• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Interstellar |OT| (dir. Christopher Nolan) Whatever can happen will happen

Status
Not open for further replies.
kittoo said:
Guys is it really worth it to see it in IMAX? Nearest IMAX is like 2 hour subway ride and I am a little hesitant to travel by subway in this sweltering heat.
Is it worth it? Or should I just see it in a regular 3D theater.
Plus I will have to watch it alone in the IMAX while there is company in regular 3D theater.
Click to expand...

Movie isn't in 3D at all. If that had any play in your decision.
 
This movie is kind of all over the place, but I think the third act pulls it together, silly as it is.
 
Fuck me I wanna see the movie again so bad... Have to wait saturday night damn it.

I'm playing Elite while listening to Day One Dark, the track that got released on SoundCloud. It's actually the song to one of my favorite scenes,
when Cooper gets balsy as fuck and dock the ship while spinning. The intensity, tension and building of that scene had me strapped to my chair like rarely, and just listening to the music gives me goose bumps all over.

5:50 in that song is when shit gets real. Those organs man, those friggin' organs.
 
nitoo said:
Fuck me I wanna see the movie again so bad... Have to wait saturday night damn it.

I'm playing Elite while listening to Day One Dark, the track that got released on SoundCloud. It's actually the song to one of my favorite scenes,
when Cooper gets balsy as fuck and dock the ship while spinning. The intensity, tension and building of that scene had me strapped to my chair like rarely, and just listening to the music gives me goose bumps all over.

5:50 in that song is when shit gets real. Those organs man, those friggin' organs.
Click to expand...

Haha, Interstellar has me ready to drop $75 for the beta this Friday (payday)
 
Scullibundo said:
See now you're somebody whose impressions I'd be eager to hear since I know you were looking forward to Interstellar even when it was back on Spielberg's backburner.
Click to expand...
Writing on my phone right now, so this will be brief-ish.

Overall I quite liked it. It's a nice emotional story of a man's relationship to his children, particularly his daughter, with big sci-fi ideas splashed around. I think that core of the movie works very well throughout and hits home hard at various points.

Some of the crazy sci-fi stuff gets stretched thin in terms of logic and/or internal consistency, but it's not that big an issue for me. That kind of comes with the territory when dealing with wormholes, black holes, time dilation, etc. Maybe some of that could be tightened up, but it at least works as a good skeleton for the emotional arcs, and it works moment-to-moment pretty well.

I do wish the overall mission were treated a little more professionally within the universe. It's a bit cavalier. I think the 20-40% range of the running time suffers from characters acting a little dumb, although this is mostly in conversation so it doesn't have big plot impacts. I suspect it was done to cut to the chase and not have a mission prep sequence, but it results in characters discussing and weighing plans and options after the mission begins, and it comes off silly. This is a mission to save mankind, I'm pretty sure you'd have your priorities, parameters for success, contingencies, etc, in order before launch. This dissipates once they're through the wormhole and variables start changing, but I would have appreciated more professionalism from the team at various points.

As has been said by others, there's less big grand space scenery than expected, but those moments are fucking amazing. Often these involve staggering juxtapositions of vast stillness and intense activity, which is fitting and awesome.

And I'll say this. I'm glad Spielberg didn't end up making it if only because I can imagine Kaminski's overbearing love of backlighting being obnoxious. He would have had ample diegetic reasons to crank that to 11 during some of the core emotional sequences.
 
This is sounding more and more like Spielberg's A.I.

That film had its share of lovers/haters.

Gonna know in 4hrs as i watch it in Liemax.
 
That was the worst movie of all time. I actually went out 10 minutes before the movie finished and asked to get my money back. The woman actually did it since she hated the movie as well. I can't believe people seriously think Nolan is good at this. Shit. That was the worst time of my life. My wife was right. She didn't want to join me because of the stuff she heard. I told her that it cannot be that bad. She was right. Cause it's even worse. I will never ever go into a Nolan flick again. I'm done with him.
 
