Support NeoGAF

[cormack12]

Spoiler: Top Three

Spoiler: Top Ten - Text

Top Ten - Text List

Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild	419​
The Witcher III: Wild Hunt	391​
Bloodborne	365​
Dark Souls	255​
Red Dead Redemption 2	219​
The Last of Us. Pt I	220​
God of War	216​
Skyrim	193​
The Last of Us. Pt II	155​
Grand Theft Auto V	129​

Spoiler: Games scoring > 9 points

Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild	419​
The Witcher III: Wild Hunt	391​
Bloodborne	365​
Dark Souls	255​
Red Dead Redemption 2	219​
The Last of Us. Pt I	220​
God of War	216​
Skyrim	193​
The Last of Us. Pt II	155​
Grand Theft Auto V	129​
Super Mario Odyssey	87​
Portal 2	79​
Nier: Automata	74​
Ghost of Tsushima	73​
Persona 5	72​
Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain	71​
Final Fantasy VII: Remake	70​
Dark Souls III	68​
Half Life: Alyx	66​
Deus Ex: Human Revolution	63​
Death Stranding	59​
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End	59​
Horizon: Zero dawn	57​
Doom	55​
Monster Hunter World	55​
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice	51​
Doom Eternal	47​
Yakuza 0	47​
Demon's Souls	46​
Cyberpunk 2077	39​
Dragon Quest XI	37​
Spider-Man	37​
Final Fantasy XIV: Endwalker	36​
Halo: Infinite	34​
Xenoblade Chronicles	34​
Mass Effect: Legendary Edition	33​
Resident Evil 2	33​
Batman: Arkham City	32​
Destiny	32​
Alien: Isolation	31​
Divinity: Original Sin II	31​
Shadow of the Colussus	31​
Dragon's Dogma	30​
Hollow Knight	30​
Hades	29​
Battlefield 3	28​
Dark Souls II	27​
Returnal	27​
Titanfall 2	25​
Destiny 2	24​
Journey	24​
Assassin's Creed: Odyssey	22​
Overwatch	22​
XCOM 2	22​
Xenoblade chronicles 2	21​
Assassin's creed: Origins	20​
It Takes Two	20​
PlayerUnknownBattleGrounds	20​
Apex Legends	19​
BioShock Infinite	19​
Max Payne 3	19​
Persona 4: The Golden	19​
Celeste	17​
Disco Elysium	17​
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze	17​
Fallout 4	17​
Mario Kart 8	16​
Super Smash Bros. Ultimate	16​
Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception	16​
Animal Crossing: New Horizons	15​
Dishonored	15​
Forza Horizon 5	15​
Ori and the Will O' the Wisps	15​
Stardew Valley	15​
Super Mario 3D World	15​
Astro bot	14​
Dishonored 2	14​
Kingdom come: Deliverance	14​
Life Is Strange	14​
The Last Guardian	14​
The Walking Dead	14​
Undertale	14​
13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim	13​
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare	13​
Inside	13​
Mass Effect 3	13​
Borderlands 2	12​
Cuphead	12​
Dead Space 2	12​
Dota 2	12​
FTL: Faster Than Light	12​
Resident Evil VII: Biohazard	12​
Spec Ops: The Line	12​
The Witness	12​
The Wonderful 101	12​
XCOM: Enemy Unknown	12​
Fire Emblem Awakening	11​
Forza Horizon 4	11​
Metroid Dread	11​
Psychonauts 2	11​
Ace Combat 7: Skies Unknown	10​
Days Gone	10​
Driveclub	10​
Dying Light	10​
Far Cry 3	10​
Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order	10​
Xenoblade Chronicles X	10​
Yakuza: Like a Dragon	10​

 

[crazy monkey]

I am ok with the list .

 

[The Cockatrice]

Bloodborne robbed again. Glad to also see Deus Ex in the list.

 

[DelireMan7]

To be perfect it should be Dark Souls on top followed by Bloodborne.

But a pretty nice list. I like it. Neogaf doesn't disappoint !

EDIT : Just realized the gap between #4 et the top 3. Funny ^^

 

[Bartski]

 

[Wohc]

Skyrim, Mario Odyssey and GTA V should be higher, but Top 5 looks good.

 

[tommib]

My hot take: everything’s ok but Witcher III should not be on the list.

 

[STARSBarry]

Not exactly thrilled by the number 1 slot, but it goes to show just how many people play switch on the forums despite most posts inside gaming being Sony or Microsoft focused. So grats to BotW.

While Monster Hunter World didn't make the top 20 it was pleasant to see the FF7 Remake, Neir Automata and Persona 5 getting near the top, alongside Deus Ex at number 20.

But 2021 just did not register at all, I thought Forza Horizon 5 would be higher given the lists people where posting in the thread, a real shame.

 

[yamaci17]

such a shame i'll never have the luxury to be able to afford a vr set and play half life alyx...

 

[Chukhopops]

Strong recency bias and some weird outliers but overall, not bad.

