SonicXtreme
Member
shocking.....ly awesome
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Sega to upgrade Megadrive / Genesis Steam game hub. Adds Mod Support!
- Thread starter Rlan
- Start date
But it's not actually a part of the process, well it hasn't in the past with Skyrim. It has to have a big stink made for Valve or whatever to even give a damn.
A possible solution is a community approval queue. But we're dealing with a niche interest on only a specific platform. It's probably ripe for abuse as well (unpopular people never getting approved for example).
Mods are cool and are happening. Paid mods? Likely not.
Banging my head against the wall because you're arguing against what you think I'm arguing and not what I'm actually arguing.
I'll add that someone making money off of someone else's content, even temporarily, is hardly the worst thing in the world, and it's essentially impossible to guard against in any industry. Remember when people discovered the Metal Gear Solid theme song was stolen from another artist?
It happens. What are the people who say "youtube's model is flawed!" even arguing? Would they suggest that people shouldn't be allowed to monetize their money on youtube at all? Because that is essentially what they are proposing here - that no paid mods at all are better than a flawed system where, occasionally, the wrong person might get paid from time to time until they are caught.
It happens. What are the people who say "youtube's model is flawed!" even arguing? Would they suggest that people shouldn't be allowed to monetize their money on youtube at all? Because that is essentially what they are proposing here - that no paid mods at all are better than a flawed system where, occasionally, the wrong person might get paid from time to time until they are caught.
RecRoulette
Member
Making a few bucks off a YouTube video is a radically different thing than making (potentially) $100ks off of stealing a mod (and poisoning the market for the actual author after the fallout). Plus it's a lot easier to prove ownership of the material that would get uploaded on something like YouTube, meaning eventual redistribution of any revenue isn't an insane legal mess.
BTW, why does anyone assume those "bad" actors didn't get paid from those stories? Valve didn't even take action in those cases, the authors did, there's no reason they wouldn't pay out...
Oh, and RBN was not the Wild West. Among many other things, stuff had to be vetted before a real release.
BTW, why does anyone assume those "bad" actors didn't get paid from those stories? Valve didn't even take action in those cases, the authors did, there's no reason they wouldn't pay out...
Oh, and RBN was not the Wild West. Among many other things, stuff had to be vetted before a real release.
what ridiculous framing. I could just as well say "making $100k of of a youtube video is radically different than making (potentially) a few bucks off of stealing a mod"
And in fact, that would be more accurate, because I doubt the market for paid sega genesis rom hacks is a $100k market, where youtube is actually a multi-million dollar market.
It doesn't have to be. Youtube uses broad strokes - you don't even have to prove ownership to take stuff down from youtube. They take a "better safe than sorry" approach. I would advocate something like this taking a similar approach.
Because the systems in question weren't up long enough before they got caught for them to get paid.
The "many other things" is actually just one other thing - you had to join the content creators club, which cost a few bucks. Steam, assuming you'd sell something, would have a similar process.
and, presumably, there would be a light cert process for paid mods as well. The entire reason we are talking about a crowdsourced vetting process is because people said a light cert process couldn't catch everyone.
Sure, and while a Greenlightesque approval queue, complete with some sort of associated fee, would definitely be the safest route to take (as Krejlooc said, this is essentially how RBN functions), I wouldn't say the paid mods system as it currently exists is unfit for purpose; abusers have been caught before they saw a cent. That, to me, says the system works, as odd as said system may seem. I'd go so far as to say that a queue should only be implemented if there comes a time that someone was finally paid for something that isn't entirely (or rather, given we're talking about mods, "entirely") theirs.
I see it in my head as a system that will get easily exhausted. Eventually people are bound to tucker themselves out if there's nothing official in place. They'll get sick of needing to kick up a fuss to get something done. Community vetting only really works as long as there's someone who cares enough to do the vetting, and without anything in place making the vetting essential... well you can probably see where I'm going with that.
you think nerds on the internet won't argue about frivolities till they are blue in the face? You don't know the internet.
deadscreensky
Member
I love you, Sega.
The only one who argues until he is blue in the face is Sonic.
How do you do this? Couldn't find anything after a quick Google.
Not true, you needed master tracks (almost impossible to get unless provided by the band/ record company) along with correct charts for every instrument on every difficulty (1 for vocals, 4 for guitar, 4 for bass, 4 for drums, 8 for keys) etc, not as easy as just uploading a sonic ROM.
again, what ridiculous framing. You describe in intricate detail the work that goes into creating a rockband track, then equate a mod to "just uploading a sonic rom."
Well, what if the process of patching your mod isn't "just uploading a sonic rom"? What if it's also involved, like, say, submitting an assembly source for your mod and letting the workshop themselves generate an IPS patch? Something that isn't really possible for people just pulling hacks off the internet?
RecRoulette
Member
Here you go.
Make sure you copy the .pak file you plan to replace for safe keeping in case you want to return it to normal. I don't have a way to get back the game I replaced with Puyo.
