Support NeoGAF

[element]

WTF? What a lame movie!!

 

[miyuru]

Yeah this movie sucked. :lol he's a

Spoiler

schitzophrenic

, that's so cliche.

 

[Jeffahn]

Like Fight Club sans the fighting.

...

 

[=W=]

Completely predictable, but some great performances, and I laughed my ass off at the ending (with the corn and whatnot...)

 

[Jeffahn]

I don't think we should be talking about Secret Garden (1st Rule).

...

 

[effzee]

Yeah this movie sucked. :lol he's a

Spoiler

schitzophrenic

, that's so cliche.

No he wasn't.

 

[Jeffahn]

No he wasn't.

Yeah, he just had short term memory problems, like the guy from Memento.

...

 

[Gattsu25]

the

Spoiler

corn bite

at the end was funny as hell :b

 

[DarienA]

He's not a schizophrenic, if anything he suffers from MPD. Learn your definitions dammit.

Personally I enjoyed the movie and loved the ending.

 

[Jeffahn]

The truth is that one of his personalities simply forgot that he was schizophrenic due to short term memory loss.

...

 

[Rlan]

I quite liked Secret Window until the very end. To me, it really felt like it came out of nowhere. I couldn't figure out how it all came to that conclusion.

Depp was the movies saving grace.

 

[xsarien]

WTF? What a lame movie!!

I thought it was lame only because

Spoiler

it's basically King revisiting The Dark Half

, and someone in casting obviously picking up on it.

 

[3phemeral]

I quite liked Secret Window until the very end. To me, it really felt like it came out of nowhere. I couldn't figure out how it all came to that conclusion.

Depp was the movies saving grace.

Agreed. The Movie was doing fine up until the scene after the post office; ruined from there on.

 

[demon]

'You stole my stories'

I thought it was alright. The ending was a bit of a letdown, though....a little too predictably cliche.

 

[Dan]

Very predictable, and the story's ending was only not given away until then because characters kept talking in extremely vague ways. It was so obvious that characters were both talking about different things, and completely unrealistic when neither realized and just continued using anything but specifics.

Still, Depp and Turturro put in good performances, but that's not enough to save a movie.

 

[Justin Bailey]

I'm just glad I rented it instead of seeing it in the theaters.

 

[miyuru]

Oh yeah yeah that was it, sorry I saw it when it came out.

Whatever, still cliche.

 

[Malakhov]

Just saw it and once again Depp is awesome. He's the saving grace of the movie.