MLB 2019 |OT| Eat, Sleep, Baseball (Postseason not included)

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#1


This game never stops! As soon as the season ends, another begins.

Offseason for free agent signings and adjustments to your roster. Coming to terms with player who are arbitration eligible.

Spring Training to get ready for the season and further fine tuning of a teams roster.

Regular Season The 162. Determining who will be Playoff eligible.

Post Season To determine who is the champions for the season.

And immediately the Offseason starts again. Whats not to love?

This is the greatest invention of the human race. Baseball > The Wheel.

This OT will serve us for The Offseason, Spring Training, and the Regular Season. Post Season will get its own OT.

And boy do we have a lot to talk about. This free agent class is a big one, with 2 of the best in the game (Harper and Machado) looking to secure huge contracts. And many others waiting to see how high they push it to secure their own.

Huge players looking to be traded and teams determining that perhaps giving prospects for MLB ready players is a better strategy than giving huge contracts to free agents.

Pitchers and Catchers report in a month!!!

Let's talk Baseball NeoGAF, because this game never stops.

The 3 BIG names I expect to see news on soon...
1. Bryce Harper
2. Manny Machado
3. Corey Kluber

For Baseball news

https://twitter.com/dougherty_jesse Washington Nationals Reporter

https://twitter.com/JonHeyman Jon Heyman

https://twitter.com/Ken_Rosenthal Ken Rosenthal

https://twitter.com/Buster_ESPN Buster Olney

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com MLB Trade Rumors

 
Last edited:
Likes: Jroderton

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#2
Reserved for Current MLB News

-Bryce Harper and Boras met with the Phillies organization in Las Vegas today (Saturday January 12th)

-Phillies "Optimistic" they will sign either Machado or Harper http://www.philly.com/phillies/bryc...ter_impression=true&__twitter_impression=true and are the clear front runners according to Bob Nightengal

-Over a dozen arbitration eligible players didn't come to terms with their teams https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2019/01/unresolved-2019-arbtration-cases.html including The Rockies and Nolan Arenado. The Rockies submitted 24 million and Arenado submitted 30 Million!!! Difference of 6 Million... *Important to keep in mind that while the deadline to arbitration was yesterday (Friday January 11th) Teams and Players can continue to negotiate up to their hearings*

-Giants Re-Signed Derek Holland https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2019/01/giants-re-sign-derek-holland.html

-White Sox may or may not have upped their offer to Machado to 8 Years 250 Million
 
Last edited:
Dec 3, 2013
16,584
9,186
555
#3
Let's go Red Sox :messenger_clapping:..:messenger_clapping:..:messenger_clapping::messenger_clapping::messenger_clapping:..:messenger_clapping:

That reminds me, I need to create my Road to the Show player in The Show to get the rest of the trophies to Plat it.

I used to just strictly just play that mode, but now I play it more in the offseason and Season/Chise during regular.

On topic, looking forward to some of the moves pre or going into ST. Especially which team signs that diva, Machado.
 
Last edited:

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#4
Let's go Red Sox :messenger_clapping:..:messenger_clapping:..:messenger_clapping::messenger_clapping::messenger_clapping:..:messenger_clapping:

That reminds me, I need to create my Road to the Show player in The Show to get the rest of the trophies to Plat it.

I used to just strictly just play that mode, but now I play it more in the offseason and Season/Chise during regular.

On topic, looking forward to some of the moves pre-ST. Especially which gets that diva, Machado.
I've heard they are moving on from Kimbrel. Is their replacement already in house?
 
Dec 3, 2013
16,584
9,186
555
#5
I've heard they are moving on from Kimbrel. Is their replacement already in house?
Nothing so far other than Dombrowski saying that they're not looking for high expenditure on a closer.

Last I heard about Kimbrel yesterday was that they could possibly sign him to a one-year deal believe it or not. Teams are being more cautious now with long term contracts, and short term high year ($25-$30+ mil/year) due to luxury caps. The baseball economy is changing a bit as it should. More PED monitoring equals longer injury stints for long term contract weariness is one reason my guess.
 
Last edited:
Likes: Musky_Cheese
Oct 13, 2014
804
100
310
#6
Die-hard Mets fan here - I'm really excited about the moves that have been made thus far, though I'd like to see them make a move for another starter and bullpen help. I'm not entirely happy about the potential for one of Lagares or Broxton to be starting in CF, but I am holding out hope that they can dump Frazier's and perhaps Lagares's contract (at least partially) and maybe snag Pollack on a 2-year deal - though I know he wants more so it's not likely. If not, I'd like to see how McNeil fares in the outfield during spring training. It would be a shame to not have his bat in the lineup as often as possible, given what he did last season.

