• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT4| New Ch/Vols! - SEE FIRST POST FOR RULES!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ah the good old weekly jump thread explosion. If only we had such treatment for the vastly superior manga...

upandaway said:
TLR 4

I'll just think of him going the harem route from the start to make this easier on myself.
Rito is a shithead. He is like Vaan from FFXII. He only serves to bring us near the actual characters.
Wiseblade said:
TLR 4
I wonder who else is going to get added to this harem? Will it be a ton of Magical girls and Haruna, school girls and Lulu or a mix of both?
Everything and anything.
 
One piece

Pretty good chapter. I like that Hody is just insane and that we aren't going to get some tragic backstory. Let him be just an insane person that has to be dealt with. I like seeing Brook and Robin's new powers, I'm expecting that there is going to be more to their powers and that this isn't it though.

Bleach

So put Ginjou vs. Ichigo on the cover and then not have them in the chapter? But OK chapter besides that. I think the more we have Tsukishima around the more confused I am about his power...

Any HxH spoilers around?
 
Nartuo

So, pretty much what we learnt from this chapter is that Sasuke will get the Rinnegan >__>

Bleach

I'm not sure how Tsukishima's retcon ability helps him know all of Byakuya's moves if he himself hasn't actually seen them, but ok *shrugs*

One Piece

I prefer this motivation for Hody than just some tragic past. Also, it had some Robin action, that inmediately makes me like this chapter.
 
The two Ussop pages alone made the One Piece chapter awesome for me. Him being all badass during a fight and not even breaking a sweat is amazing. I'm sure his old characteristics will remain to some extent but I like his and Chopper's development the most.
 
Karate Shoukoushi Kohinata Minoru v8

Hahaha wow. This tournament has been great so far. I love this.

Been a while (since... HxH) that I liked the non-fight stage of a tournament this much.

But yeah I love this now. Definitely didn't see that coming from the first couple volumes.
 
Naruto

Seeing Madara's power is a bit overwhelming. At least they are hyping him appropriately, he's supposed to be fucking terrifying. Too bad they had to resort to the Rinnegan... Seriously, Kishimoto could have had a well written series on his hands. They need to have three people on a team; the creative/concept dude, the writer, and the artist.

Bleach
So... how is Byakuya still not giving a fuck? Shouldn't he be buddies with Facebook now, or did Facebook just fuck up by only inserting himself into training sessions?

One Piece

Usopp, Brook, and Robin development. I like Usopp's new character traits, Brook's explanation of his powers + Soul Sword, and Robin's massive upgrade. She can teleport AND clone herself in addition to being able to generate gargantuan limbs (like Luffy) without the drawbacks.

Hody being an empty villain is great. I was expecting a scar or tattoo or something on his tongue, some sort of mutilation to make us feel empathy for him. Nope, he's just a monster without redemption that Luffy will, eventually, remorselessly beat into shit.
 
Sai said:
I imagine it's something similar to Kakashi, or Danzou's situation. They get the eyes, but because they aren't natural born Uchiha, they can't use them as potentially well as an Uchiha could.

Would also explain why Nagato seemingly couldn't deactivate the Rinnegan, just as Kakashi and Danzou couldn't deactivate Obito and Shisui's Sharingan.

This speculation wavers because:

A)In Jiraiya's flashback on Nagato he had normal eyes until the rinnegan activated, if they were implanted into his eye sockets this wouldn't be the case.
B)If Nagato wasn't born with the rinnegan, then how the fudge did Edo Tensei'd Nagato have the rinnegan.
 
upandaway said:
This kind of sentence is just as old, though.
The jump flood is the equivalent of anime-gaf random except anime-gaf random can be fun.
Sai said:
And then he goes on to start talking about To LOVE Ru.

:P
TLR is an idiot read but fun.
Solune said:
Damn exposed.
Tough to label if you are that myopic.

I retract my comment against the mainstream. Enjoy.
 
Steroyd said:
This speculation wavers because:

A)In Jiraiya's flashback on Nagato he had normal eyes until the rinnegan activated, if they were implanted into his eye sockets this wouldn't be the case.
B)If Nagato wasn't born with the rinnegan, then how the fudge did Edo Tensei'd Nagato have the rinnegan.

