Well, I think they may want to examine where their dislike of those things is coming from, but no, thats a perfectly fine reason to dislike something.
Its NOT however, a good reason to scream about how the game is horrible and it ruined final fantasy and anyone who likes it is an obvious creep and terrible person. (All things that have been said, in this thread, about the game).
I'm not a big fan of heavily masculine, violent shooty stuff, in general. So...I don't play those games. I don't make threads about how terrible those games are, and I don't tell people who like them that they are horrible people.
Its not the liking/disliking that is the issue, its people's inability to handle others liking/disliking things in ways they don't approve of. This thread, as started by the OP, is basically 1 step away from trolling, and certainly didn't convey anything that actually needed to be said.
"But, the OP wanted to know why people liked the game! He was curious because he disliked it!" you say. Well, the OP post is basically him mocking the game and basically saying he could never understand why people liked it. (he also only played 40 minutes, which does that even get you gameplay? Its been so long I don't remember, but in some FFs it definitely doesn't) But then throughout the thread he ignores people who say they like it, he argues that people's explanations for why they liked it can't be true, and just in general shows no interest in actually having his opinion changed.
And if you aren't interested in having your opinion changed, or at least aren't open to the possibility, don't make a thread for it. its pointless and just makes people mad. (this applies to a lot of threads on GAF, and of course on messageboards throughout the interent. This is nothing new. I've been on various messageboards for over 15 years, and I know how this goes. Acting like this is something shocking and beyond the pale doesn't fool anyone.)
Anyway, what the OP wanted wasn't to find out why people liked the game, he wanted to mock people who liked the game, and have his opinion that the game was shitty and girly validated by others. And many posters went right ahead and did just that. They confirmed for each other that they weren't bad for not liking girly things, and reestablished their manhood credits.
I've seen this dozens and dozens of times, this isn't new. This has been happening literally since before the game even came out, well over a decade ago.
Do you want to know what the reactions were when the first key visual was released? I bet you can imagine. Its not hard.
And then the game came out, and the reactions were, well, exactly what we've seen.
I don't care if you like the game or not, but if you're gonna come out and publicly announce yourself to be a jackass over it, don't be surprised when you get pushback.
A lot of people aren't as reasonable and as rational as they should be, or able to understand and at least try to appreciate other people's viewpoints. It's an inherent flaw with human nature as sad as it is. But the easy thing to do is just ignore them. I mean wasn't the biggest fan of FFX-2, so I just moved on. I'm also not a fan of the dudebro and overly macho stuff either, so largely ignore those too. I figured that was the simple and easy thing to do, not pay much attention to things that don't really interest me. It's only when I started browsing gaming forums that I realised there was so much drama about that single entry in a long franchise.
Yes there'll be people who are over dramatic in their criticisms of things you may enjoy, while refusing to see things from another side. They can be in their own.bubble at times. But it's best to forget them. Because when you get overly defensive as a counter it can make yourself look just as bad with your responses.