OmegaDL50
Member
It's in the Steam community FAQ, refer to section III - https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=398334923
You can get around this by renaming the replaced rom to a completely different name, as long as the naming structure is the same as (series of numbers.pak extension).
Also the the numbers of the game dictates their order shown in the emulator itself. You can for example rename every single game so their order would list them in alphabetical order, unlike the random jumble the games are as default.
Orakio Rob
Member
I love the Genesis Collection on Steam! I know many people hate the filters, but I actually love the TV filter, it looks very good when I connect my notebook to my TV. The only thing that bothered me was the interface, but now it's solved. The Genesis Collection is my most played Steam game.
I didn't know I could add my own roms to it, I'll try later. Anyway, I legally own all games released officially by Sega and will gladly send them even more money if they release more games.
I didn't know I could add my own roms to it, I'll try later. Anyway, I legally own all games released officially by Sega and will gladly send them even more money if they release more games.
Sub_Level
wants to fuck an Asian grill.
I did. There have been mods for that for a while now.
The Wood zone absolutely sucks. The others are playable but not great.
ramoisdead
Member
If it means more new stuff for Shining Force and Shining Force 2, count me in.
Tye The Czar
Member
I'm hoping the emulation is vastly improved. Whenever I had VSync on, I noticed serious input lag.
Mod support, however, really shows that Sega is attempting to compete with free emulators to (hopefully) offer a better service.
I do still have a few wishes for what Sega should do:
Mod support, however, really shows that Sega is attempting to compete with free emulators to (hopefully) offer a better service.
I do still have a few wishes for what Sega should do:
- Bring modern console ports & remasters of their other games to Steam.
- Start selling MAME, Master System, 32X, Sega CD roms(I'm looking at you, Golden Axe: Revenge of Death Adder!)
- Release Steam versions of Sega 3D Classics, if possible.
- More Japanese exclusives(Shining Force III & Dragon Force II! NOW!)
I wouldn't be so sure. There are fewer things people hate than someone earning money they're not entitled to or otherwise don't deserve. But, hey, you may be right and that's one of the reasons why an approval-based system would be the safer option.
Of course I am serious. Steam workshop evolving as a way to sell mods is inevitable, and putting rom hacks up in this new mod workshop for genesis games seems like such an obvious thing to do. Why not put one and one together?
Yes please.
Tizoc
Member
I am interested in these paid mods tha t you are talking about
Cuz the last time vslve tried to monetize it the idea was dropped 2 weeks later
kimifan141
Member
SEGAAAAAAAAA this is awesome , would have been perfect if they added the extras that the 360 and ps3 had like those pics and videos and achievements.
some of the psn games also have drop in online co - op
some of the psn games also have drop in online co - op
Crimsonclaw111
Member
chaobreaker
Member
What the fuck with that mod?
How did this thread go by for 4 pages without anyone commenting on this?
Kent
Member
You know... I wonder how difficult it would be to gather the distribution rights for the entire 32X library. I know there are a few licensed games that might be difficult.
I'm really hoping they do 32X and Sega CD, eventually, just so you can have your customizable Tower of Sega next to that little CRT.
And the veritable fire hazard of connecting them all to an outlet.
I'm really hoping they do 32X and Sega CD, eventually, just so you can have your customizable Tower of Sega next to that little CRT.
And the veritable fire hazard of connecting them all to an outlet.
I'm not sure what you mean, it looks like a fun challenging addition to Sonic 2
Gentleman Jack
Member
Now everyone can enjoy Sonic Boomed
ThatStupidLion
Gold Member
This is all i care about - gonna have to try this
Theanine3D
Member
I'm amazed that a company as well-known and with such a big legacy like SEGA is doing something like this. Very forward-thinking move.
Romhacking was one of my hobbies when I was a teen. It eventually led me to making mods for full PC games, which then led to my first job in the game industry. So to see them legitimizing romhacking makes me very happy.
Romhacking was one of my hobbies when I was a teen. It eventually led me to making mods for full PC games, which then led to my first job in the game industry. So to see them legitimizing romhacking makes me very happy.
Crownjo
Member
So I guess Sonic Classic Heroes might be possible on this?
Since Sega are embracing emulation here I'd love the next step on from this to be a Sega Arcade hub. They could have a virtual Sega World arcade and keep adding games from thier vast library. Now that MAME is available for commercial use many of them could be emulated without too much effort. If it was up to me I'd start off with the obvious choices with the likes of Outrun, Space Harrier and Afterburner and then just keep adding more machines leading to the dream situation of games that never made it out of arcades like Revenge of Death Adder finally being made available officially.
Tizoc
Member
Any of their arcade titles that used licensed property or references may be difficult to get them on steam
In that case maybe they could mod them to strip out any infringing content(and then modders could always add it right back again unofficially). There is past history of this as for example the version of Outrun playable in Shenmue 2 changed the car to a more generic model.
Edit: Anyway a lot of the classics have been put out on and are currently being sold on the 3DS so I see no reason why they can't have PC releases too at the very least.
