My only nitpick with the first finale is that I thought Brooke's party could have seen a lot more bloodshed. It felt like this huge setup to multiple killings because of all the dumbassery, but only a handful of people died.
I also think the casting of Kieran is incredible, he reminds you of Skeet Ulrich, pretty boy but with eyes that suggest a dark side and demons in the closet, but ended up (for now) being really cool.
Unfortunately, Piper being the killer was far too predictable, they do a decent job of tossing around red herrings left and right but the evidence started to pile up pretty early and just kept worsening:
-random outsider comes to town and gets into everyone's shit, plays super nice with Emma
-the ultrasound revelation and Emma's mom saying "I don't even know if it was a boy or girl" (this was the major ringer)
-the stuff in the garage with Will, her being knocked out, etc. felt super fishy to me for some reason-- showing her in the presence of another Ghostface felt like they were trying too hard to take suspicion away from her
Fun show. Excited to burn through season 2. I'm waiting until it's all out because I like to binge these kinds of things, doing so for season 1 yesterday made it feel like this huge slasher epic. So again I should probably not even be in the thread lol as I've already seen one huge spoiler, but w/e