Support NeoGAF

[Kadey]

Tie between Mass Effect and Bioshock. If there was more Silent Hill 5 tidbits besides a crappy screenshot and voice trailer, it would be it.

 

[Insane Metal]

Killzone

YES!

/thread

 

[Thoren]

Whats so great about Super Mario Galaxy? I mean I haven't seen any levels that don't look insanely linear, and waving the wii remote to spin Mario looks really annoying. I wish they'd just make Super Mario 64 pt 2.

 

[Uncle]

Mass Effect.

 

[Mudhoney]

Super Mario Galaxy

Bioshock and LBP biting at its heals though.

 

[BenjaminBirdie]

Mass Effect

 

[grandjedi6]

Super Mario Galaxy

Whats so great about Super Mario Galaxy? I mean I haven't seen any levels that don't look insanely linear, and waving the wii remote to spin Mario looks really annoying. I wish they'd just make Super Mario 64 pt 2.

All impressions of the game have been insanely positive.

 

[neorej]

Killzone 2.

Why, was there any other game on E3?

 

[TONX]

Killzone 2

 

[WHOAguitarninja]

Tough call between Mass Effect and COD4. Right now, COD4, but that might change. Still havent seen most of the footage for mass effect. Watching the Gamespot demonstration now and i'm like :O

 

[beelzebozo]

Whats so great about Super Mario Galaxy? I mean I haven't seen any levels that don't look insanely linear, and waving the wii remote to spin Mario looks really annoying. I wish they'd just make Super Mario 64 pt 2.

its one apparent flaw is that you don't get it.

 

[Blader]

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

It's not the game I'm anticipating the most, but it did impress me the most.

 

[DeadyFernGarden]

SMG sex on a disc.

 

[xaosslug]

 

[The Spacepope]

Mass Effect, closely followed by Rock Band.

 

[Supervlieg]

Counted up till post #65 (not including ties)

Super Mario Galaxy IIIII IIIII IIIII IIIII I
MAss Effect IIIII IIII
Little Big Planet IIIII II
Killzone IIIII
Rock Band III
Bioshock II
Call of Duty 4 II
Wii Fit I
Fallout 3 I
Echochrome I
Assasins Creed I
Ratchet and Clank I
Infamous I

 

[AlphaSnake]

While Killzone 2 had the best showing, the game everyone seems to have overlooked was Army of Two.

Prepare to flame the hell out of me, but the game played better than Gears of War. The emphasis on co-op was kickass, and the action was ****ing awesome.

 

[Apenheul]

Super Mario Galaxy, looking better every time.

 

[jko]

The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass

 

[beelzebozo]

While Killzone 2 had the best showing, the game everyone seems to have overlooked was Army of Two.

Prepare to flame the hell out of me, but the game played better than Gears of War. The emphasis on co-op was kickass, and the action was ****ing awesome.

you played it? bad ass. i'm really looking forward to this more than most of the other shooters that are getting more press.

 

[Orobi]

Killzone 2
Uncharted too!

 

[ezekial45]

Left 4 Dead (not getting enough attention)

 

[Forsete]

Dont make me choose.. I refuse to choose.

Its between LBP which is pure LOVE.. Killzone which is pure awesomeness.. and Uncharted which is the-game-Ive-always-wanted.. So.. UGH.

 

[Branskins]

Super Mario Galaxy
Runner up: Metroid Prime 3 (This game is hardly getting any attention!) and Call of Duty 4

 

[TheGreatDave]

Mario Galaxy.

 

[derder]

I think the best presentation for a game was killzone 2.

I think the best game they had there was Mass Effect.

 

[K.Jack]

Killzone

Runner-up:Mass Effect

Honorable Mention: Heavenly Sword

lol @ Super Mario Galaxy winning. Take off the Nintendo tinted glasses ONCE.

 

[Visualante]

TBH if you can't choose one game your vote will be discarded.

 

[God's Vessel]

Galaxy has got me really excited.

 

[Mau ®]

I made a Top 10 most anticipated games thread yesterday. Today I counted the first 100 votes and here are the results!

1.- Super Mario Galaxy (45 votes out of 100, ZOMG!)
2.- Metal Gear Solid 4 (36 out of 100)
3.- Mass Effect (33 out of 100)
4.- Uncharted (29 out of 100)
4.- Call of Duty 4 (29 out of 100)
4.- Killzone 2 (29 out of 100)
7.- Super Smash Bros (27 out of a 100)
8.- Resident Evil 5 (25 out of 100)
8.- Halo 3 (25 out of 100)
10.- Grand Theft Auto 4 (24 out of 100)
10.- Metroid Prime 3 (24 out of 100)

Well its 11 games but thats because there was a draw between GTA4 and MP3

Interesting notes!