They're Edo-Tensei'd from when they died. He would have Rinnegan the same way the filler brothers had the Kyuubi's power from being in his stomach.
 
I think it's a law that 99% of Korean comics must turn to shit after a set period of time, if they didn't start out shitty from the start.
 
Dresden said:
I think it's a law that 99% of Korean comics must turn to shit after a set period of time, if they didn't start out shitty from the start.
That's about on par with the 98.99% of manga.

Freezing
Legend of Maian
Onihime VS
The Breaker

haven't. Unbalance and Sun-Ken Rock are there or on their way.
 
Breaker went to shit (from shitville) like 50% of the way in.

Freezing is Im Dal Young, a.k.a. shit. Same for Unbalance.

Haven't read the rest but I'm sure they're shit.

It's kind of sad because there has to be more being published and stuff but the only stuff that makes it over here are the junk.
 
KuwabaraTheMan said:
One Piece:
Fuck yeah, Usopp is a man amongst men. I'm so glad to see him getting a chance to shine. Best part of One Piece in quite some time.


Can't wait when he shares his adventure stories with Kaya again (and they will be real this time).
 
Naruto

Madara was cool until the Rinnegan bullshit. It was cool as a rare eye ability that appears for no reason every few hundred years or whatever. But now that's ruined.
 
Holy shit Robin's new powers have some serious fetish fuel potential.
 
One Piece

Goddamn. This chapter was awesome. I'm good with that Hody revelation (it's what I really wanted). It ties perfectly to what the whole Fisher Tiger and Otohime flashback was about. Hody is a product of a generated saturated with racism, who passed along their hate to the youth thus creating the entirety of the current conflict. It's easy to call him insane, but there's more to it. I really liked those images of Hody as Broshi was talking about him. He looked out of his mind; a guy who has lost control and lost his identity. He's nothing but a monster now. This is how I'll always remember him.

Yeah. There's nothing driving him. No tragic past. No justifiable motivation. He's just a victim of Arlong's will and a failed generation. That resonates more with me than a sad past. Depending on how it ends, Hody could end up being one of the more interesting villains in all of OP.

It sucks that so many people are down on this arc because it seems like they're overlooking some of Oda's more intelligent writing. This arc is really about the world of OP rather than the SH crew and what Oda has done in 40 chapters is kind of remarkable. He was able to carve out another piece of the universe with so many dimensions and he built it around an honest story. And the art is just fantastic. I can go on and on about OP but I'll stop now.

Naruto

Lol. What the hell? That Rinnegan was certainly surprising. I don't know how it makes sense but whatever.

Bleach

Rukia was funny. The only bright spot in this chapter. Keep cashing in that check Kubo.
 
vicissitudes said:
Naruto

Madara was cool until the Rinnegan bullshit. It was cool as a rare eye ability that appears for no reason every few hundred years or whatever. But now that's ruined.

I suspected the Uchiha eye can get to sage eyes after the whole decendent from Sage
 
Infinite Justice said:
Her powers always did though
(check some of the hentai :))
I know, they just got even better :)
 
Dresden said:
Breaker went to shit (from shitville) like 50% of the way in.

Freezing is Im Dal Young, a.k.a. shit. Same for Unbalance.

Haven't read the rest but I'm sure they're shit.

It's kind of sad because there has to be more being published and stuff but the only stuff that makes it over here are the junk.
Well Breaker still has potential with the better characters. It's funny you say 50% in when the beginning of the Breaker was the worst part. Freezing also had its rough spots but I'm positive about first chronicle. Dal Young's stuff is hit or miss. I wouldn't say it is all bad and I'm liking Legend of Maian.

The question I would pose is what's better? These are action series primarily and most shounen doesn't measure up. What I would compare against is the good seinen like Until Death Do Us Part. It's not like your Bleach, Naruto, OP, etc... are shattering the quality of action seinen and manhwa.

The good shounen stuff also has a chance like Blood Lad and Beezlebub. They are a level above the mainstream jump even though I have a soft spot for what Magico brings. You also can't go really wrong with classics like Chrno Crusade, Claymore, Berserk, and even other stuff like Superior.

