around the fact this footage is a turd nugget surrounding by turd sauce, it's not very good.



Link(s)?

Giant Bomb:

Additionally, the PlayStation 4 version has a handful of noticeable dips in its frame rate. This usually seemed to happen when a lot of smoke or other effects were on-screen, but occasionally it occurred in multiplayer for reasons I couldn't even guess at.

From Polygon:

Much has been said about the fact that the PlayStation 4 version of the game runs at a native 1080p, and while that may be true, the game did struggle to maintain a steady framerate, especially in hectic multiplayer matches. The PS3 version of the game ran into similar problems, whereas the Xbox 360 version maintained a steady 60 frames per second.

 

[infinityBCRT]

That gif is frame per frame the same as the original footage. (0:45)

May be just the conversion process from 60fps to 30fps, the footage has a shitty quality, but it looks like a dip in frame rate. If the PS360 version run smoothly, IW has fucked something up.

Could definitely be a video compression hiccup.

 

[madmackem]

Yes, you're right, multiple reviews stating exactly what I said is little to no evidence.

Ive played 4 hours now on 360 and seen numerous frame drops and stutter in mp.

 

[Skeff]

A person who can read between the lines will see different from your post history, but to each their own. It's no crime to hate Xbox, I just don't get how your able to spend so much time posting about a console you don't like.

It's not about not liking XB1, it's about not liking some things about the XB1, I also do like some things about the XB1, it's not Black or white. As a Games developer I have a vested interest in all of the next Gen consoles.

 

[BigDaddyFatSack]

Bad quality. Will wait until better footage comes out before judging. I'm expecting the frame rate to be rock solid 60fps compare to the sloppy PS4 port.

 

[rakkadakka]

It looks like Call of Duty.

Even if you play it on PC the games never look particularly great.

Sharper textures and a few other things but.. nothing on the scale of playing BF3/4 on 360 or PS3 vs PC.

 

[Majanew]

Looks just as ugly as all the other platforms running COD. Wish COD would hurry up and die.

 

[MysticGoujon]

This needn't be a console war here, IW have just done an embarrassing job across the shop, that's all their is to it.

 

[Curufinwe]

Bad quality. Will wait until better footage comes out before judging. I'm expecting the frame rate to be rock solid 60fps compare to the sloppy PS4 port.

That's probably why it's embargoed. They don't want the great news about the Xbone version coming out too soon.

 

[Dragon]

Giant Bomb:
From Polygon:

Yeah I read the GB one. I was talking specifically about the XB1 version being better on the framerate side because your original post was implying that. I don't see any information about that whatsoever.

 

[Barristan Selmy]

So, don't judge a PS4 game from youtube vids, but judge Xbox One games from youtube vids... Got it .

 

[Kacho]

I worry about those framerate dips. Yikes.

 

[Always-honest]

So, don't judge a PS4 game from youtube vids, but judge Xbox One games from youtube vids... Got it .

No, these vids look horribad. I mean the youtube compression. Best not to watch them even. But don't act like a beaten XboX-puppy

 

[MikeE21286]

That's a bad-looking current gen game

 

[nib95]

Bad quality. Will wait until better footage comes out before judging. I'm expecting the frame rate to be rock solid 60fps compare to the sloppy PS4 port.

There's frame rate drops even in these videos lol. Ahh, wishful thinking. There's been so much of it lately.

 

[Dicer]

Wii U version looks fine....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwZgXfaAfFs

 

[LabouredSubterfuge]

Why can't I set the video to 1080p? I can't see what's going on

You're so used to 4K graphics on the PC that all the sterile sharp angles have lacerated your vision.

 

[ElTorro]

Could definitely be a video compression hiccup.

Probably. Odd thing is that he turns multiple times on that bus, and the frame rate always drops. When he turns at other points on the map, the turn is much more smooth.

Anyway, the footage quality is really not good enough to reach for conclusions.

 

[deputyspade]

Bad quality. Will wait until better footage comes out before judging. I'm expecting the frame rate to be rock solid 60fps compare to the sloppy PS4 port.

Ha! Good luck with that, bigdaddy.

 

[onQ123]

Reminds me of farcry on the Xbox 1

 

[Slayer-33]

Reminds me of farcry on the Xbox 1

hahaha

 

[Hyunashi]

So, don't judge a PS4 game from youtube vids, but judge Xbox One games from youtube vids... Got it .

Here we go.
If you dont think these vids look bad then I have nothing left to say.