* There are 3 wii games, 3 PS3 games, 3 multiplataform games (PS3,360) and 2 360 games in the Top 10
* The Top DS game was Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (14 out of 100)
* Top PC game (no counting multiplataform releases like COD4) is Crysis (7 out of 100)
* The Top PSP game is Silent Hill Origins (3 out of 100)
* All PSP games are gonna BOMBA, all PSP games that made the list (excluding Silent Hill) only had 1 vote!! ONLY ONE!!! WTF!!
* Uncharted is the only new IP to make the Top 10. Impressive!

NOTE: I will keep on counting the votes so soon I will unveil the definitive list.

Link to thread http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=171533

 

[Cryect]

Super Mario Galaxy (which I didn't expect to come away with quite as good impression as I did after reading & seeing the demos).
Followed up by: Bioshock and CoD4

 

[number1jagsfan]

Mass Effect

Runners Up: LBP, COD 4 and Rock Band

 

[RiskyChris]

lol @ Super Mario Galaxy winning. Take off the Nintendo tinted glasses ONCE.

Let me guess, you haven't looked at a single gameplay demo of SMG? Fool.

 

[Quazar]

Mass Effect

 

[lackey]

Killzone 2

 

[beelzebozo]

lol @ Super Mario Galaxy winning. Take off the Nintendo tinted glasses ONCE.

let me just dispense with the formalities and let you know that i think you're an idiot

 

[Yoboman]

Little Big Planet. The game really sparked my imagination this E3 with it's creation. The game seems incredible, revolutionary even

 

[Threi]

lol @ Super Mario Galaxy winning. Take off the Nintendo tinted glasses ONCE.

I have had them off for over 10 years.

But i decided to put them on just to piss you off in this thread.

 

[MasterMFauli]

lol @ Super Mario Galaxy winning. Take off the Nintendo tinted glasses ONCE.

 

[Haunted]

Galaxy

 

[LocoSWE]

Yeah Super Mario Galaxy!

 

[K.Jack]

Let me guess, you haven't looked at a single gameplay demo of SMG? Fool.

Of course I have. It looks fun, and i'll be buying it. I do have a Wii in my household.

Name calling is unnecessary, but is to be expected around these parts.

EDIT: WOW you guys are sensitive. I have a freakin' Wii!!! I just thought the margin of victory was a bit more vast than it should be.

 

[NinSoX]

Game of the show, as in best gameply shown other than pure graphics? I would have to say Mario Galaxy and Left 4 Dead.

 

[xaosslug]

I made a Top 10 most anticipated games thread yesterday. Today I counted the first 100 votes and here are the results!

1.- Super Mario Galaxy (45 votes out of 100, ZOMG!)
2.- Metal Gear Solid 4 (36 out of 100)
3.- Mass Effect (33 out of 100)
4.- Uncharted (29 out of 100)
4.- Call of Duty 4 (29 out of 100)
4.- Killzone 2 (29 out of 100)
7.- Super Smash Bros (27 out of a 100)
8.- Resident Evil 5 (25 out of 100)
8.- Halo 3 (25 out of 100)
10.- Grand Theft Auto 4 (24 out of 100)
10.- Metroid Prime 3 (24 out of 100)

Well its 11 games but thats because there was a draw between GTA4 and MP3

Interesting notes!

* There are 3 wii games, 3 PS3 games, 3 multiplataform games (PS3,360) and 2 360 games in the Top 10
* The Top DS game was Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (14 out of 100)
* Top PC game (no counting multiplataform releases like COD4) is Crysis (7 out of 100)
* The Top PSP game is Silent Hill Origins (3 out of 100)
* All PSP games are gonna BOMBA, all PSP games that made the list (excluding Silent Hill) only had 1 vote!! ONLY ONE!!! WTF!!
* Uncharted is the only new IP to make the Top 10. Impressive!

NOTE: I will keep on counting the votes so soon I will unveil the definitive list.

Link to thread http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=171533

err... why'd you only use the 1st 100 votes? Sucks for that late comers. :/

 

[Cdammen]

Left 4 Dead

This game will be co-op bliss

 

[RiskyChris]

Of course I have. It looks fun, and i'll be buying it. I do have a Wii in my household.

Name calling is unnecessary, but is to be expected around these parts.

EDIT: WOW you guys are sensitive. I have a freakin' Wii!!! I just thought the margin of victory was a bit more vast than it should be.

You basically insulted every person who picked SMG in this thread. Expect someone to bite back, mmkay?

 

[Mau ®]

err... why'd you only use the 1st 100 votes? Sucks for that late comers. :/

Like I said. I will keep counting the later votes! I will make a definitive list soon! Its hard work man! :lol

 

[Haunted]

Keep the system wars out of here. Just the voting please.

 

[impirius]

After seeing the developer walkthrough videos... yeah, Super Mario Galaxy.

Runner-up is CoD4, which was barely even on my radar before E3.

 

[jko]

lol @ Super Mario Galaxy winning. Take off the Nintendo tinted glasses ONCE.

i'd change my vote to SMG just for this, but i wont