 

[DukeNukem00]

such a shame i'll never have the luxury to be able to afford a vr set and play half life alyx...

Come on, "never" is a long time. You never know when an awesome job comes up that pays well. In the meantime, just save a little bit every month, sooner or later you'll have it. It's not like it costs a fortune, a quest 2 is 300$ on amazon

 

[Bragr]

Not a bad list, this forum is very FromSoftware heavy and the list reflects that. I am happy to see Deus Ex on there, and a bit surprised that so many on here love the FF7 Remake that much.

 

[Y0ssarian]

Hmm maybe I should play Zelda again.

Persona 5 should have been #1

 

[Bo_Hazem]

Ok glad it's not Halo Infinite again. This doesn't fit my preference but at least it's very understandable and reasonable.

 

[The Cockatrice]

such a shame i'll never have the luxury to be able to afford a vr set and play half life alyx...

you will but the better question is should you waste money on VR for one game? I wish the VR scene would get more games like Alyx, story focused, big budget and all that but so far in that department it's dead. If there were at least 10-20+ games like Alyx it would be much more worth. Not really interested in other VR stuff.

 

[nominedomine]

Damn good list actually, except for Skyrim (I still don't get what people see in this game).

 

[TintoConCasera]

Not a list I could agree with, but there are some good titles over there for sure.

I would remove TLOU 2 while leaving the first one, and also remove GoT.

Put GoW a little bit lower, raise Persona 5, and finally add Yakuza 0 and Monster Hunter World.

 

[Fuz]

Swap 1 with 4 and it's a pretty decent list. Not perfect, but decent enough.

 

[Hugare]

Love you, GAF. So happy to see Human Revolution on the list.

It's one of my all time favorites for sure. It's a very special game.

BOTW at #1, tho ...

I'll have to accept (one day) that maybe I'm one of the few people that dont understand why its so beloved, but not today

 

[RoadHazard]

Not bad, nerds. I agree with a lot of that.

 

[NeoIkaruGAF]

I haven‘t even played many of these, but solid list, I guess. I’d only take out Dark Souls 3 and replace it with… I dunno, maybe a Xenoblade game? The list already features two FS titles, both of which are far better than DS3.

 

[Tg89]

Solid list.

 

[ahtlas7]

Interesting list especially for Sony.
congrats to these games!

 

[Alter_Fridge]

My hot take: everything’s ok but Witcher III should not be on the list.

 

[Touch fuzZy. get BizZay]

Some great games

wow botw crushed it

 

[Bonfires Down]

Other than the souls games and Nier I do like almost every game here that I've played. BotW and Witcher are predictable but they are deserving.

 

[chixdiggit]

Good list. Some thoughts:

• Half Life Alyx deserved higher but understandable for a PC-VR game.
• Nintendo ranked pretty low overall. Smash, Kart, Crossing, Splatoon, Donkey Kong, etc didn't even make the top 50. Not saying I disagree, just surprising.
• From Software killed it. Really need to give their games another go.
• Deus Ex top 20! Good job GAF.
• Ranked at #67, Mario Kart is the highest ranked racing game on the list followed by Forza Horizon 5 at #72
• No sports games
• No Rocket League
• No Knack (clearly a miscount?)

 

[BusierDonkey]

The perfect pair up at the top where they belong.

But what if they banged?

Spoiler

 

[Mozzarella]

Called the top 6 in the voting thread. Easy to predict actually.
The top 3 are the same as the top 3 of the gen, but i expected Witcher to win.
Good list overall.

A physics tech demo, a card game, a beast cutting simulator. No complaints.

 

[remember_spinal]

Pretty good, hard to argue with that list tbh

 

[adamosmaki]

decent list but personally i wouldnt have GTA V anywhere close to top 20
Glad Deus Ex made the top 20

 

[S0ULZB0URNE]

Ok glad it's not Halo Infinite again. This doesn't fit my preference but at least it's very understandable and reasonable.

The honeymoon faze is over for Infinite.

Anyway I am not mad at the results all modern classic games, GOOD JOB GAF.

 

[Krappadizzle]

Top #1 and #2 are so interchangeable in my book. On any given day if someone were to ask me what my favorite game was it'd solely be based on how I feel at that moment whether it's BotW or W3. Overall, great list. Glad Half-Life: Alyx got some love, wasn't expecting that. Alyx is an amazing experience.

 

[arvfab]

BotW

 

[nightmare-slain]

that #1-3

TLOU2 has no right being that high up and Persona 5 is lower? bullshit.

BotW

 

[amigastar]

Hm, i really have to give BotW another Chance, tried it a few times but it never really clicked with me.

 

[nightmare-slain]

for me it's

1. Breath of the Wild
2. Persona 5/Royal
3. The Witcher 3
4. Bloodborne
5. TLOU (1)
6. Nier Automata
7. RDR 2
8. Elden Ring
9. Dark Souls
10. Skyrim

 

[LavitzSlambert]

Very surprised and disappointed by the lack of support for Hollow Knight.