Support NeoGAF

[Agent X]

I'll cast a vote for LittleBigPlanet.

 

[danwarb]

Mass Effect

 

[Xenon]

CoD4

 

[Gigglepoo]

I'm going to limit this to games I actually played. That automatically eliminates Fallout 3, which looks amazing. Also, though I did play the combat demo of Fable 2, I'm not going to count that. It's my most wanted game but I haven't experienced actual gameplay scenarios yet.

Which leaves me with...

Turok!

 

[devilscallmedad]

Could we please only vote in this thread and not fight over each other's opinion ?

The massacre continues......


SMG 36
Mass Effect 18
Little Big Planet 12
Killzone 2 11
Rock band 3


Complete till post 150.

Someone else please take it on from here

 

[gollumsluvslave]

Tie between Mass Effect and Bioshock

Preach it.

Though I give the edge to Bioshock, based on the Gamespot demo walkthrough, and the fact that it's out first

 

[Wollan]

 

[donny2112]

 

[Supervlieg]

(Up to post 159, not counting ties)

Super Mario Galaxy IIIII IIIII IIIII IIIII IIIII IIIII IIIII I (36)

MAss Effect IIIII IIIII IIIII III (18)

Little Big Planet IIIII IIIII II (12)

Killzone 2 IIIII IIIII II (12)

Rock Band III

Call of Duty 4 III

Bioshock III

Wii Fit III

Left 4 Dead II

Fallout 3 I
Echochrome I
Assasins Creed I
Ratchet and Clank I
Infamous I
Army of two I
Zelda Phantom I
Metroid Prime 3 I
Halo 3 I
Unreal 3 I
Fable 2 I
Ace Combat 6 I
Turok I

 

[Threi]

I guess it's because PS3 and Xbox360 votes are divided over several games, while for the Wii SMG is THE game most are looking forward to. Just an observation.

Really?

I see Ninty votes going between Prime 3 and SMG, with SMG clearly leading
I see Sony votes going between Killzone 2 and LBP, with LBP clearly leading (*edit - seems thay are tied now :lol, but adding both of them wouldn't create a "landslide" anyways so it doesn't matter much*)

I see MS votes going between Mass Effect and Rock Band, with Mass Effect clearly leading

so yeah my observation is a little different...

 

[MasterMFauli]

I guess it's because PS3 and Xbox360 votes are divided over several games, while for the Wii SMG is THE game most are looking forward to. Just an observation.

 

[meppi]

Mario Galaxy without a doubt.

Great to see the team that made DK Jungle Beat continue to have that magic touch.

 

[Oblivion]

Actually, I think Smash 'may' have gotten more votes if they showed anything. Well, that's what happened last year, anyway.

 

[MassiveAttack]

It will be very interesting to see if these votes change after TGS.

Edit: LittleBigPlanet.

 

[Uncle]

Halo 3 I

I find this pretty surprising. But then again, they didn't show much of the game to the public.

 

[cartoon_soldier]

Mass Effect

 

[JDSN]

Galaxy, we have seen 4 bosses, tons of galaxy and uses for the Wiimote and thats only the demo.

 

[Supervlieg]

I find this pretty surprising. But then again, they didn't show much of the game to the public.

How about MGS 0 votes? Guess cutscene trailers dont cut it anymore. And what about Crysis?

 

[Sharp]

Really?

I see Ninty votes going between Prime 3 and SMG, with SMG clearly leading
I see Sony votes going between Killzone 2 and LBP, with LBP clearly leading (*edit - seems thay are tied now :lol, but adding both of them wouldn't create a "landslide" anyways so it doesn't matter much*)

I see MS votes going between Mass Effect and Rock Band, with Mass Effect clearly leading

so yeah my observation is a little different...

One vote for Prime says you're wrong but yeah, there's a sharp dropoff after the top four.

Is there really no other planet-hopping game though? Bleh if true.

 

[neojubei]

Little Big Planet.

 

[sonycowboy]

1) Killzone 2 (by a mile)
2) Little Big Planet
3) Call of Duty 4
4) Mass Effect
5) Uncharted

 

[GreekWolf]

i think a LOT of it has to do with childhood nostalgia

Hey, I'll be honest and freely admit that nostalgia plays a big factor in my fanatical anticipation for Mass Effect. Watching that Gamespot demo the other night was just like being a kid again, when the folks took me to see Star Wars for the very first time. Since that night, I've been patiently waiting to play a game that recaptures that same magic from sitting in the theater, and watching this incredible reality set in a science-fiction universe unfold. Games like KoToR were a step in the right direction but, up until now, the technology just wasn't there to create something truly believable.

Well, the time has finally arrived and I couldn't be more excited. Real, digitized actors, each with their own personality and character traits. A revolutionary conversation system that allows you to express your thoughts and emotions on the fly, even if it means rudely interrupting an 8 foot tall alien with a bad attitude. Exploration of hundreds of worlds, all layered with a ridiculous amount of detail.