Franck Ribery said:
That was the worst movie of all time. I actually went out 10 minutes before the movie finished and asked to get my money back. The woman actually did it since she hated the movie as well. I can't believe people seriously think Nolan is good at this. Shit. That was the worst time of my life. My wife was right. She didn't want to join me because of the stuff she heard. I told her that it cannot be that bad. She was right. Cause it's even worse. I will never ever go into a Nolan flick again. I'm done with him.
Click to expand...

You're fucking ridiculous, do you know that? I haven't even seen the movie and I know that whether or not I enjoy it, it certainly will not be the WORST MOVIE OF ALL TIME!!! Hyperbolic timechamber in these mother fucking threads.
 
Franck Ribery said:
That was the worst movie of all time. I actually went out 10 minutes before the movie finished and asked to get my money back. The woman actually did it since she hated the movie as well. I can't believe people seriously think Nolan is good at this. Shit. That was the worst time of my life. My wife was right. She didn't want to join me because of the stuff she heard. I told her that it cannot be that bad. She was right. Cause it's even worse. I will never ever go into a Nolan flick again. I'm done with him.
Click to expand...


Not sure if sarcasm
 
Franck Ribery said:
That was the worst movie of all time. I actually went out 10 minutes before the movie finished and asked to get my money back. The woman actually did it since she hated the movie as well. I can't believe people seriously think Nolan is good at this. Shit. That was the worst time of my life. My wife was right. She didn't want to join me because of the stuff she heard. I told her that it cannot be that bad. She was right. Cause it's even worse. I will never ever go into a Nolan flick again. I'm done with him.
Click to expand...

Give me a fucking break. I'm sure the movie may not be the best to some people, but if this is truly how you feel then you must have a pretty miserable life and hate everything.
 
Franck Ribery said:
That was the worst movie of all time. I actually went out 10 minutes before the movie finished and asked to get my money back. The woman actually did it since she hated the movie as well. I can't believe people seriously think Nolan is good at this. Shit. That was the worst time of my life. My wife was right. She didn't want to join me because of the stuff she heard. I told her that it cannot be that bad. She was right. Cause it's even worse. I will never ever go into a Nolan flick again. I'm done with him.
Click to expand...
Nah, it was pretty good. Actually, it's one of the most fun times I've had in a theater.
 
Franck Ribery said:
That was the worst movie of all time. I actually went out 10 minutes before the movie finished and asked to get my money back. The woman actually did it since she hated the movie as well. I can't believe people seriously think Nolan is good at this. Shit. That was the worst time of my life. My wife was right. She didn't want to join me because of the stuff she heard. I told her that it cannot be that bad. She was right. Cause it's even worse. I will never ever go into a Nolan flick again. I'm done with him.
Click to expand...

lol this fuckin guy. Worst film of all time!!! Worst time he's ever had in his life. lol trolls gonna troll.
 
Franck Ribery said:
That was the worst movie of all time. I actually went out 10 minutes before the movie finished and asked to get my money back. The woman actually did it since she hated the movie as well. I can't believe people seriously think Nolan is good at this. Shit. That was the worst time of my life. My wife was right. She didn't want to join me because of the stuff she heard. I told her that it cannot be that bad. She was right. Cause it's even worse. I will never ever go into a Nolan flick again. I'm done with him.
Click to expand...
How about this? Tell us WHY you disliked the move instead of just saying "Worst movie evah!!!"
 
Franck Ribery said:
That was the worst movie of all time. I actually went out 10 minutes before the movie finished and asked to get my money back. The woman actually did it since she hated the movie as well. I can't believe people seriously think Nolan is good at this. Shit. That was the worst time of my life. My wife was right. She didn't want to join me because of the stuff she heard. I told her that it cannot be that bad. She was right. Cause it's even worse. I will never ever go into a Nolan flick again. I'm done with him.
Click to expand...

That's not the reason your wife didn't want to join you.

She's having an affair with Brett Ratner.

Sorry you had to find out this way.
 
kittoo said:
Guys is it really worth it to see it in IMAX? Nearest IMAX is like 2 hour subway ride and I am a little hesitant to travel by subway in this sweltering heat.
Is it worth it? Or should I just see it in a regular 3D theater.
Plus I will have to watch it alone in the IMAX while there is company in regular 3D theater.
Click to expand...

I know the film isn't in 3D but someone please answer this man!

