The Xbox One controller I tried at the GameStop station felt a bit odd to me. The sticks are extremely loose compared to the 360 controller. Maybe it just mangled over time? or is that the way it is? That would seem hard to get used to.
Still debating on picking one up. Shame it doesn't work with the old wireless dongle. I guess for sitting at my computer desk having the controller wired is not a big deal.
I freaked out when I first used the sticks. Now I can't stand going back to the 360 pad. You get used to it quickly.