So after playing about 20 hours so far, my opinion hasn't changed: this is a fun, addicting little rpg. I can still absolutely see why people wouldn't like it, but to me it's exactly what I wanted it to be: a throwback to PS2 rpg's with some great tunes and nice mechnanics. Don't go in expecting a 2016 game and you should be fine. I love how fast-paced almost everything is. I'd say my main gripe would be the backtracking (which is why I said "almost everything"), but usually I don't even mind that because it all feels so smooth and I like traversing the maps.
Again, don't go in expecting anything groundbreaking and you'll find a fun addicting little rpg that's well worth your time. If you're on the fence watch some reviews that cover both sides of the love/hate spectrum I guess and decide for yourself.
/edit: I should also note that the game is almost laughably low-budget. The corners they have had to cut are so obvious it's almost funny. Almost nothing gets animated, most things happen off-screen. It almost gives it an OG Star Trek feel. Personally I'm a fan of low-budget things when the actual game is solid, and this definitely qualifies for me.