Does Pokemon really need a "Super Saiyan 2", as a central mechanic no less? Does Alakazam have to unleash his Bankai?
He is giving valid and solid arguments of why he doesn't like Megas, far from an "angry rant".
Megas are fine but there shouldn't be as many. Normal, new evolutions of old pokemons shouldn't stop happening.
On the point of it preventing roster bloat, I think it does the opposite. Mega Evolutions are essentially new Pokemon, except less of them can be used. It also might create mechanics bloat in the end, which is worst than making a 700~ roster into a 800~ one.
This pretty much, Sylveon should not be the only new evolution for past Pokémon with the rest getting Mega especially those that don't have evolution or are currently two stage. Furthermore they shouldn't prevent new Pokémon existing Gen 6 has the lowest new Pokémon count period.
At this point it feels like that Game Freak is so focus on Mega that the series is slowly changing into something that can't enjoy and be a part of it.
I was really excited for gen 6 as it was Pokémon first step into 3D and I greeted with nothing but disappointment and Game Freak still continues to disappoint me.
I am still excited for Pokémon Omega Ruby but it isn't as high when I was for Pokémon Y.
Not really Mega aren't counted in the in-game Pokédex thus do they count as new Pokémon, making the term "Mega evolution" misleading since it's the Pokémon version of Burst mode.
They are nothing more than a souped up form changed and anyone saying otherwise need to look at the in game Pokédex and will find Mega data in the forme section.
Is not overkill on Mega Lucario, an infinitely better Pokemon.
I like to think Gamefreak just doesn't want to have to keep coming up with new evolution gimmicks to explain previously fully evolved Pokemon getting new evolutions when a Megastone is a universal mechanic for it now. It's also put a lot of previously shelved Pokemon back into the spotlight, or given spotlight to Pokemon that were never used to begin with.
Lucario is pretty powerful but I don't think Adaptability Weavile would be all that bad. Its strongest moves are all less than 90BP. Not that it wouldn't be a great boon for it, but boosted Ice Shard and Knock Off would be its main benefits.I would argue that it is overkill on Lucario unless you're playing by VGC rules where Weavile wouldn't be all that good either way. Also, you're ignoring the fact that Mega Lucario can't use an item, while Adaptability Weavile would be able to use anything it want.
How so?
Also, I wouldn't blame Mega Evolutions for the issues you listed when GF has the ability to do more if they want.
I would argue that it is overkill on Lucario unless you're playing by VGC rules where Weavile wouldn't be all that good either way. Also, you're ignoring the fact that Mega Lucario can't use an item, while Adaptability Weavile would be able to use anything it want.
Anyone knows the name of the smogon forum when people are discussion the current mega announcements?
You said Adaptability would be over kill on Weavile (from what I've seen a Pokemon that's never used competitively and thought as weak according to certain forums) and then say it wouldn't be good either way in VGC. Kind of confused on your thinking.
There are quite a few Pokemon that are just the right ability away from being viable competitively. Off the top of my head
Metagross (a new ability like Filter, without its Mega upgrade)
Salamence (a new ability like MultiScale, again without its Mega)
Weavile (even though I use it now)
Dusknior (HP upgrade)
There's more that I can't think of right now (long day) but it'll only improve the overall game if Gamefreak went back and gave out new abilities, relocate stats, or add some more stat points to final evolved Pokemon that needs them. Another evolution or a Mega evo aren't the only ways to make any Pokemon more viable.
On the one hand, I look at something like Mega Kanghaskan and lose faith in the Mega concept (and humanity in general)
But on the other hand....
Yeah but they could always just retcon things. They retcon everything else, but for some reason evolutions that should've been possible earlier are a big no-no.This is true, and its definitely something I appreciate. Gen IV got ridiculous with some of those requirements.
this gif is so fucking coolAll mega evolutions should just add more hair to pokemon.
![]()
Mega Ampharos will never not be the best thing ever.
Do they ban every announced mega?
Well, don't know about .GIFs, but I recently stumbled onto these YouTube videos of Charmander and Squirtle evolving Digimon style, which were pretty fucking awesome IMO.this gif is so fucking cool
are there any other digimon-pokemon gifs like that?
There's a special ladder for suspect testing, where the Pokemon/item being suspected is banned. At the end of the testing period everyone who was above a given ladder rating votes whether the metagame with the ban is more promising than the metagame without.No, it seems to basically go, "this thing is killing us constantly, let's hold a formal investigation to see if it's actually broken." Then they hold some "suspect test" that attempts to seem democratic but I don't really know details. Aegislash just got banned recently. They're investigating mega mawile. Everybody is acting like it's a shoein to be banned, and seems to expect that this will just create a niche for the next offensive mega to seem broken and come under investigation in turn.
Mega Alakazam looks absolutely terrible. I'd like it if the beard was like Alakazam's:
![]()
but it looks bad with normal looking hair.
I'm not a fan of its two spoons evolving into five spoons either...
Mega Slowbro?
![]()
It doesn't even look like they tried LOL
I was saying that Weavile would be overkill in singles, but bad in VGC.
My problem with Adaptability Weavile is that base 120 atk and base 125 speed with Adaptability powering up one of the best attacking types in the game currently, and whatever item you want is too much. The real problem with Weavile is that its frail and its typing isn't exactly good defensively. It doesn't need any help offensively.
Since you mentioned Salamence I'm assuming you play Standard, and GameFreak is never going to acknowledge, let alone recreate Pokemon just to make certain Pokemon stick out more. Game Freak could make certain Pokemon better by going back and changing everything, but people will just end up picking out the best Pokemon and rest of the metagame will just form around them.
Also, the Pokemon you listed are already viable and just aren't used much either because of their typing vs the current meta makes them "harder" to use, or because they are simply outclassed by other Pokemon that do the same job better against what's used the most. For these Pokemon to shoot up in usage you would either need to change the metagame or give them huge enough stats/abilities to where it doesn't matter and then you end up with Pokemon that people will just want banned.
Okay.. Replace Salamence with Flareon or any Eveelution. Yes eventually the Evee lines will get Mega's and be improved but that's not the point I'm trying to make. I'm not talking about more evolutions or more mega evolutions (I'm fine with both though) I'm talking about going to Every Pokemon Evolution line and making each final evolution in that line competitively viable by relocating stats, adding some more base stats, and giving a ability that makes sense so the the very Pokemon they themselves created could see the light of day in competitive use. Yes there always going to be a Pokemon that does something better than other ones but if the other ones are close to the ones that does it the best than that will be more game changing than Mega Evo ever will be.
Edit: I also agree with what you're saying.