• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Games that are 10\10 in your book

Earthbound: Best video game story, puts last of us to shame
kidding last of us has a very different story compared to earthbound
, game play that does its best not to annoy the player. Interesting locales and god like soundtrack, what could be better.

and

super smash bros melee, greatest fighting game ever made, fast paced and the freestyle type gameplay where you create your own combos using a direction plus a or b is just amazing.

honourable mentions:cave story, stronghold crusader, gunbound, halo ce
 
I usually 10/10 the games I have a blast with from start to finish (so my list is kinda big)

grim fandango
akai katana
team fortress classic
muramasa: the demon blade
earthbound
planescape: torment
the sea will claim everything
demon's souls
chrono trigger
super mario rpg: legends of the seven stars
diablo 2
devil may cry 3
super metroid
xenogears
castlevania: circle of the moon
mother 3
ibara
sin & punishment: star successor
battle garegga
esp ra.de.
zone of the enders: the 2nd runner
ico
armed police batrider
progear
psyvariar 2: the will to fabricate
bayonetta
 
Myth the Fallen Lords

Myth_-_The_Fallen_Lords.jpg



Myth II Soulblighter

1305212613_pic.jpg

Damn, well theres a nostalgia trip. I remember I used to backseat game this with my cousin all the time when I was a kid.
 
Indigo Prophecy - Man I remember the first time I played this game. I was always into cinematic experiences but this just came as a shock to me. One of the best gaming experiences of all time. Heavy Rain and Beyond: Two Souls were also superb, but Indigo Prophecy is just so embedded in my mind that I have to put it above them. I also learned how great Theory of a Deadman is because of this game.

Resident Evil 4 - You already know exactly why.

Metal Gear Solid 3 - My first time with the series started with this one, and OMG what an amazing experience. Story, characters, cinematics, gameplay, graphics... Everything was just perfect for me.

God Hand - One of the funniest, most awesome brawlers ever made with a deep combat system, intense boss fights and controls that demand reflexes and strategy. All that put together with crazy characters and a goofy story and you get an unforgettable experience.

There are probably more but these are the ones that came up to me right now.
 
It's hard to say 10/10 because even the games I love have their own little flaws that could bother others, but I'll try anyways

Majora's Mask
Earthbound
Resident Evil 4
Super Mario Galaxy 1/2
Batman Arkham City
Super Mario 3D World
Xenoblade Chronicles
Psychonauts
Sans Meat Circus
Star Wars KOTOR
Metal Gear Solid 3
Portal 1/2
 
It's hard to say 10/10 because even the games I love have their own little flaws that could bother others, but I'll try anyways

Majora's Mask
Earthbound
Resident Evil 4
Super Mario Galaxy 1/2
Batman Arkham City
Super Mario 3D World
Xenoblade Chronicles
Psychonauts
Sans Meat Circus
Star Wars KOTOR
Metal Gear Solid 3
Portal 1/2

You have great taste, I tried to get into psychonauts on steam last year but it felt a little to dated for me, wish I had played it when it came out.
 
The Last of Us is the only game I'd give a 10/10 to. That's my favorite game of all time.

I'd give a 9.8 to Fallout 3 (2nd favorite) and a 9.7 to Resident Evil 4 (3rd favorite).

Honorable mention to Uncharted 2.
 
Samurai shodown 2
Real Bout 2 Fatal Fury Special
Snk vs Capcom (neogeo pocket)
Revenge of Shinobi
Super Castlevania IV
Super Metroid
Super Mario Kart
Castlevania Rondo of Blood
Resident Evil
Castlevania SOTN
MGS
MGS2
MGS3
God of War 2
Splinter Cell Chaos Theory
Advance Wars
Uncharted 2
Motorstorm Pacific Rift
Tlou
 
You have great taste, I tried to get into psychonauts on steam last year but it felt a little to dated for me, wish I had played it when it came out.

It has aged a bit and based on the Meat Circus alone, I'd say Tim Schafer wasn't the best at level design. It carries itself for me based on humor and collectathon aspects and is really fun
And for whatever reason, the XBLA download doesn't work on my 360 anymore *Grumble grumble*
 
1) Deus Ex

Dxcover.jpg


Ohhh, Warren Spector. What hast happened to thou ever since this peak of your career?

Isn't player agency great? To essentially let the player choose to tackle a mission their way rather than prodding them with this long stick to prompt them the one or maybe two "proper" ways of doing it? Deus Ex knows. One of the most exquisite bits of game design I've seen.

