Vital Tundra
Member
abxy or the PS symbols is fine by me. Its Microsofts backwardness that bothers me. Nintendo had it first, and you go and switch it around.
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Does anyone prefer PS button controller symbols over A/B/X/Y or 1/2/3/4?
- Thread starter JinjoUnchained
- Start date
Stone Ocean
Member
I don't care about what the symbols are, just their positions.
I guess it comes from "check the box" on certain documents etc
There is enough stuff that uses each version "X O" and "O X" in different countries that's never really made me think about it too hard.
ChronotriggerJM
Member
I vastly prefer the symbols over the letters. They're just so much more fun, and the universal aspect of it is more interesting to me.
I never understood why the Japanese controllers would be using Roman alphabet to identify buttons.
I never understood why the Japanese controllers would be using Roman alphabet to identify buttons.
LordBaztion
Member
Lol, I have troubles when playing on Nintendo platforms due to the placing of the buttons, I'm too used to the xbox layout.
Also preffer R1/2/3 over RT/RB/RS. Its just easier to identify.
Also preffer R1/2/3 over RT/RB/RS. Its just easier to identify.
I like that the PS controller symbols don't lend themselves to layout issues
I have no idea why XY are above A B on Xbox, and it takes me a second to remember if I haven't played it in a bit. Also, i'll never call L1 "bumper" it makes no real sense, it's not a bumper... it's a button, and it's not shaped like a proper bumper in any fashion. WHY IS IT CALLED A BUMPER?!
I have no idea why XY are above A B on Xbox, and it takes me a second to remember if I haven't played it in a bit. Also, i'll never call L1 "bumper" it makes no real sense, it's not a bumper... it's a button, and it's not shaped like a proper bumper in any fashion. WHY IS IT CALLED A BUMPER?!
DJ_Lae
Member
I prefer the Xbox layout for whatever reason. I have no problems with Nintendo, but it is weird considering I've used a 360 controller on my PC for ages and it's just burned into my brain now.
Also have no problem with the Dual Shock symbols, though they're probably my least favourite. My daughter agrees with me there.
But I've played enough on each platform type that the only real button screw-ups come when I'm trying to remember what all the shoulder buttons on the wiimote and nunchuck are called.
Also have no problem with the Dual Shock symbols, though they're probably my least favourite. My daughter agrees with me there.
But I've played enough on each platform type that the only real button screw-ups come when I'm trying to remember what all the shoulder buttons on the wiimote and nunchuck are called.
This confused the heck out of me when I started using my PS controller on PC.
anothertech
Member
The shapes are actually easier for my little ones to understand than the letters. Makes it a little easier when they haven't learned the alphabet/numbers yet.
Other than that, it's just whatever you're used to. I love the ps shapes cause I grew up with them. So X will always be bottom and Square will always be left for me
Other than that, it's just whatever you're used to. I love the ps shapes cause I grew up with them. So X will always be bottom and Square will always be left for me
It's all buttons in the end, so nah, I don't have a preference either way; I don't get Nintendo's layout confused with Microsoft's also, so it's all gravy.
What does get me at times is when O and X are swapped for games I've imported; muscle memory usually kicks and and backs me out of menus sometimes since I'm used to the N.A. layout of X being Confirm and O being the Cancel (Usually) button.
What does get me at times is when O and X are swapped for games I've imported; muscle memory usually kicks and and backs me out of menus sometimes since I'm used to the N.A. layout of X being Confirm and O being the Cancel (Usually) button.
I don't prefer any but the a b x y (edit i mean those alphabets in any order) is seen as standard in my mind. I don't get confused with button placing either, i never thought about it even when i had a xbox and one of nintendo's systems. The changes for all just seem natural when swapping to a different system.
darkazcura
Member
I'm used to everything now, but PS symbols took a LONG time to get used to. I started gaming "for real" with the N64, and Nintendo flipping between their layouts every generation threw me off a bit. SNES, Wii, and Wii U have a consistent format of the buttons, but since I started with the N64, I was used to A being below B and being the main action button so to speak. With the Gamecube they flipped A and B to be like it was with the SNES, but A was larger so it still felt like the main button (the lower most button). X and Y were on the right side with Y on top which is flipped from SNES..and then with the Wii, they went back to the SNES days with X on top (and to the left of A/B instead of to the right like with GCN). Definitely threw me off at first, but I'm used to it now for the most part. X and Y still throw me off sometimes. I'm so used to Y being on top from Gamecube, Xbox, and Xbox 360.
