-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
EA Sports trailer: #teamreal or #teamcg?
- Thread starter chubigans
- Start date
Balmung421
Member
#teamcg
Looked way too similar to me when compared to the xbox 360 madden reveal.
Looked way too similar to me when compared to the xbox 360 madden reveal.
Baldwin_the_First
Member
CG. No way in hell will EA be able to implement the Pettis Kick from the cage in-game! ..No way in hell.
CassidyIzABeast
Member
Tiburon is incapable of such animation, cg.
HueyFreeman
Banned
Seemed like all the Xbox One unveilings had a similar graphic quality to them, sort of an early CG look - hard to explain, the closest I can come up with is like PS2/PSP CG. That sounds like a dig - but it's really not, just trying to find an analogue to that similar texture
Given that, I feel like they were all in engine, logic dictating if you were going to go CG, you'd make it more impressive than the graphics that were shown. If they were real time, really impressive stuff.
Given that, I feel like they were all in engine, logic dictating if you were going to go CG, you'd make it more impressive than the graphics that were shown. If they were real time, really impressive stuff.
ReturnOfTheRAT
Member
CG and not that impressive.
E3 should have actual gameplay across devices.
E3 should have actual gameplay across devices.
See You Next Wednesday
Banned
BLAH
CRUDDY CGI that didn't even look as good as their CGI 8 years ago when they reveled games for 360 & PS3.
CRUDDY CGI that didn't even look as good as their CGI 8 years ago when they reveled games for 360 & PS3.
It was done by a visual effects house.
You guys do realize that real-time rendered computer graphics is...CG? Shocking, I know!
So it should be #teamprerender vs. #teamrealtime. Not as catchy, admittedly.
Personally, I think it was a real-time rendered cinematic, but not using the actual in-game engine. I know EA is a little sleazy, but when they say "This is what our games will look on One", and then show a cinematic that was pre-rendered on a super computer...that's going too far.
So it should be #teamprerender vs. #teamrealtime. Not as catchy, admittedly.
Personally, I think it was a real-time rendered cinematic, but not using the actual in-game engine. I know EA is a little sleazy, but when they say "This is what our games will look on One", and then show a cinematic that was pre-rendered on a super computer...that's going too far.
SatelliteOfLove
Member
After last gen's Madden bullshots, any who are in this #teamreal camp are also shopping for a bridge in Arizona.
giancarlo123x
Banned
CG all the way. Reminded me so much of the Madden 06 reveal on 360.
Thug Waffle
Member
I was about 70% sure the entire EA trailer featured bullshots. This means we got less than a minute of true next-gen gameplay footage (I'm excluding CoD: Ghosts because it seriously looked like it came out two years ago...) in a one-hour reveal. Awful.
Anyone remember?
I can see this being rendered in real time on a PS3. Just not as actual gameplay.
Uncle Rupee
Banned
Whether it was pre-rendered or real-time, you won't be seeing the game from those camera angles unless it's a replay.
Most of the time, the camera will be panned way out so you can see the playing field. At that distance, it'll be impossible to notice the fine grain details.
Most of the time, the camera will be panned way out so you can see the playing field. At that distance, it'll be impossible to notice the fine grain details.
That's besides the point though, I think. Hopefully everyone is aware of that. But people are flat-out saying that it couldn't be rendered on the One in real time, which I think is rather presumptuous.
Bomber Bob
Banned
everything was pre rendered
even the #XBOXONE was pre rendered lol
even the #XBOXONE was pre rendered lol
Madden 06 (360) called and it wants it's trailer back.
No way Madden is going to look that good, it's fucking EA, they're going to 1/2 ass it just like they have all this gen.
Also, EA hasn't put out a NBA game in two years and now they've figured it out on brand new hardware, yeah right.
No way Madden is going to look that good, it's fucking EA, they're going to 1/2 ass it just like they have all this gen.
Also, EA hasn't put out a NBA game in two years and now they've figured it out on brand new hardware, yeah right.
Anyone remember?
this 2006 CG looks better than the one showed
Anticitizen One
Banned
At the Xbox Conference today
"What we are about to show you is your first look at actual in game footage of our new sports line up for Xbox One" - EA guy
*Shows trailer that has ps2 era CGI*
I mean come the fuck on. That's not in game footage. Why did they even bother to come on stage just to piss us off?
I'm really starting to dislike the way these big game companies are trying to hoodwink consumers. Thank God for sites and forums like Gaf that act as watchdogs.
"What we are about to show you is your first look at actual in game footage of our new sports line up for Xbox One" - EA guy
*Shows trailer that has ps2 era CGI*
I mean come the fuck on. That's not in game footage. Why did they even bother to come on stage just to piss us off?
I'm really starting to dislike the way these big game companies are trying to hoodwink consumers. Thank God for sites and forums like Gaf that act as watchdogs.
Thug Waffle
Member
Yeah, some of the running animations just look silly.
If NBA 2K can implement specific players' jumpshots, EA can afford to frickin' include player-specific throwing motions.
bernardobri
Steve, the dog with no powers that we let hang out with us all for some reason
Sales of the new Sim City proved it, somehow.
Darkangel
Member
friskykillface
Banned
everyone in the live trailer was skinny as hell.
at least jesus Bynum is back
the madden vid from 05' was better then the madden vid in 13'
at least jesus Bynum is back
the madden vid from 05' was better then the madden vid in 13'
That looks more impressive though
EA did the exact same thing 8 years ago. Why would it bother you now?
Raging Spaniard
If they are Dutch, upright and breathing they are more racist than your favorite player
Heres the thing, if they had real time gameplay to show then THEY WOULD SHOW IT instead of showing a shitload of wireframes and wip models in Maya
A Sentient Keyboard
Member
Because Simcity over a million.
EDIT: Beaten handily
EDIT: Beaten handily
Byronic Hero
Member
This is exactly what I thought of when I was watching it.
Yup they sure did