2) Red Dead Redemption

Red_Dead_Redemption.jpg


This is an open-world game done right, set in a surprisingly underused and excellently-realised western setting approaching its eve brimming with the details and a genuine atmosphere. Its inhabitants feel like people and virtually every mission or random encounter has been worth playing, unlike something like I dunno, Assassin's Creed 3 which despite having a bukkake load of content, are mostly banal and uninteresting.

3) The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past

The_Legend_of_Zelda_A_Link_to_the_Past_SNES_Game_Cover.jpg


This one might be largely down to the nostalgia factor given the fact that it's one of the first videogames I have ever touched, and thus something that commands considerable eminence in my heart. And for good reason as well. My mind was blown when I realised that with the Light and Dark world system, the game overworld had virtually doubled in size. LBW, Ocarina, Majora and Wind Waker have all been great, but LTTP continues to be my favourite Zelda.

4) Shadow of the Colossus

Sotc_boxart.jpg


I'm never going to forget this game. My other 10/10 choices are excellent games, but this one will be the game I will forget last. If I'm looking for absolute perfection in a game, this is as close as I will probably get to it. The frenetic puzzle fights against the Colossi themselves, the hauntingly bleak yet beautiful landscape, the perfect atmosphere and the surprisingly distressing story all done with virtually no dialogue script at all.

SOME excellent 9/10 shoutouts:

- Morrowind - would be a 10, but I've never been too entranced by that Elder Scrolls combat.

- Skyrim - see above. I just wish I was able to play this on PC, but alas...

- Final Fantasy VI - It's been demoted to a 9 because given my gradual drifting away from turn-based combat, I'm not quite itching to replay this one as some others.

- TimeSplitters 2 - The few difficulty spikes irked me a bit at the time, but still my favourite FPS game ever.

- Xenoblade Chronicles - A couple of bosses cheat and sidequests mundane, but perhaps as close to JRPG perfection as it can get for me in recent memory.

- Batman Arkham City - Story isn't as strong as in Asylum, but this time round boss fights are considerably more satisfying as they should be.

- Zelda: Majora's Mask - Hello, says Majora's Mask, I'm the second best Zelda game and I deserve a 3DS updated port! Yes, I say. Yes you are and yes you do.

- The Last Of Us - It's been a hell of a stressful game to play, I have to say, especially when cauliflower-faces decide to start munching me to death with one hit.

- GTA V - The way Online has turned out is the big mark against it, but the game has made a fan out of someone who used to be rather apathetic towards the franchise.

- Metal Gear Solid 3 - I'm still having an internal debate here. Do I upgrade this one to a 10/10?
 
Well, Final Fantasy XII, Chrono Trigger, Shadow of the Colossus, Link's Awakening and Pokemon Gold/Silver are my all time favorite, so I'll go with them.
 
I have so many personal 10's in mind, most of them with a lot of nostalgia value:

1_mp1g5uir.jpg
2_rtcw164u6d.jpg


3_nfsu2sxui8.jpg
4_sof1xxuex.jpg


5_gtavc77ukq.jpg
6_hl2k8u0r.jpg


Also:
- Ocarina of Time
- Need for Speed Porsche Unleashed
- World of Warcraft (the very first one, without expansions)
- Deep Duck Trouble
- Deus Ex: HR
- Mirror's Edge

And probably a lot more, if I would think about it for another 5 minutes.
 
KOTOR II
Stalker: Shadow of Chernobyl
Mount and Blade Warband
Rainbow Six 3
Dark Souls
Age of Empires 2
Fallout: New Vegas
Hotline Miami
Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory
DOOM
Chaos Theory
Battlefront 1
Ys 1&2
 
Zelda - Ocarina of Time
Persona 4
Resident Evil 4
Resident Evil Remake
Metal Gear Solid 2
Metal Gear Solid 3
Metal Gear Solid Ground Zeroes (yes, short, expensive, but perfect.)
Vanquish (yea, i said it)
Bayonetta
Dark Souls with Artorias of the Abyss, on PC (console not perfect due to mediocre performance)
Fire Emblem Awakening
Zelda Link Between Worlds
Kid Icarus Uprising
DKC tropical Freeze
Super Mario 3D World
Wonderful 101 (lol at it's scores, thumb-less reviewers)
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Metroid Prime Trilogy Wii
Ikaruga
Super Mario 64
Halo Combat Evolved
Devil May Cry 4 (that's right, 4)
Makaimura Gaiden
Street Fighter Zero 3 (spent a fortune on this one back at the arcade days, and won triple that on bets)

Bah, if i stay up i'll think of even more, better go to bed.
 