Backfoggen
Banned
I may be alone on this but the symbols feel like a weird 90s left over. Saying circle, triangle instead of just A or B etc. also seems way unwieldy to me.
I can understand why they went with it and now that it's iconic keep going with it but it still feels weird.
I can understand why they went with it and now that it's iconic keep going with it but it still feels weird.
shiftplusone
Member
pizza boxes/hamburger
thechristoph
Sir!
Button names should not be more than one syllable when you say it out loud.
What is different about "memorize the input and i'm good" if it's letters or symbols?
Leafhopper
Banned
I tolerate them. Never really cared for them.
TheLastCandle
Member
ABYX for life.
Although, I would prefer the trigggers on Nintendo's controllers to be called L2 and R2, instead of ZL and ZR.
Although, I would prefer the trigggers on Nintendo's controllers to be called L2 and R2, instead of ZL and ZR.
Stilton Disco
Member
I instantly prefered triangle, circle, X and square from the moment I started using a PS1.
AB(C) XY(Z) never really made sense to me, and just started to get ridiculous once Nintendo went crazy with the C buttons/stick and ZL and ZR nonsense. Same with L1/2/3 and R1/2/3, so much better than the competition, even if I do appreciate the terms bumpers and triggers to tell the upper and lower shoulder buttons apart.
Worst of all though, is the way Nintendo and Xbox use the same face buttons, but in different places. That always confuses the shit out of me when I'm switching between their consoles.
AB(C) XY(Z) never really made sense to me, and just started to get ridiculous once Nintendo went crazy with the C buttons/stick and ZL and ZR nonsense. Same with L1/2/3 and R1/2/3, so much better than the competition, even if I do appreciate the terms bumpers and triggers to tell the upper and lower shoulder buttons apart.
Worst of all though, is the way Nintendo and Xbox use the same face buttons, but in different places. That always confuses the shit out of me when I'm switching between their consoles.
2002whitegt
Member
Coming from PC and Xbox 360 the ABXY is my go to, took a while to get used to PS square when I got a PS4, I really liked the DS4, and use it on PC even if I get the prompts on screen for ABXY the button placement is ingrained, so no need to look at controller.
Playing Madden on PS4 for the first few weeks sucked cause I would see a receiver with the PS "x" and hit the ABXY "x". It was really frustrating.
Playing Madden on PS4 for the first few weeks sucked cause I would see a receiver with the PS "x" and hit the ABXY "x". It was really frustrating.
ldcommando
Banned
abxy because snes
it's probably that i haven't played enough on any playstation console, but everytime i do the buttons confuse the crap out of me, because
1) i'm not clear as to how to call them (which sounds a bit silly but it adds confusion) and
2) there's no natural order to those symbols unlike the pretty clear concept of the alphabet.. like with ABXY i just need to know that A is in the bottom left or bottom right position and everything else makes sense somehow, but since my brain doesn't have any concept of how to put the PS symbols in order, i always have to look down onto the controller.
obviously i could get used to it eventually, i just never got as to why they went with those in the first place, since in my mind it just adds confusion..
1) i'm not clear as to how to call them (which sounds a bit silly but it adds confusion) and
2) there's no natural order to those symbols unlike the pretty clear concept of the alphabet
.. like with ABXY i just need to know that A is in the bottom left or bottom right position and everything else makes sense somehow, but since my brain doesn't have any concept of how to put the PS symbols in order, i always have to look down onto the controller.obviously i could get used to it eventually, i just never got as to why they went with those in the first place, since in my mind it just adds confusion..
digitalrelic
Banned
I love Playstation. It's my console of choice. I think the DS4 is the most comfortable controller out there. That said, I hate the button symbols, specifically circle and square. They're too damn hard to tell apart! Especially in a game where split second decisions need to be made all the time! Like in Madden, when I see a receiver wide open just as I'm being sacked and hit circ-nope, that was actually square. Circle throws it right to the defender.
What genius thought it would be a great idea to make one button pink and another one red? Argh
You can't tell me those two buttons couldn't be easily confused, especially when they're being displayed at a really small size like they usually are in sports games.
What genius thought it would be a great idea to make one button pink and another one red? Argh
You can't tell me those two buttons couldn't be easily confused, especially when they're being displayed at a really small size like they usually are in sports games.
