From my observations the Switch seems like a very popular console over here at GAF, if this site indeed represented the majority of the gaming market then the Switch would be a worldwide phenomenon that was changing lifes left and right.
By DOA, I mean right at console launch. The Switch is popular on GAF now.
Like Splatoon, there was a large contingent after the initial reveal that expected it to do quite poorly, even the rare claim that it would do worse than the WiiU. The price, the form factor, the seemingly barren software at launch. All were used for speculation that the console would fail.
Like with the general audience however, it seems much of GAF has shifted to be more positive on the Switch; the power of hands on experience.
Ah you misunderstood my answers let me rephrase them:
OP question: Is the Switch becoming the main console for gamers?
- No, although many in GAF might do there are millions of gamers uses PS4 or Xbox as their main and thats a fact.
- No OP, Switch is the new toy and every one want to use their new toy
- No, the amount of software releasing in the other home consoles like Cod, Battlefield, Destiny, Red Dead etc makes the the Switch by default unfit for main console unless you only want to play Nintendo games and some indie titles that already exist in the home console.
Edit: I can't believe we actually arguing that a handheld, family focused games with no 3Rd party support can be a main console for the mainstream gaming community!
You opened with the idea that those broad answers could be used to answer for most Switch threads.
For example, none of the answers you gave originally could explain the overwhelmingly positive reaction to Zelda, nor its sales, which have had numerous threads. Nor could they be used to accurately respond to threads about joycon issues, or the lack of the MHXX Switch port, or to expected indie support.
Your more detailed follow up makes a lot more sense where your broad strokes did not.
I agree that the Switch will most likely not become the main console for the majority of today's market, but I don't see why it wouldn't capture a main position for a significant portion.
It is, after all, partially a handheld, and even the diminished sales of the 3DS rival (not outclipse, I think?) the PS4.