Just an update. It turns out that when you file your claim at Amazon, the seller gets the email and is the one responding, so he saw the email I thought I was sending to Amazon detailing everything that was made this a counterfeit. Then he sends me an email asking me to send the game back to him. I don't know the laws on these things, but I really did not want any part in mailing pirated games. Even if I wasn't going to get in trouble for it, I didn't want to spend time out of my day to box the thing up and take it to the UPS store or whatever either. So, I emailed Amazon directly and told them I didn't want to deal with this guy and spend time sending him his worthless fake game back and they gave me a full refund and I don't have to do anything. Apparently the seller could also see this email and sent me another email asking me to send the game back to him again, which I'm ignoring. Anyway, I ordered another copy which is fulfilled by Amazon from a seller with a better rep with my refund.