GTA:San Andreas
Red Dead Redemption
Half-Life
Half-Life 2
Bioshock 1
Uncharted 2
The Last of Us
Resident Evil 4
Fallout 3

... A lot more that I can't remember right now.
 
Half-Life 2
Uncharted 2
Resident Evil 4
Final Fantasy VII
Crash Team Racing
Metal Gear Solid 3
Spyro 3
Tomb Raider 1
Red Dead Redemption
GTA Vice City
 
Super Metroid
Galaxy
Zelda albw
Mario 3
Little big adventure
Curse of monkey island
Remake
Warcraft 3
Planescape
Half life

Many handheld game
 
Super Metroid - My favorite game of all time. 100 percented it for the first time when it came to WiiU Virtual Console. I can't find a single fault with it.
IMO, as utterly amazing as Super Metroid is, there is in fact one glaring flaw with it:

It ends :(
 
Mario 64 (N64)
Phantasy Star Online (Dreamcast)
Total Annihilation (PC)

These are the only games I've ever played that had absolutely no margin for improvement. As their subsequent follow-ups proved.
 
Bayonetta: Never have had this much fun playing a game. My all time favorite ever.
Devil May Cry 3 and 4: Close second to Bayonetta.
Ninja Gaiden Black: Completes the Holy Trinity of action games.
Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2: Still the best of all Mario games.
Half-Life 2: Enjoy it immensely from time to time even after so long.
World in Conflict: Oh god this game, the multiplayer was so good.
Civilization 4: So many turns. So many lost nights.
Galactic Civilizations 2: Even more nights gone.
The Last of Us: So many feelings. So satisfying when it was all over.
Tons more, too tired to go through them all.

Honorable mention, not quite a 10/10, but very close.
Spec Ops: The Line: In the flood of generic shooters with the same dudebro story over and over, this game comes out and just flips it all over its head and just makes me depressed. And happy at the same time. Gameplay itself could have been a little better.
 
mirror's edge. it sticks around as long as it needs to, doesn't make you do any more than you have to, and lets rewards you when you think outside the box. thanks to its artstyle, it's going to age slowly when it does, and the music is just fantastic.

super mario galaxy 2. like mirror's edge, i was surprised at how tight and well-designed this was. it's also a good deal longer than mirror's edge, but challenges are mixed up to a pretty insane degree. the green star challenges blew my mind too, forcing the player to consider to think of the entire levels, not just the obstacles in front of them, when it came to solving problems. just amazing.

i don't know which others reach those heights. beyond good & evil probably does. despite its age, it's a pretty tight game and doesn't stick around longer than it needs to. it also integrated cutscenes into gameplay better than most current games do, and gave the player a better feeling of accomplishment in the things it has you do for the story (something modern game-filmmakers like david cage or naughty dog could learn from). and it's topped off by the wonderful soundtrack from christophe heral. i can't believe the sequel is just around the corner.

honorable mentions: skies of arcadia, valkyria chronicles, twilight princess, and resident evil 4.
 
I'll stick to 7th gen games because it would take too long to comb over the last 30+ years:

kwy5RV0.jpg


Mushihimesama Futari - Six modes (or nine if you include version 1.01), each with a skill ceiling that very few people could ever reach, complete with flawless stage design and bullet patterns, an easy to understand, yet hard to master scoring system in each mode, a good soundtrack, and beautiful art design. Simply put, it's the greatest game of all time.
Dodonpachi Daioujou Black Label - This also includes White Label, which I've started to like more than BL for balance reasons. Regardless, Daioujou added hypers to the Donpachi formula, which is exactly what it needed. It keeps the chaining from feeling too dry and makes it much more interesting to come up with new strategies. The second loop is also wonderful, as they took the time to recreate every bullet pattern to make it more difficult instead of taking the lazy way out and throwing a mess of suicide bullets at the player. Plus the soundtrack is still one of Namiki's best. (On a side note, I actually like Saidaioujou more than DOJ, but a bug completely rekt the balance of that game. I couldn't give it a 10, at least not until I've played version 1.5 extensively.)
Akai Katana - One of Cave's most unorthodox games, but I love absolutely everything about it. The scoring systems in both the arcade version and Shin, all three shot types, the stages, the bosses, the art, the music - everything. Hell, even the bugs in the arcade version help make the game better.
Espgaluda II - The game can be difficult to grasp at first because of all of the different systems and mechanics, but it's incredibly fun once you understand the flow of scoring. It's the perfect evolution of the original game's formula. So much so, that I fully believe Cave never made a sequel because they couldn't figure out what they could do to improve it further (the same can be said for Futari).
Ninja Gaiden II - The pinnacle of action gaming. High difficulty, nine different weapons with huge movesets, vicious AI, and perhaps most importantly, it's the only game in the genre with a scoring system worth taking seriously (unfortunately, it's exclusive to survival mode).
Mega Man 9 - If it's not the best game in the series, it's right up there with MM2. Challenging and creative stage design, great music, great boss fights and powerups. It's everything I could want out of a Mega Man game.
Virtua Fighter 5: Final Showdown - I'm hesitant to list this because I haven't played it a ton (Goh is the only character I'm decent with), but it's still my favorite 3D fighting game ever. Top notch netcode and all of the customization options certainly help.
Ouendan 2 - The oddball of the group, but I love the Ouendan/EBA system too much to not include it. Great music, great note charts, lots of difficulty options, extremely stylish.
Tetris: The Grand Master 3 - The ultimate Tetris game. What else needs to be said?

