Yes. Simply because nothing since has managed it's narrative execution without bloat. Of course, that's okay, because while other big budget games might not be as air tight in narrative as TLOU, many others use games as a medium more to tell it's story, including it's sequel, which also has better gameplay to boot.
But anyway, if you look at all said big critically acclaimed AAA narrative driven games since TLOU. Such as GOW 18/Ragnorok, Red Dead 2, Witcher 3, Cyberpunk, even TLOU2 and many more. While some of them can match or even suprass TLOU's narrative on occasion, none of them are as consistent due to said bloat and lack of focus. I promise you, no other game could have a TV show that 80% follows it beat for beat and still end up highly acclaimed, because taken as a whole other big budget narratives simply aren't consistently good enough. TLOU is remarkably not just written and performed but
paced as a narrative,a large portion of TLOU's audience remember it line for line, beat for beat for that reason, the whole thing, not just certain moments. If this game came out for today's standards they would also make it bloated and thus less impactful aswell.