Support NeoGAF

[Kindekuma]

I only really got the mario button/pin set. I still haven't even taken it out of the plastic wrap yet.

 

[routerbad]

i have the shirt, a MM Soundtrack and some ALBW posters. Loved getting physical rewards, it's a shame people complained about them lacking digital trophies when they had physical ones.

 

[MacGurcules]

The 3DS Game case

And the Ocarina of Time 3D soundtrack CD which I still haven't opened

These were great. I really wish they'd sell them. The similar third party ones just aren't the same quality.

 

[jluedtke]

I loved the physical rewards. I got Platinum every year they offered it, too. It was a great incentive to buy more games. The Hanafuda cards were cool, as were the Game & Watch games, but to me, nothing will top the Game & Watch replica. That was awesome.

 

[emb]

Yeah, it was really cool.

Still regret not going for the Game & Watch Ball replica or the hanafuda cards. Even the towels. I saved up for both Game & Watch DS games though, and grabbed a gold nunchuk at one point.

Only others I bought were right at the end: Majora's Mask bag, MM puzzle, 3DS game case, and a Zelda 3DS pouch.

 

[Glix]

3DS pouch and game case were the BEST.

Also Game and Watch, and the Game and Watch DS games.

MyNintendo rewards are super disappointing. I never redeem anything except fire emblem stamina potions.

Oh I forgot about the dope tote bad. My girl still uses it.

 

[Misuta]

My first Club Nintendo rewards were the Mario Kart Double Dash!! baseball cap and two key chains. Later I bought a NDS game rack.

 

[Zips]

I never managed to get the hanafuda cards.

By the time I saved up enough coins/points for them, Nintendo had discontinued it and left them out of stock before removing entirely.

At least I got the deck of cards platinum reward. Still have those, and they're neat. I'll always wonder about those hanafuda cards though...

 

[PAULINK]

I loved the program a lot, definitely made it worth buying new nintendo games.

 

[The_Spaniard]

Platinumed all 5 years for the physical rewards. Bummed that program is gone now.

 

[_SAKY_]

Ah, memories of pilfering Club Nintendo codes from the display cases at Blockbuster video. I managed to platinum on two accounts a few years.

Spoiler

3DS game case with OG Zelda insert was the awesomest.

 

[ZZMitch]

3DS Pouch and Mario playing cards for me!

I also got the Wii remote holder, which I use for TV remotes now

 

[cbrun44]

I'ma let you finish OP, but we all know the best Club Nintendo rewards were both physical and games.

Best rewards during the life of this program... Items I actually use.