There are a bunch of other games I'd say are borderline 10/10s, but there's something about all of them that prevents me from putting them in the same class as the above.
 
For shooters, Halo everything but 4. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed 4, but it wasn't quite on the same level as its numbered predecessors.

Company of Heroes is quite easily the best RTS I've ever played, the cover system for infantry was a game changer.

In my MMO space, nothing comes close to the Burning Crusade, mostly for introducing me to my beloved space goats. The atmosphere, the end game encounters, the music, the class changes... Just untouchable.

And my absolute favorite in this list is Diablo II: Lord of Destruction. I burnt so many hours in that game and regretted not a single one. Just pure fun. Although, Reaper of Souls is starting to catch up to it. Time will tell.
 
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty


Honestly, every Metal Gear experience has been a "10/10" experience for me. But I figured I should only choose one, and so I have to go with the one that will always be closest to my heart: Metal Gear Solid 2. I will never forget playing through this game for the first time, as it was the first Metal Gear I was able to play to completion (due to not having the PlayStation to complete MGS1). My first playthrough clear time was just over 37 hours, despite playing on the easiest available difficulty...
To say that I was bad at video games would be an emphatic understatement.
I can't recall the exact number of alert phases I triggered or soldiers I killed, but damn it, by the time I had finished the game, I felt that it all mattered - in some way. Metal Gear Solid 2 is not just a game, it is a narrative, and a masterful one at that. The story, the characters, the setting, the music, the attention to detail, the gameplay - each facet supports the technological masterpiece that is Metal Gear Solid 2.

Persona 4 | Persona 4: Golden


The game that rekindled my passion for role-playing games, Persona 4. This is probably the most accessible and light-hearted game within the Shin Megami Tensei franchise, and some would argue that it's a casualized dating sim... For me, though, those factors played a huge part in making this a "10/10" experience. Like many, Persona 4 was my first real experience with the series. I honestly had no idea what to expect, and what I discovered was a franchise that I had fallen in love with. If not for Persona 4 easing me into the world of Shin Megami Tensei, I would have been overwhelmed by previous entries in the series (as well as the SMT series, itself - no, especially the SMT series, itself). Many will tell you that Persona 4 is one of those games that takes "X" hours to get into. I'm not sure I necessarily agree with that... I think it's one of those love it-or-hate it kind of games for a lot of people. Fortunately enough for me, however, I love it, and have since gone back to play through previous installments of Persona and SMT.
 
I'm playing RollerCoaster Tycoon now, I love the combination of management and how you solve problems such as lack of space by being creative. It has the right amount of depth as a tycoon game, a solid sandbox foundation and some micro-management. Some of the game elements are unrealistic and can be argued being flaws, but they totally work if you accept them as game logic imo.
 
I would only give a 10 to games that caused me to lose sleep and made me addicted..

Smb2
Legend of zelda snes
Chrono trigger
Wing commander 2 - 11/10
Tekkken 2
Street fighter2
Ff7
Gta vice city
Cod 4
Bfbc2
Fallout3
Oblivion
 
Final Fantasy VI
GTA: Vice City
GTA V
Red Dead Redemption
Chrono Trigger
Final Fantasy IX
Fallout 2
Morrowind
Super Mario World
Max Payne 2
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
Halo: Combat Evolved
 
Ocarina of Time
Link to the Past
Crono Trigger
Super Metroid
GTA 5
Red Dead Redemption
Secret of Mana
Mario 3
Tie Fighter
FF6
Morrowind
Oblivion
Wing Commander 3
Half Life 2
Civ 4
Mega Man 2
Mega Man X
GTA San Andreas

Ok, my list is getting way too long
 
Planescape: Torment (even with the combat)
Fallout 2
Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura
Witcher 2
9 Hours, 9 Persons, 9 Doors
Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of TIme
Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker
Super Mario 3D World
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze
Chrono Trigger
Dragon Quest V
Gotic II+ expansion
Halo 3
Unreal Tournament GOTY
World of Warcraft
StarCraft
Civilization V with all expansions
Alpha Centauri
Diablo I and II
Pokémon Yellow
Pokémon Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald
Pokémon X/Y
 
Super Mario Bros. 3
Mega Man 2
Chrono Trigger
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
Super Mario World
Yoshi's Island
Super Metroid
Pokemon Red/Blue
Super Mario 64
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Paper Mario
Ape Escape
Crash Bandicoot
Crash Bandicoot 2
Metal Gear Solid
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
Metroid Prime
Jak and Daxter
Kingdom Hearts
Metal Gear Solid 2
Metal Gear Solid 3
Okami
Persona 3
Persona 4
Ratchet & Clank 3
Mario Kart DS
Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver
Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep
Donkey Kong Country Returns
Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Xenoblade
Demon's Souls
Dragon's Dogma
Metal Gear Rising
Ratchet & Clank: A Crack in Time
Rayman Origins
Kid Icarus: Uprising
The Wonderful 101
 
Only 2 games:

Chromehounds: Absolute peak of multiplayer gaming. Chose a country with your squad, fight for that country with completely customizable mechs to make money, take part in electing officials for that country, read the newspaper ingame, completely strategic slow-paced gameplay. Nothing comes close to matching it.

Escape Velocity Nova: The only game to ever pull off chocie without it being an illusion that I've played. What you chose to do in game completely changes what missions you take on, what factions you side with, the scale of the ending from the game. The endings ranged from simply becoming a competent pirate captain to bringing peace to the galaxy. You could spend the entire game just playing with the economic side of buying and selling good across the galaxy with a merchant fleet. Story was awesome, gameplay was tight, this is a game I cannot find a fault with.

No other games reach 10/10 for me.
 
Ocarina of Time
Final Fantasy VI
Earthbound
Chrono Trigger
Tetris Attack
Marvel vs Capcom 2
Bayonetta

There's a ton I am forgetting for sure but these stand out in my head without reading the rest of the thread first. Interesting that most of them are 16-bit era. I guess they've been allowed the time to percolate more than the others?

Maybe Mario 3D World? That game was awesome.
 
The Last of Us
Uncharted 2
Modern Warfare
Red Dead Redemption
Mass Effect 2
Skyrim
Halo CE, Halo Reach
Half-life 1-E2
Killzone 2
Perfect Dark 64
Turok 2
UT99
Crysis
Doom 3
MGS1-3
Portal
Fallout 3
Deus Ex 1 and HR
Starcraft



a bunch of others.


No 10/10 is not perfection.
 
Dark souls
Half Life 2
Super Mario 64
The last of Us
Oddworld Abe's Exoddus
Ninja Gaiden Black
Gears of War
Super Street Fighter 4
Counter Strike (not source)
BioShock
Bayonetta
Riven
DMC3
Ocarina of Time
Majora's Mask
PYST
 
Red Dead Redemption
Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario 64
GoldenEye
Lego City Undercover
GTA V
Pac-Man
Zelda: LTTP
Zelda: Ocarina
Resident Evil 4
Resident Evil GCN
Shenmue
Soul Calibur 2
Super Metroid
Halo CE
Wii Sports
Go Vacation
Fishing Resort
The Warriors
 
If I'm not interested in playing it [again] right now, it's not 10/10. So, in alphabetical order:

1) Bayonetta (360)
2) Metroid Prime (Wii)
3) Metroid Zero Mission (GBA)
4) Resident Evil 4 (Wii)
5) Super Street Fighter II Turbo (Arcade)


Dragon's Dogma, Guardian of Light, and Guacamelee might belong somewhere up there, too, but they're too fresh in my mind to judge fairly. And Ninja Gaiden Black probably deserves a spot as well, but I haven't played it in years and memories of Sigma are difficult to separate. I'd also like to stick RE2 or REmake in there (maybe RE5 as well), although I haven't played either recently, and some representative from each of Advance Wars, Castlevania, Fire Emblem, The Legend of Zelda, and Super Mario Bros. surely warrants representation. Probably Street Fighter IV as well, though I have a love-hate relationship with that series. Chrono Trigger should get a mention, too, but I have no desire to play it again after going through it once (-ish) more on the DS a few years ago. I know PC gaming is underrepresented in the preceding discussion, but even though I started as a PC gamer and was heavily into PC gaming through the 1990s, I can't think of a PC-exclusive game that I'd want to go home and play this very day.​
 
Top Bottom