It's a brain thing. Some are better with shapes than letters or numbers, some are better with numbers or letters than shapes, while others are good with both. Many in this thread are showing signs of that by just saying "____ never made sense to me"
EDIT: One example comes from me. I'm not that great with shapes, but if something maintains the same button mapping layout it's easier to transition and get used to it. I'm probably quicker on the draw with L1, L2, R1, R2 buttons than anything because I can quickly map 1 and 2 to where they belong.
I dont really prefer one over the other....but switching playing time between consoles can cause problems.
Like this..
I even have problems going from PS3 to 360 at times.
This too. I think in some games its hard to tell which button is which. And is irritating for QTE if it isnt colored or shaped good, correctly . And I have done that in Madden too. I have to make sure I see a preview of the play, routes ran, study it enough...and still mess up sometimes...lol.
Like this..
I even have problems going from PS3 to 360 at times.
I love Playstation. It's my console of choice. I think the DS4 is the most comfortable controller out there. That said, I hate the button symbols, specifically circle and square. They're too damn hard to tell apart! Especially in a game where split second decisions need to be made all the time! Like in Madden, when I see a receiver wide open just as I'm being sacked and hit circ-nope, that was actually square. Circle throws it right to the defender.
What genius thought it would be a great idea to make one button pink and another one red? Argh
You can't tell me those two buttons couldn't be easily confused, especially when they're being displayed at a really small size like they usually are in sports games.
This too. I think in some games its hard to tell which button is which. And is irritating for QTE if it isnt colored or shaped good, correctly . And I have done that in Madden too. I have to make sure I see a preview of the play, routes ran, study it enough...and still mess up sometimes...lol.
I have never grown completely used to it. I still have to look down at the controller at times, or at the very least, *think* about it for brief moment when shown a prompt on occasion.
The Xbox layout bothers me, too. I grew up playing SNES and that shit is so ingrained in me that the Xbox layout using the same labelling, but switching which is which fucks me up sometimes as well.
I think this is more a symptom of how impactful learning things at a young age can be on somebody later on. I've probably played more on PS and Xbox controllers than I did the SNES controller altogether, but it still messes up once in a while.
The Xbox layout bothers me, too. I grew up playing SNES and that shit is so ingrained in me that the Xbox layout using the same labelling, but switching which is which fucks me up sometimes as well.
I think this is more a symptom of how impactful learning things at a young age can be on somebody later on. I've probably played more on PS and Xbox controllers than I did the SNES controller altogether, but it still messes up once in a while.
AwesomeMeat
PossumMeat
I prefer the DS4. I couldn't care less what the symbols, letters, etc are. I use it as a PC controller primarily which gives me a lot of xbox controller prompts but the positions for either are burned in to my skull.
Wow, I had no idea. Now THAT is confusing.
DJ_Lae
Member
What genius thought it would be a great idea to make one button pink and another one red? Argh
You can't tell me those two buttons couldn't be easily confused, especially when they're being displayed at a really small size like they usually are in sports games.
The symbols make them easy to tell apart, though. I'm colourblind and couldn't really tell you what colour each symbol is unless I stare at it for a while.
Same way I kind of like the transforming dpad version of the 360 controller, as making all the buttons grey is almost an improvement for me over having them different colours.
Mass Effect
Member
Why is everyone blaming Microsoft for the A/B X/Y reversal? Didn't Sega do it with the Dreamcast first?
Commanche Raisin Toast
Member
Yes.
It's easier for me to see a button prompt on screen and know what to press, as opposed to controllers with numbers or letters because sometimes different companies change up which letters/numbers go where, and even with the (nearly) standardized layout scheme it's still confusing to use letters.
It's easier for me to see a button prompt on screen and know what to press, as opposed to controllers with numbers or letters because sometimes different companies change up which letters/numbers go where, and even with the (nearly) standardized layout scheme it's still confusing to use letters.
CountAntonius
Member
ABXY is the best.
xenorevlis
Member
While I didn't mind A/B X/Y (and ABC / XYZ) from Sega days, I think the PS symbols make the most sense globally.
K
kittens
Unconfirmed Member
I don't care.
silver.tongue
Member
Too good.
digitalrelic
Banned
When made into small icons on a TV screen, circle and square look similar enough that they can be confused, especially when their colors are also similar (pink vs red). I've confused the two countless times in split-second decisions.