Still, it's always fun going into the season with some hope., and that doesn't always happen in Mets land. The NL East is looking pretty stacked though, so it should be interesting...
 
Likes: Musky_Cheese

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#7
Nothing so far other than Dombrowski saying that they're not looking for high expenditure on a closer.

Last I heard about Kimbrel yesterday was that they could possibly sign him to a one-year deal believe it or not. Teams are being more cautious now with long term contracts, and short term high year ($25-$30+ mil/year) due to luxury caps. The baseball economy is changing a bit as it should. More PED monitoring equals longer injury stints for long term contract weariness is one reason my guess.
Makes sense. I heard he was originally looking for a 6 year deal... YIKES

Die-hard Mets fan here

JK :pie_roffles:

Die-hard Mets fan here - I'm really excited about the moves that have been made thus far, though I'd like to see them make a move for another starter and bullpen help. I'm not entirely happy about the potential for one of Lagares or Broxton to be starting in CF, but I am holding out hope that they can dump Frazier's and perhaps Lagares's contract (at least partially) and maybe snag Pollack on a 2-year deal - though I know he wants more so it's not likely. If not, I'd like to see how McNeil fares in the outfield during spring training. It would be a shame to not have his bat in the lineup as often as possible, given what he did last season.

Still, it's always fun going into the season with some hope., and that doesn't always happen in Mets land. The NL East is looking pretty stacked though, so it should be interesting...
I was jealous of them signing Jeb. I wanted my Nats to sign Jeb.
 
Aug 19, 2007
8,485
213
950
#9
Cub fan checking in. Needed the giants to take heyward so we could get Harper.
I’m scared as fuck come 2020/2021 when half our team is free agents :( Can’t lose this core
 
Last edited:
Sep 28, 2014
2,041
215
325
#10
Cub fan checking in. Needed the giants to take heyward so we could get Harper.
I’m scared as fuck come 2020/2021 when half our team is free agents :( Can’t lose this core
Giants fan here and the last thing we need is another long term contract with an underperforming player.

Great OT! Can't wait for the season to start. Harper and Machado not wanting to sign in Philly despite being offered the most money is hilarious.
 
Aug 19, 2007
8,485
213
950
#11
Giants fan here and the last thing we need is another long term contract with an underperforming player.

Great OT! Can't wait for the season to start. Harper and Machado not wanting to sign in Philly despite being offered the most money is hilarious.
Same thing happened to the cardinals which is hilarious to me. I believe it was Lackey and Heyward took less to come to Chicago.
 
Jun 22, 2014
7,695
1,109
390
#12
Red Sox fan reporting in (sorry guys). The MLB offseason sucks so much, I get it and somewhat appreciate that teams are being smarter with money, but geez at least move the draft to somewhere around this time. The last thing that happened that I can remember was the Sox bringing back Eovaldi. The NBA and NFL are year long things, the MLB just forces you to forget about baseball until ST.
 
Likes: DeepEnigma

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#13
Red Sox fan reporting in (sorry guys). The MLB offseason sucks so much, I get it and somewhat appreciate that teams are being smarter with money, but geez at least move the draft to somewhere around this time. The last thing that happened that I can remember was the Sox bringing back Eovaldi. The NBA and NFL are year long things, the MLB just forces you to forget about baseball until ST.
Well. We go in circles don’t we based on how teams are winning in recent years.

And the majority of teams winning over the last 10 years aren’t doing so by making huge FA contracts. It’s done thru growing talent and making a big trade mid year if teams feel they are making a run.

It’s not surprising to me at all to see FA like it has been the last few seasons.
 
Jun 22, 2014
7,695
1,109
390
#14
Well. We go in circles don’t we based on how teams are winning in recent years.

And the majority of teams winning over the last 10 years aren’t doing so by making huge FA contracts. It’s done thru growing talent and making a big trade mid year if teams feel they are making a run.

It’s not surprising to me at all to see FA like it has been the last few seasons.
Yeah agreed, long term contracts for declining players are bad for teams and I'm glad they're avoiding that. I'd like to see some compromise between the MLBPA and the owners though, something like less arbitration years and a minimum salary threshold of sorts based around the team's revenue but with partially unguaranteed contracts as a counterpoint. And the draft should be around now as well.
 

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#15
Yeah agreed, long term contracts for declining players are bad for teams and I'm glad they're avoiding that. I'd like to see some compromise between the MLBPA and the owners though, something like less arbitration years and a minimum salary threshold of sorts based around the team's revenue but with partially unguaranteed contracts as a counterpoint. And the draft should be around now as well.
Absolutely agree with you.

