Gameplay for starters. And I dont mean gameplay for the sake of gameplay like they showed with some indie games like Kena and Little Devils. I mean next gen AAA gameplay. That was one of the biggest complaints of Microsoft's event in May, where they showed lame indie games and little to no gameplay, and Sony pretty much came out and did the same thing. It's really hard to get a good understanding of gameplay systems from just a trailer. Right now I am looking at all these trailers and I dont see whats next gen about it. They look prettier, sure but are the CPU and SSD being used for?
Ratchet is a great example of how to cut a trailer. They showed exactly what Cerny was talking about, and while it might be gimmicky it's something that sets the PS5 apart from next gen. I look at Horizon, Demon Souls and Spiderman and I am struggling to see what next gen gameplay systems are being used. Lets not even get into GT7 which looks cross gen as fuck because PD is basically a shell of themselves now. The less expected of them the better.
Graphically speaking, nothing blew me away like the KZSF demo. The moment people saw that, everyone knew next gen was here. What was that moment here? I cant think of one. What did blow me away was the UE5 demo. the flying sequence showcased the SSD in a way Sony's first party games that have been in development for 2-3.5 years couldnt. EA showed literally 15 seconds of footage that was more next gen than anything. People straight up refused to believe it. That's what you want, you want people to be so blown away they call BS. Hellblade 2 is another great example. The Australia realtime demo recently released by one ex-DICE dev is a great example.
It's pretty crazy to me that third party devs, Ninja fucking theory and Epic of all people have outclassed Sony studios at their own game. That simply shouldnt have happened seeing as how GG had 3.5 years to get a badass demo going. Bluepoint had 2.5 years. PD had almost 3 years. And while Insomniac did show up with the most impressive game of the show, there is only so much you can do with games like ratchet. this isnt the PS1, mascot games simply arent going to define next gen anymore. People look to spiderman or Horizon or AAA games like TLOU2 to see what games can achieve.
And then there is the fact that they went with native 4k. it makes zero sense seeing as how much GPU resources are used to get to native 4k. Anyone with a PC knows this. Literally 4x going from 1080p to native 4k. Sony devs better hope MS also goes with native 4k, because if they do go with 1440p or 4kcb then that 18% difference that is so minuscule right now is going to get much much bigger when paired with the savings they get from going down to 4kcb. There is a reason why UE5 looks so much better, it's only outputting half of the pixels of the PS5 games. They didnt waste their GPU chasing DF wars. They put it to good use making games look next gen.
Lastly, this idea that these are just gen first gen games and shouldnt be expected to look amazing is ridiculous. This is exactly the rhetoric used by MS fans who defend their cross gen stance. Oh the "real" games will come later. Wrong. Next gen games should look and play next gen. Period. We finally have a CPU that allows devs to do amazing destruction, massive world simulations like weather, NPC behavior, and interaction and we got none of that. Is there destruction in Horizon? Do trees catch fire when you use fire arrows on dinobots? Do other NPCs help you out? What are the SSD upgrades? That thing was sold to us as this secret sauce to justify a smaller 10 tflops GPU. Is it only good for level switching and loading?
Yes, I wholeheartedly agree with you that nothing in Sony's show wowed me. Everything looked shinier and newer but nothing revolutionary. It's probably going to be the next COD, Battlefield or similar big budget FPS game that showcases what next gen is all about specially because they will utilize life like photogrammetry scans, which in itself is nothing revolutionary. And now Sony have lost the studio which made the most visually stunning game on the PS4, to facebook. Ready at dawn could have come up with something amazing for the PS5.
I'm hoping that Sony will come up with some outstanding new IP to amaze us once again, 'the Horizon Zero Dawn' of next gen !
Also what we saw was just a glimpse. Sony 'might' have a lot more new gameplay mechanics to show us somewhere down the line.