as far as this screencap goes, the 'night' scene xo version looks remarkably better than the 360 version, but i meant i want to see a video treatment of it, like the ps3/ps4 version got.
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
MGS V: Ground Zeroes Console Quality Comparison Video
- Thread starter jbug617
- Start date
as far as this screencap goes, the 'night' scene xo version looks remarkably better than the 360 version, but i meant i want to see a video treatment of it, like the ps3/ps4 version got.
SenjutsuSage
Banned
I think it does. PS4 received real next gen enhancements from the looks of it, whereas Xbox One version is more along the lines of the current gen releases, and it actually shows in the video footage. Don't know how else to say it, but when a system as old as the 360 seems to rival the xbox one, something is wrong.
Windom Earle
Banned
lol @ people saying PS360 hold up well. 30fps and sub-hd... So satisfying!
iceDragon7
Banned
Grimløck;101414234 said:
The game barely looks a step above current gen. There's hardly anything extra going on. You could even say ps4 should be able to run the game at 4k based on the leap since it seems to be pushing the same geometry across all versions. If the engine was on PC first then that's even more reason for the xbone to keep pace as both new machines may as well be modded laptops.
Shao Kahn Brewing a Stew
Banned
They'll find out once they actually start playing.
8-9 year old hardware.
Amentallica
Unconfirmed Member
What generational leaps are some of you expecting? It seems like some people expect to go from N64 -> PS3 in terms of quality. We already are reaching CGI fidelity in graphics, and while there is room for improvement in so many areas of games, there will never be as big of a leap as was possible before. Now there is room to improve IQ, frame rate, and effects in games, but set your expectations.
And with that said, there are differences in the video, and the PS4 version definitely looks and runs better than the other three versions. Deal with it.
Jesus fuck.
And with that said, there are differences in the video, and the PS4 version definitely looks and runs better than the other three versions. Deal with it.
Jesus fuck.
DirgeExtinction
Member
Maybe Kojima gave the PS4 "special treatment" because he saw it was the only console that can realize his next gen vision(1080p, 60fps, near photorealistic graphics)?
Shao Kahn Brewing a Stew
Banned
Holy shit. Sidelining.
Just pointing out how silly some posts are, calling out Kojima's team when the biggest xBone game looks just as dodgy (as a cross gen title).
See?
Then get off your 1080p display and get to an optometrist. The PS4 version is likely pushing three times the resolution and double the framerate of the PS3 version and you can barely see the difference? Which video are you watching exactly?
as someone who has both consoles and doesn't have a dog in this fight to protect, i don't see anyone in here panicking. the game still looks good.
lovely ladies
Member
What it has felt like around here since the next gen consoles have launched;
I guess all of this is mildly entertaining at least.
Lol, we are not really dealing with a D grade development house here, I think I'll give Kojima and his bros the benefit of the doubt.
Honestly after this? I wouldn't be suprised.
Though its more likely it was running on a PC they probably didn't even have a dev kit for E3 to run it on.
Its sure as hell not going to look like it did in that video on the X1...
Spring-Loaded
Member
This honestly isn't a troll question: why did snake running on Xbone look smoother to me than it did on PS4? Like, the motions, not the resolution
is it like some optical illusion because of the lower resolution?
is it like some optical illusion because of the lower resolution?
travisbickle
Member
Yes.
My response is the first half of Littlejonny's post but with the company names switched.
BIONIC-ARRRMMM!!
Member
DirgeExtinction
Member
To me it seemed slower than the PS4 version, but slightly faster/smoother than the PS360 versions.
foxuzamaki
Doesn't read OPs, especially not his own
Yeah, the graphics are pretty average.
TitanFall might be fun to play, but that doesn't diminish the fact that the graphics in that game aren't all that good and even those graphics make the Xbox One drop the FPS in some situations quite noticeably.
Here you go, makes the comparison easier:
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/63318
Lighting looks... odd on the XB1 version. Might be due to a spot light though.
eyeball_kid
Member
Huh, guess I didn't see the ToraShiro correction. Last thing I saw was a gaf saltstorm. Thanks for the heads-up.
LittleJohnny
Banned
not sure why i've seen people saying the xbo is clearly an upressed 360 version, it's pretty obvious that the xbo has the same geometry upgrades the ps4 version got, it's just that the xbo version is lacking the higher resolution, better lighting model (dat sky), and what looks like the better anti aliasing of the ps4 version
nice, thanks for that.
i guess i'll have to wait for someone to do a side-by-side though with the ps4 version with the same scene.
I think you're just seeing the effects of watching a fairly low res video streaming online. It all gets a bit muddy.
maybe the xbone version cant handle the dynamic sky whilst maintaining 60fps (and possibly 720p too lol)
SenjutsuSage
Banned
Xbox One is better hardware than 360
Not according to this video, it isn't. State of the Xbox One version with respect to the 360 version is downright embarrassing. My final statement on the subject.
Lots of waiting to do.
XBO = 360, you heard it straight from Sage folks!
i doubt it. i'm sure digital foundry will jump right to it once they get both versions in the lab. they're predictable, if not dependable, like that.
DirgeExtinction
Member
*shrugs* not trying to be condescending in any way towards XB1 owners. I'm just throwing possibilities out there. We know the XB1 has trouble with 1080p/60fps with graphically intensive games without turning down some options(AA, DoF, etc). The PS4, on the other hand, seems more than capable of being up to the task.
Shin-Ra
Junior Member
Apparently
Sub-720p > full 1080p (PS4) 720p (XBO)
Improved atmospheric/sky rendering (PS4)
30fps > 60fps
Increased draw distance/extra scenery props
Increased texture resolution and anisotropic filtering
Added high frequency detail textures
Added motion blur (possibly DoF too)
Improved lighting
Improved shadow res/smoothing
Isn't a worthy generational upgrade in an open-world game from a Japanese developer.
Sub-720p > full 1080p (PS4) 720p (XBO)
Improved atmospheric/sky rendering (PS4)
30fps > 60fps
Increased draw distance/extra scenery props
Increased texture resolution and anisotropic filtering
Added high frequency detail textures
Added motion blur (possibly DoF too)
Improved lighting
Improved shadow res/smoothing
Isn't a worthy generational upgrade in an open-world game from a Japanese developer.
Shao Kahn Brewing a Stew
Banned
Seems like it. Dynamic weather/skybox is a load on the console, and if XBO is struggling with 720p then it was best to not add it.
viveks86
Gold Member
Oh come on now. The xbox one still runs at twice the framerate and slightly better textures. Do you have to take one extreme position or the other?
Sorry, it was a reference to you also saying "we will just have to wait and see" in the PS4 sells 5.3 million thread.
iceDragon7
Banned
See? At minimum the one is 6-8 times more powerful and 4 8-10 yet all 4 look pretty much the same. There's really no use in arguing though. This new gen is awful all around so far.
thunder_snail
Member
From the screenshots, yes this game shows the bigger difference. But in motion, the difference in TR is bigger. Read my post again. TR for xbone : worse textures at half the framerate. GZ for xbone : worse sky at half the resolution. And as far as the differences go, framerate > resolution when you're actually playing the game, not staring at screenshots. If the resolution was more important, Kojima would've gone 1080p/30fps for xbone like Tomb Raider.
Blue barrels and telephone lines exclusive to the bone
Xbone has a lot of headroom, PS4 is rendering same scenes with 2.3x pixels.
oh that. that was just in reference to me not being the kind of guy to crown a console winner after just three months. call me an optimist, but i usually like waiting a year before forming an opinion on such matters.
The MGS case is a glorious addition.
Some people expect more from next gen graphics other than resolution and frame-rate. Others are less discerning.
viveks86
Gold Member
Blue barrels and telephone lines exclusive to the bone
LOL!
juicyfruitas
Member
Great video - more devs/publishers need to start doing this as well.
putting Digital Foundry out of business tho....
putting Digital Foundry out of business tho....
I can't see that, not if this sells well on PS360.
Similar threads
- Locked