The standards of reading are really weird today. However, it isn't as crazy as what anime has shifted to. There are definitely manga gems out there like Blood Lad (read it!).

I also read TLR, hurp derp
 
Wiseblade said:
It can also turn into the Rinnegan which has the power to:
  • Summon a number of giant creatures, each with different powers.
  • Mechanically augment their body, with extra limbs or weaponry.
  • Control Gravity
  • Remove someone's soul or read their mind.
  • Summon a seperate creature capable of interrogation and healing.
  • Absorb an infinte amount of Chakra.

Is there anything I'm missing?
It allows the user to use all elements in any combination. It can do anything.
 
Kusagari said:
Do we even know if Madara could summon this huge meteor before? Kabuto said he made Madara stronger. Madara's Rinnegan might have been gimped like Nagato's in his life.
I'm guessing he was given a Uzumaki clan body.
 
Naruto

tumblr_lr62sfOoY81qdlkgg.gif

kishi just had to find a way to give The sauce ranieningan too.

Sharengain can do everything

Bleach

azien 3 is trolling me more than his opponent by confusing the fuck out of me
 
Naruto: F+

The plus is because there was some kind of relevant action.

Everything else...shake my fucking head. FUCK. It's so awful. This has opened up so many potential plotholes and questions and necessary backtracking. Like, seriously? I think Kishimoto doesn't give a fuck anymore.

Sasuke with the Rinnegan. Okay. Sasuke > Naruto. Madara > Naruto.

This is so stupid.

Bleach: C+

Oh Kubo. If you have made this whole chapter Tsukishima vs Byakuya this would've been an A. Seriously, the first few pages of this chapter were awesome. At first I thought Book of The End was just some random power, but it's really being fleshed out in its ability - and it's pretty awesome. Tsukishima is such a great troll/enemy. And he always has quotables:

"Every tactic you've ever created won't work on me...Those moves and tactics were all born from countless hours of training...

...with ME"

Great. But I also like that Byakuya is still sporting that Byakuya swag and isn't bitching up like Ichigo did. The Rukia part was too long but it had to be covered, I'm not a particular fan of Rukia and her love of the cute stuff, it's cool, but whatever.
 
I hate Tsukishima's power because it's even worse than Aizen's. He could literally kill Byakuya right now by going into his past. He should be unbeatable.
 
Karate Shoukoushi Kohinata Minoru

OH MY GOD

HE-

HE JUST-

WHAT THE FUCK

DODGED A SPINNING ELBOW

AND TURNED THAT

INTO A GODDAMN SPINNING ELBOW

FUCKKKKKKKKKK

GENIUS

just give me a chapter of reaction faces now. and even that won't be enough.

i don't care about hyperbole anymore. the fights are short as hell but some of the finishers are god-tier
 
Naruto

The thing about Tobi is that we were given the idea that EMS gave you eternal life, which is why "Madara" was able to live this long. However, real Madara is dead with the EMS. Does Tobi even have an EMS? For him to be Madara's brother, he actually has to be immortal/ageless, which given Madara's death, I doubt.
 
Karate Shoukoushi Kohinata Minoru - The Blazing Final Fight

Yeah ok wow. I fully support my earlier statement. Doubly so even. This was insane. Helmet saved the fucker.

Man, so I'm almost caught up? Damn. At least they translate fast, thank god.
 
Someone please explain to me this: If the Sharingan can become the rinnegan (think about that for a minute), then why the FUCK did the Sage of the six paths have two kids and supposedly have given one the rinnegan and the other the sharingan? Why when the fucking sharingan can become the rinnegan?
 
Stat Flow said:
Someone please explain to me this: If the Sharingan can become the rinnegan (think about that for a minute), then why the FUCK did the Sage of the six paths have two kids and supposedly have given one the rinnegan and the other the sharingan? Why when the fucking sharingan can become the rinnegan?

Did the other kid have a rinnegan?


If Sasuke gets the Rinnegan then Naruto will get it too cause apparently he's related to Senju.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom