• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Holiday Exclusives Showdown: PS3 vs. 360

L4D2 is a pretty huge console exclusive for the 360 judging by the sales of the first one that suprised me noting there is both a huge 360 and PC audience for this game.
 
Sony has got to have GT5 for this year. I think they have to have something for November or December. They have nothing...
 
dralla said:
the 360 line-up looks weak to me. most of my cash will be going to Sony. the biggest game on 360 is a $60 expansion pack to a 2 year old game. `*yawn*
Click to expand...
Are you talking about L4D2 or ODST?
 
I only own one of these consoles, so in the interest of maintaining the idea that the other console and any exclusives it offers are rotting garbage unfit for consumption by the lowest dregs of sentient life, I'll spread some nice FUD and troll the living hell out of anything the opposition offers up.

So help me, I will not abide a single person to state they enjoyed *console exclusive* when the console in question isn't mine.
 
Y2Kev said:
Sony has got to have GT5 for this year. I think they have to have something for November or December. They have nothing...
Click to expand...

I hadn't realized until this thread that they don't have anything for Christmas...then again neither does Microsoft. :P
 
Jerid said:
And you have *Looks at custom title*, hey whatever compensates and makes you feel better about yourseld and IRL.
Click to expand...
Ooh, we got a clever one here folks.
 
Y2Kev said:
Sony has got to have GT5 for this year. I think they have to have something for November or December. They have nothing...
Click to expand...
:o Sony putting all their monies behind the casual waggle wand confirmed.
 
I think the titles mentioned in the opening post for 360 will achieve greater sales success and overall greater critical acclaim than those mentioned for PS3.
Uncharted 2 is looking like the PS3's big title this 'holiday' to me, I feel it has the best chance of both great sales and great critical acclaim compared to the other Sony exclusives. If GT5 hits this year, things would look more even.
 
jett said:
I hadn't realized until this thread that they don't have anything for Christmas...then again neither does Microsoft. :P
Click to expand...
The reason I say Sony is stacking October is because they have something for November or December.

It doesn't make sense to me otherwise.
 
inner-G said:
Are you talking about L4D2 or ODST?
Click to expand...

:lol :lol Left 4 Dead is only 1 year old.

But you have to give ODST *some* credit. Sure, its probably overpriced, but it isn't just more of the same.
 
Demon's Souls means the PS3 wins for me. Anyone who imported the game knows how awesome it is. The 360's line up this holiday is pretty disappointing though (IMO).
 
vocab said:
I have to agree. If MS weren't riding on the sequel train, they might of had some heavy hitters for this season. All those games will be successful regardless of the quality.
Click to expand...
So, what are Sony and Ninty riding if not the sequel train? Everyone's always riding that riding that one...it's just that half of 'em decided to take the late trains when you look at what got delayed 'til next year...virtually all sequels. XBLA/PSN are where it's at these days, and there's still plenty of sequels and remakes to be had there, too. Whether it's a console, handheld, or PC...most everything is a sequel or remake (of a sequel) these days.
 
Y2Kev said:
The reason I say Sony is stacking October is because they have something for November or December.

It doesn't make sense to me otherwise.
Click to expand...

EyePet is releasing November 17th. People that got excited for the Natal demos this summer should look into that one.
 
SuperEnemyCrab said:
Pretty weak holiday lineup for both consoles is all I can say.
Click to expand...

People always say stuff like this, but honestly, assuming Sony does have GT5 this year, what else would you like both companies to have? Between the exclusives and 3rd party games, there is only so much room in the holiday space. It doesn't make sense to trot out countless games to suffocate in the market.
 
september

932983_20090527_gum007.jpg
954261_08122009_gum018.jpg


360 exclusive:

08/09 Raiden IV (US)
09/09 Serious Sam HD (XBLA)
22/09 Halo 3: ODST

PS3 exclusive:

__/__ Trine (PSN)
03/09 Mobile Suit Gundam Senki Record UC 0081 (JP)
04/09 Supercar Challenge
09/09 LittleBigPlanet: Game of the Year Edition (US)
17/09 Cross Edge
17/09 Tales of Vesperia (JP)
18/09 Katamari Forever
22/09 Afrika (US)
25/09 SingStar Motown​


october

955125_20090818_gum008.jpg
959038_20090818_gum006.jpg


360 exclusive:

__/__ Doom II: Hell on Earth
__/__ Quake Arena Arcade
27/10 Forza Motorsport 3
29/10 Grand Theft Auto: The Ballad of Gay Tony

PS3 exclusive:

__/__ Critter Crunch (PSN)
__/__ Dead Nation (PSN)
__/__ PixelJunk Shooter (PSN)
02/10 Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2
06/10 Demon's Souls (US)
16/10 Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
30/10 Buzz! Quiz World
30/10 Ratchet & Clank: A Crack in Time
30/10 Agarest: Generations of War
30/10 EyePet​


november

960511_20090601_gum001.jpg
919864_20041112_gum010.jpg


360 exclusive:

__/__ Perfect Dark (XBLA)
20/11 Left 4 Dead 2

PS3 exclusive:

__/__ VidZone (free)
__/__ God of War Collection (US)
06/11 SingStar Take That​


december

928790_20090109_gum015.jpg
942026_20080306_gum015.jpg


PS3 exclusive:

__/__ Final Fantasy XIII (JP)
04/12 Gran Turismo 5​

(europe dates & subject to changes)
 
El-Suave said:
This - as it was last year unfortunately...
Click to expand...
People honestly think UC2 will be better than ODST? I'm fairly certain they're both going to be on an equal level of awesome. As far as quality goes, the systems look pretty similar. Sales wise, ODST will be the top exclusive.
 
vermadas said:
Demon's Souls means the PS3 wins for me. Anyone who imported the game knows how awesome it is. The 360's line up this holiday is pretty disappointing though (IMO).
Click to expand...

Awesome game that hardly anyone will buy. See Chronicles, Valkyria.
 
Jostifer said:
EyePet is releasing November 17th. People that got excited for the Natal demos this summer should look into that one.
Click to expand...
Fuck, theory and hope destroyed :(

GT5 next year.

eyepet bitches, go play your halo 'n' weep
 
MightyHedgehog said:
So, what are Sony and Ninty riding if not the sequel train? Everyone's always riding that riding that one...it's just that half of 'em decided to take the late trains when you look at what got delayed 'til next year...virtually all sequels. XBLA/PSN are where it's at these days, and there's still plenty of sequels and remakes to be had there, too. Whether it's a console, handheld, or PC...most everything is a sequel or remake (of a sequel) these days.
Click to expand...

I kind of forgot Uncharted 2 and R&C were sequels. :lol You're right.

elrechazao said:
Awesome game that hardly anyone will buy. See Chronicles, Valkyria.
Click to expand...

Well pre order numbers are 50-60kish. That's not bad for a game like this. Word of mouth will ride this game for years.
 
elrechazao said:
Awesome game that hardly anyone will buy. See Chronicles, Valkyria.
Click to expand...
Well, knowing it'll tank sales-wise just about wraps it up for any interest I had in the actual game!
 
lawblob said:
People always say stuff like this, but honestly, assuming Sony does have GT5 this year, what else would you like both companies to have? Between the exclusives and 3rd party games, there is only so much room in the holiday space. It doesn't make sense to trot out countless games to suffocate in the market.
Click to expand...


I'm not assuming GT5 is coming. If it is, then it would be a decent lineup. Honestly Forza 3, Uncharted 2 and the possibility of GT5 are the only things that stand out to me. I'll get MW2 and L4D2 on PC...
 
In the face of Ratchet, I kinda wish 360 had a platfomer with color. That's whats lacking in the 360 in comparison to the PS3 this holiday IMO.
 
Like most showdowns of this type, the winner is entirely determined by one's personal tastes and how you define "exclusive".
 
Doesn't MS have Natal for the holidays?
I'm sure there will be quite a few new titles for the launch...

But Ps3 has the best upcoming games imo.
The only X360 game I'm looking forward to is Forza 3. I'm not interested in (mainly) online multiplayer titles like L4D2 or ODST.
Not a fan of online gaming.
 
Second said:
Doesn't MS have Natal for the holidays?
I'm sure there will be quite a few new titles for the launch...

But Ps3 has the best upcoming games imo.
The only X360 game I'm looking forward to is Forza 3. I'm not interested in (mainly) online multiplayer titles like L4D2 or ODST...
Click to expand...
Natal is out next holiday with first party support from Rare.
 
PS3 wins my heart this holiday with Ninja Gaiden and import Final Fantasy XIII. But I think the ps3 will not fair as well do to Microsofts marketing and because everyone is just going to be playing/buying MW2.
 
As others have stated, I don't see any hardware drivers this season. I think they're both on cruise control.
 
Buying UNCHARTED 2!!!222!!!
angry.gif
, Ratchet, Demons' Souls, Eyepet and HALO 3 ODST.
Indifferent2.gif


If they get GT5 out this year I will buy GT5.
Indifferent2.gif
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Ghost of Yōtei vs Assassin’s Creed Shadows | Ultimate Graphics Showdown
3 4 5 6 7
306
8K
saintjules replied
Tekken: Dark Resurrection - PS5 vs. PS3 vs. PSP Emulator (PPSSPP) | Side by Side
Analysis Retro Trailer 
1
263
Danny Dudekisser replied
Hopefully Xbox goes exclusives only too.
2
83
102
NickFire replied
Hunters are NOT ready for this | Hunt: Showdown 1896 Reveal
Trailer 
3
155
ahtlas7 replied
Hunt: Showdown 1896 - Official Devil's Trail Gameplay Trailer
Trailer 
0
123
IbizaPocholo replied
Top Bottom