ShironRedshift
Member
Casebook false dilemma. You're acting as if the only possible reason to continue playing a game is if one is still enjoying it, or else play would cease. However, these are clearly not the only two options. For instance, one can continue playing despite enjoyment having ceased to nonetheless be as informed about the game as possible and to see how it ends or in hope that at some point something changes, the game does become enjoyable again, regardless of whether that hope is actually ever fulfilled or not. If you refuse to accept that the possibilities you've presented are not the only ones then you're just living in a different reality, I'm sorry. That is to say, you can ignore these other possibilities as much as you like, but it doesn't stop them from existing. It just makes you delusional.How do you spin it as not?
That's like watching 20 Lord of the Rings movies and then claiming you actually don't like the genre/story.
And what's particularly insidious about this variant of the false dilemma, which I like to call the Skyrim argument since that's where I first saw it in mass is that it can be used to shut down any and all criticism about a game. Played too few hours? You haven't seen enough to criticize it and haven't given it a fair shake. Played too many? Well, you must have enjoyed it and therefore your criticisms are irrelevant. There's no happy medium that can't be disregarded like this. Of course, nonetheless it remains a false dilemma since it obscures alternate possibilities, including the most likely ones and therefore remains in very poor form.