The current setup doesn't seem ideal for the majority of player imo.
 
Likes: DeepEnigma

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#16
Phillies "optimistic" they will sign either Harper or Machado http://www.philly.com/phillies/bryc...ter_impression=true&__twitter_impression=true

Very strange wording imo. Not the optimistic part... they have a lot of money to spend even if they have to over spend to get one of them there.

But the "The Phillies are going to be finalists for both Harper and Machado." makes me scratch my head a bit because... they already are.

Even if there is a mystery team or 2 for either player, it is rumored that neither player has more than 3 or 4 teams interested. So of course the Phillies are going to be finalist. They already are exactly that.

Harper has the interest of Dodgers, Cubs, Phillies, Nationals, and White Sox. And can you really consider the Cubs as a real destination right now? The White Sox and Dodgers aren't willing to go more than 7 years.

Machado has even less interest. Supposedly The Yankees are out which seems likely since the signed Lemahieu. The Phillies and White Sox seem to be the only 2 teams that are interested.

Keep in mind that "interested" means willing to give these players somewhere near the contract they are looking for.

But who knows. Greinke to Arizona was out of no where.
 
Likes: DeepEnigma
Sep 28, 2014
2,041
215
325
#17
I honestly believe Machado's antics greatly impacted his market. Being an obnoxious player who gets under the other teams skin is one thing; going out of your way to intentionally injure players is another. That and coupled with his "not Johnny hussle", pimping homeruns that turn out to be doubles yet managing to end up on first, I doubt there's a lot of teams out there who want that level of stupidity.

A player as talented and as young as him should have had no trouble landing a long term deal even with the current trends in FA. The lack of interest is baffling.
 
Likes: DeepEnigma

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#18
Bob Nightengal is now saying that Phillies are clear cut favorites to land Harper


FYI some of the details contradict other well known sources. Such as A) The Nationals haven't been in contact with Harper in a month and B) they won't offer more than 25 million a year.
 
Last edited:
Likes: DeepEnigma
Nov 5, 2016
3,462
2,225
270
I don't care where (just far)
#22
Have you guys followed the Kyler Murray story? Sounds like he wants the A’s to pay him 15 million to not play in the NFL instead.

From what I read it sounds like in order to pay him that, they would have to place him on the 40 man roster despite probably not calling him up for years.

Not sure I remember a situation in recent history where a player commanded such clout in two pro leagues (it’s possible he’ll be first QB drafted).

Also, sounds like A’s wouldn’t get a compensatory pick if Murray goes NFL, though he would have to return the 4 million signing bonus they paid him.

That’s my understanding of the situation, anyway
 
Last edited:
Likes: Musky_Cheese

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#23
Have you guys followed the Kyler Murray story? Sounds like he wants the A’s to pay him 15 million to not play in the NFL instead.

From what I read it sounds like in order to pay him that, they would have to place him on the 40 man roster despite probably not calling him up for years.

Not sure I remember a situation in recent history where a player commanded such clout in two pro leagues (it’s possible he’ll be first QB drafted).

Also, sounds like A’s wouldn’t get a compensatory pick if Murray goes NFL, though he would have to return the 4 million signing bonus they paid him.

That’s my understanding of the situation, anyway
Certainly is a fascinating story.

I can't blame anyone (Players Union or otherwise) for not having planed on a situation like this.

In other news lol

 
Last edited:

Musky_Cheese

Community Liaison
Oct 23, 2016
3,636
4,559
625
#27
I don’t blame Murray. It’s a business and he’s playing a business move. Curious how it turns out.

Also, regarding Machado and Harper.....

I get these guys are stars, I get they are gonna make insane-o money, but do either of these guys scream “Championship Material,” honestly?
For 2019, would you win more games giving $30 million to
A) Harper
B) Machado
C) Kimbrel

The answer is C

I’ve spent the last 7 years watching Harper. I probably watch 150 Nats games a year minimum.

But I am more than ok with my Nats OF being Soto, Robles, Eaton to start the season.
 
Likes: JareBear
#29
Machado supposedly has a 7/175 ($25 a year) offer from the White Sox.

Obviously the market isn't as high as some thought it would be.
I’m honestly not surprised. Both these guys have been part of talented teams (in certain seasons, maybe not for the entirety of time in Baltimore/Washington but each were part of multiple playoff runs and neither have been particularly impactful in playoffs, from what I remember). Machado has temper tantrums and Harper seems like he’s always dealing with some minor injury of any sort.

Both great players but I don’t look at either guy like “ok NOW we are winning the series.”