Usually i play myst with some of my friends, with a tons of block notes and drawing map to solve some of the puzzles.
Myst:
Finished in one day, probably the easyest. Didn't use any walkthrough
Riven:
The first time, when i was a kid, it took us 1 month and half to solve it.
The main problem with Riven was to find the passage hidden behind the doors leading to Gen's Lab.
Myst III Exile:
The easyest right after Myst, and the less inspired probably.
The only problem about it was Edanna, 'cause you always get lost.
Is the only one i played alone, and i finished it in one week and a half.
The OST was great, but the only age really worth playing was Amateria!
Myst IV Revelation:
The best one for me.
The ages were breathtaking, the story wonderful, the puzzles absolutely crazy.
Is the only one i used a walkthrough for, and specifically just for the throne puzzle in Syrrus prison age (in italian is named Pinnacolo, but i'm not sure about the english name)
Myst V End of Ages:
never played it properly.
I just don't like the fact that they shifted to pre-rendered graphics to real time 3D.
I have a quick and possible silly question, since I'm new to the series. Is it possible to do something that will get you permanently stuck in the Myst games (1-5)? I want to know if I need to be using different save files more often, or if everything is designed so that at least one "right" solution is always available until you figure it out. I know that some of the games may have different endings, but I just want to make sure I don't lock myself into "losing" and/or getting stuck forever.
I don't really remember that you could get stuck.
Usually if you do something really wrong in these games you just die.
But don't worry, usually you'll have the feeling that you could die, so you don't really have to save the game every 5 minutes or so.