I'm trying to make the same decision myself. IMAX would be a way bigger hassle than the theater a few streets away from me that his both charming and lovely. But if it's really that big of a deal I'll make the trek.
 
Just got out....

anigif_enhanced-buzz-15239-1361334623-1.gif


reaction achieved. Man, I really loved this movie. We don't get such films as often so I'm happy as fuck when we do. It's not a perfect movie by any means but the core story resonated with me alot. But man, DEM VISUALS, sound mixing and holy shit at the soundtrack. The sound mixing where I was at was perfect, didn't notice anything and everything was crystal clear, my rib cage got FUCKED. I cannot wait for the bluray. Also, MM as the lead was perfect, dem tears man. There were lows but for me the highs were way more than the lows. Best nolan movie? not so sure about that yet but I really loved it.

EDIT: Also, IMAX ONLY. The movie at times reminded me of 2001.
 
kittoo said:
Guys is it really worth it to see it in IMAX? Nearest IMAX is like 2 hour subway ride and I am a little hesitant to travel by subway in this sweltering heat.
Is it worth it? Or should I just see it in a regular 3D theater.
Plus I will have to watch it alone in the IMAX while there is company in regular 3D theater.
Click to expand...
Is it worth seeing in IMAX? Yes, the experience for me was memorable, and I'd recommend it to anyone.

Is it worth seeing in IMAX if you're going to be miserable about the trip you just made, the trip you will have to make afterwards, and that you're missing your friends? It sounds like it's not, but you can't expect us to make that decision for you.
 
The only thing i didn't like about the movie is Nolan's dialogue. Other than that - pure emotion. Matthew, music, picture. I cried 3 times, i mean damn. This is the movie you need to see in IMAX. 70mm or as me in digital one. It won't be the same experience at home or at a normal theater. And yeah there is something off with sound mixing. You can't hear dialogue at a cartain moments. And i saw it with russian dub, so there must be something wrong with original mix.
9/10.
 
WarrenMax007 said:
The only thing i didn't like about the movie is Nolan's dialogue. Other than that - pure emotion. Matthew, music, picture. I cried 3 times, i mean damn. This is the movie you need to see in IMAX. 70mm or as me in digital one. It won't be the same experience at home or at a normal theater. And yeah there is something off with sound mixing. You can't hear dialogue at a cartain moments. And i saw it with russian dub, so there must be something wrong with original mix.
9/10.
Click to expand...

everyone says they cried 3 times. so ill expect 3 emotional moments lol
 
WarrenMax007 said:
The only thing i didn't like about the movie is Nolan's dialogue. Other than that - pure emotion. Matthew, music, picture. I cried 3 times, i mean damn. This is the movie you need to see in IMAX. 70mm or as me in digital one. It won't be the same experience at home or at a normal theater. And yeah there is something off with sound mixing. You can't hear dialogue at a cartain moments. And i saw it with russian dub, so there must be something wrong with original mix.
9/10.
Click to expand...

Movie got me choked up twice lol!

When Cooper is watching the videos after 24 years had passed. And then the one that really got me is when Cooper was screaming "No!!! Noo!!!" And just started bawling during the scene in the fifth dimension while we was trying to communicate with murph. Powerful stuff
 
I'd love to see this with my gf but she's scared of aliens. Does this have any aliens in it? Simple yes/no should suffice, no spoilers please.
 
Mitama said:
I'd love to see this with my gf but she's scared of aliens. Does this have any aliens in it? Simple yes/no should suffice, no spoilers please.
Click to expand...

Answering this would actually be a spoiler. You'll understand after seeing it. Let's just say I don't think your girl will be too frightened.
 
Shemyaza said:
Movie got me choked up twice lol!

When Cooper is watching the videos after 24 years had passed. And then the one that really got me is when Cooper was screaming "No!!! Noo!!!" And just started bawling during the scene in the fifth dimension while we was trying to communicate with murph. Powerful stuff
Click to expand...

