David H Wong
Banned
So...before I just read the cliffnotes version of this dude's memo, but now I read the whole thing. This dude seems to go out of his way to cover his ass, consistently saying that he's not against diversity, that White people certainly have not had a harder time dealing with life than minorities, and such. But his "solutions" are basically to...eliminate all the current programs Google has for diversifying its workforce. There seems to be some bizarre, twisted logic where he seems to be arguing that removing these programs that promote diversity will some end up increasing diversity, which was his whole fucking problem in the first place.
And this is the main thing I don't get about this stupid conversation we're having. Google's decision to hire more women and minorities wasn't the result of government policies. This was Google management making a decision based on what they felt was the direction they wanted to take the company. Whether they did it because they legitimately think it's a noble thing to do, or if they did it just to get good PR, the fundamental result is the same. What this nimrod seems to be arguing is that Google is somehow being compelled to do this by some outside force. We've already established that this outside force is not the government, which means that the only thing this force must be is...holy shit, the FREE MARKET!
Well their position is that groups organizing boycotts and putting pressure on companies to change policy isn't part of the free market; like groups tried to boycott Chick Fil A over their gay marriage stance but in the end, the average customer just liked their sandwiches too much. They would say that second one is the free market, and that boycotts and protests and hashtag campaigns are activists trying to interfere.
To believe that in his position, you have to ignore the absolute epidemic of anti-woman harassment that happens in the tech industry (how many big sexual harassment cases have hit this year? This month?) and what is unquestionably a hostile environment.
Even if the science was on his side and it's true that most women avoid the field purely out of choice, that's still the dumbest possible battle to be fighting. That tech is trying TOO hard to be welcoming of women? That's like marching in favor of police being quicker to shoot suspects. You have to be totally oblivious to what's going on in the world.
Let's face it - you can tell a lot about someone by the battles they choose to fight.