Even without the nostalgia factor, Mass Effect would be a great game in its own right... but for us children of the 80's, it's like a dream come true.

 

[taku]

My game(s) of the show is a tie between Little Big Planet and Super Mario Galaxy. They were both tremendously impressive.

 

[Threi]

One vote for Prime says you're wrong but yeah, there's a sharp dropoff after the top four.

Is there really no other planet-hopping game though? Bleh if true.

Well yeah, that was kinda the point i was trying to make

Ratchet? @_@

 

[Yixian]

All it takes is one trailer and it wins whatever show it's at.

 

[Uncle]

How about MGS 0 votes? Guess cutscene trailers dont cut it anymore. And what about Crysis?

Oh yeah, I didn't even notice that no one had voted for MGS. I guess Killzone stole it's thunder. Absence of Crysis isn't that surprising since there doesn't seem to be very many PC gamers on the boards.

 

[Error]

Super Mario Galaxy for me.

 

[tak]

banjo koozie 3, it wins even if it is not shown

 

[Woo-Fu]

Was Left 4 Dead at the show? I'm hyped for it, but I haven't seen an E3 coverage of the game.

Going to be an awful lot of cries for help over mics when that game comes out.

"Help!!! There is a zom.. there are 5... there are 10... omg, help!!!!"

 

[so1337]

Super Mario Galaxy

Haven't been this excited about a game since Super Mario Sunshine (even though that one turned out to be kind of a disappointment...oh, well.).

 

[artist]

KZ2

 

[Sharp]

Ratchet? @_@

That's like calling Kingdom Hearts a planet-hopping game.

 

[joedan]

Resident Evil 5 If trailers count.

Otherwise Super Mario Galaxy

 

[laserbeam]

Galaxy for sure

 

[Threi]

That's like calling Kingdom Hearts a planet-hopping game.

I dunno i never played it. I just heard somebody say that Mario galaxy was unoriginal because Ratchet did something similar @_@

i don't know then

 

[devilscallmedad]

Votes For System Exclusives
Nintendo 41
Sony 26
Microsoft 24

GAF hardware bias poll
Nintendo 41%
Sony 29%
Microsoft 27%



:lol

 

[AAK]

Ratchet and Clank

 

[Visualante]

Votes For System Exclusives
Nintendo 41
Sony 26
Microsoft 24

GAF hardware bias poll
Nintendo 41%
Sony 29%
Microsoft 27%



:lol

Come back in 24 hours.

 

[h1nch]

SMG looks awesome, but I'm still hesitant to commit to it 100% after the trainwreck that was Mario Sunshine. I'll stick with a wait-and-see approach for the time being.

CoD4 gets my vote, followed by Assassin's Creed.

 

[Gigglepoo]

banjo koozie 3, it wins even if it is not shown

Man, we don't even know the name of it yet. I want my Banjo!

 

[HocusPocus]

Votes For System Exclusives
Nintendo 41
Sony 26
Microsoft 24

GAF hardware bias poll
Nintendo 41%
Sony 29%
Microsoft 27%



:lol

Lower the Microsoft one to under 10% and raise the Sony one up the same amount and you'll have it here.

 

[Defcon]

Little Big Planet. I'll probably buy a PS3 this year because of it.

 

[nelkon and parker]

Chalk me up for Mass Effect.

 

[Gigglepoo]

Little Big Planet. I'll probably buy a PS3 this year because of it.

The finished game will not actually be released for a year, though. Still, I had the same reaction. This and Echochrome are impossible to resist.

 

[Azure Dream]

I'm not digging out pics, but you've seen these before by now, anyway.

Winner: Super Mario Galaxy

It can't be helped. What they showed was an absolute knock-out. It looks better than every other Wii game, even those unreleased that we've seen so far. (Sorry, Brawl, you still look fantastic though!) It has a charm and imagination that the Mario series has been sorely missing. It makes grown men and women wide-eyed with wonder. It makes me a little sad that Nintendo's pushing away from making games like it and Twilight Princess, when they do it so well.


Runner-up: Call of Duty 4

I usually don't care much about shooters. I care even less about the Call of Duty series. But the detail, and the animated motion, and the intelligent narrative/dialogue... things just had a "punch" that caught me off-guard, staring at the TV while it showed. It generated a lot of interest from me, in a genre and particularly in a series I don't play heavily, so it deserves props for that.

 

[DreamMachine]

mass effect!!

 

[Xamdou]

Mass Effect!!!

 

[AltogetherAndrews]

Killzone

Runner-up: Ratchet & Clank TOD

 

[Xenon]

omg :lol People see this as a good thing?

 

[schuelma]

Galaxy...I feel like a little kid when I see the videos. Most hyped game for me in a long time.