Just my humble opinion. I'm looking forward to the xbox one and I think the system IS delivering some potentially awesome experiences. I have no idea about the value aspect because I have no clue about what the doo dads cost within the machine. What I do know is that I am very excited for the voice controls, tv stuff, and nfl integration. Yes, I am one of the heathens that does not care about the drm and used game stuff. I think 500 bucks is a good price for what they are delivering.
The thing is, I bought the 360 and ps3 in my late twenties. I am now in my mid thirties. Xbox one is appealing to the older gamer in me. As I get older, games are becoming less important for me and watching tv/sports and having other cool shit to play around with is becoming more important.
I also think when customers see the displays/kiosks in the store for Xbox One and PS4, they are going to see what the machine can do, not what it's taking away from you. I feel that MS' list of "can do's" is going to dwarf the PS4's list. Now, if Sony wants to go the marketing route of "Look what our competition is taking away from you.", I don't know if that's the best thing to do. It works in gaming forums and E3 where the majority of people are gamers and are really passionate about these issues, but will the general public really care about the drm/used game/internet functions when Apple/Kindle/phones function in a similar fashion? I don't know.
I'll end this post like this: I'm buying a PS4 for MLB the Show. The PS3 is/was my official MLB the Show box. But I have absolutely no excitement, besides graphics, for what the PS4 is doing for gaming. With MS, I see them trying to do something different. I see things like Illumiroom and neat Kinect stuff. I like the tv and sports stuff. I think the cloud shit sounds neat. I like new tech and seeing new ideas. Since this IS a luxury item, I don't mind a company breaking a few eggs to try new things.