Another scene as well

When he leaves for take off, just the music, countdown and MM crying...MAAAAAANNNNNNNN and when things get silent as they reach space, fucking amazing.Which reminds me..."What are you doing?" "Docking." SHEEEEEEEEEIIIIITTTTT! Also, poor Romilliy
 
Mitama said:
I'd love to see this with my gf but she's scared of aliens. Does this have any aliens in it? Simple yes/no should suffice, no spoilers please.
Click to expand...
In short, there's no need for your girlfriend to be scared.
.
 
Anton Sugar said:
Hahaha, actually, there kinda are (IMO). I texted my sister right after I saw it and said "you will cry three times".

If you are a dad with a daughter, or a daughter yourself, increase chances of cry by 50%.
Click to expand...

Noooooooo!

Can't wait to see this. Got imax tickets for Saturday evening!
 
Maninthemirror said:
I just became a father to a daughter 16 months ago

I'm screwed aren't i
Click to expand...

you are already bawling

Mitama said:
I'd love to see this with my gf but she's scared of aliens. Does this have any aliens in it? Simple yes/no should suffice, no spoilers please.
Click to expand...

Hahaha, yes/no is kind of a spoiler though.

No.

Shemyaza said:
Movie got me choked up twice lol!

When Cooper is watching the videos after 24 years had passed. And then the one that really got me is when Cooper was screaming "No!!! Noo!!!" And just started bawling during the scene in the fifth dimension while we was trying to communicate with murph. Powerful stuff
Click to expand...

Yup. For me it was when
Coop first leaves Murph, when he watches his videos, and when he can't reach her in the tesseract.

Death Metalist said:
Another scene as well

When he leaves for take off, just the music, countdown and MM crying...MAAAAAANNNNNNNN and when things get silent as they reach space, fucking amazing.Which reminds me..."What are you doing?" "Docking." SHEEEEEEEEEIIIIITTTTT! Also, poor Romilliy
Click to expand...

Hahah yup. I actually forgot how well that scene was put together when I listed my favorite moments. I love how they just go from that
straight to the blastoff.
 
Death Metalist said:
Another scene as well

When he leaves for take off, just the music, countdown and MM crying...MAAAAAANNNNNNNN and when things get silent as they reach space, fucking amazing.Which reminds me..."What are you doing?" "Docking." SHEEEEEEEEEIIIIITTTTT! Also, poor Romilliy
Click to expand...

I absolutely loved that scene dude. One of the best scenes in the movie imo. Driving away as the score is blasting and then the countdown to the ship taking off is going on in the background and all you see is Cooper crying and driving away and then we have blast off. I love how they handled that. So fucking good.

Sorry for all the spoiler tags y'all i know this ain't the spoiler thread so I'll try to keep it to a minimum
 
Saw it last night.

This movie, yikes. Loved it. I feel like Nolan has his finger on EXACTLY what I want in a movie. Exactly.

There was one part that was straight up unnecessary/bad:
Damon
Just seemed so... out of place.
 
Death Metalist said:
Another scene as well

When he leaves for take off, just the music, countdown and MM crying...MAAAAAANNNNNNNN and when things get silent as they reach space, fucking amazing.Which reminds me..."What are you doing?" "Docking." SHEEEEEEEEEIIIIITTTTT! Also, poor Romilliy
Click to expand...
This. So fucking this. I just couldn't hold it.
 
Franck Ribery said:
That was the worst movie of all time. I actually went out 10 minutes before the movie finished and asked to get my money back. The woman actually did it since she hated the movie as well. I can't believe people seriously think Nolan is good at this. Shit. That was the worst time of my life. My wife was right. She didn't want to join me because of the stuff she heard. I told her that it cannot be that bad. She was right. Cause it's even worse. I will never ever go into a Nolan flick again. I'm done with him.
Click to expand...

Yours truly, Franck.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

The thing this say doesn't happen but keeps happening just happened again...
12
387
RJMacready73 replied
  • Poll
Who's the better filmmaker: Christopher Nolan or Martin Scorsese?
2
90
2K
Sonik replied
What happened to shame?
NSFW 
36
230
Chuck Berry replied
Someone Uploaded Christopher Nolan's short film "Tarentella" On Youtube.
2
665
kremiso replied
Christopher Nolan’s ‘The Odyssey’ will be the first blockbuster shot ENTIRELY on IMAX cameras
26
2K
AJUMP23 replied
Top Bottom