• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Superman vs the Incredible hulk...settle my nerd debate please

Status
Not open for further replies.
RealDeadOne said:
He doesn't have to kill him to beat him. He can be thrown into space, although that could lead to a World War Hulk scenario years down the line. There are ways to incapacitate the Hulk, or cause him to be "knocked out" and turn back into Banner. But of course the problem with comics is that's never really consistent.
Click to expand...

Sorry, I meant beat or incapacitate/knock out as you said. But yeah that's true.
 
Current gen Superman would lose.

Silver age Superman would fuck up any version of the Hulk real bad.
 
Wouldn't Superman just throw Hulk into space? Even if the Hulk can survive in space, he has no way to getting back on Earth without outside help. He could be extremely lucky and happen to hit something like an Asteroid(not likely, space is HUGE) and somehow manage to target a moving Earth when he leaps off of it. If Hulk manage to return, Superman can just throw him back into space again(or into the direction of the sun).
 
tenchir said:
Wouldn't Superman just throw Hulk into space? Even if the Hulk can survive in space, he has no way to getting back on Earth without outside help. He could be extremely lucky and happen to hit something like an Asteroid(not likely, space is HUGE) and somehow manage to target a moving Earth when he leaps off of it.
Click to expand...

World War Hulk shows that he's quite adept at finding his way back home after being abandoned in space.
 
tenchir said:
Wouldn't Superman just throw Hulk into space? Even if the Hulk can survive in space, he has no way to getting back on Earth without outside help. He could be extremely lucky and happen to hit something like an Asteroid(not likely, space is HUGE) and somehow manage to target a moving Earth when he leaps off of it. If Hulk manage to return, Superman can just throw him back into space again.
Click to expand...

Nerdsteve said:
Hulk would throw Superman in space.

2453417-hulk_vs_superman.jpg
Click to expand...


!
 
As much as I love Hulk, I would give it to Superman in this. But only if Superman is smart enough to know to just jettison Hulk off into space. If he tries to keep it earthbound, then Supes is screwed. Of course, Superman was dumb enough to keep his first fight with Doomsday earthbound.

That would be a cooler fight. Hulk vs. Doomsday. Hulk would just have to keep finding better ways to smash him each time he came back.
 
CorvoSol said:
At least Peter Parker didn't kill his father figure and use a force he knew was more likely to hurt than harm in an attempt to kick start his species?
Click to expand...


uh.....what?

User Name Here said:
Hulk would win unless they fought on the sun or something. But then Hulk would get mad enough to survive a fight on the sun.

So the real question is: How many licks does it take to get to the center of a tootsie roll pop?



But that's assuming Superman would kill him in one maneuver. If Superman's first move doesn't kill him, his subsequent moves wouldn't likely kill him since Hulk would be pissed at that point.
Click to expand...


45 licks
Superman doesn't kill and he's already fought people of equal and greater power (Brainiac, Darkseid, Doomsday) Hulk SAYS the madder he gets the stronger he gets, but it's bnever been shown to eb the case. while Superman has been shown to Move planets and moons (current modern Superman not silver age) and hulk hasn't topped that. plus speed, heat vision, invulnerability and flight make him too much for Hulk. I think the more interesting argument is Gladiator versus Superman.
 
Deified Data said:
Please, he'd find a fucking ship.
Click to expand...

it would take him a looong time assuming he's tossed into random space and it takes 1xx years to crash into a planet with enough tech.

PhoncipleBone said:
As much as I love Hulk, I would give it to Superman in this. But only if Superman is smart enough to know to just jettison Hulk off into space. If he tries to keep it earthbound, then Supes is screwed. Of course, Superman was dumb enough to keep his first fight with Doomsday earthbound.

That would be a cooler fight. Hulk vs. Doomsday. Hulk would just have to keep finding better ways to smash him each time he came back.
Click to expand...


well it's not like Hulk or Doomsday will just let themselves get grabbed and tossed into space. ebings of equal strenght usually just have drag-out, knock-out fights because theya re so evenly matched. Superman grabs Doomsday and tosses him to the moon, Doomsday just jumps back down to Earth. same as the Hulk.
 
Hulk

Superman absorbs his power from the Sun.

Hulk draws his power from from the multiverse.
 
The Flash. The answer is always speedsters.

Though I am going to have to go with Superman, super speed and flight are huge advantages.

The real question is can Kenshiro's Hokuto Shinken kill Superman or the Hulk?
 
Superman would appeal to Hulk's sense of not having any sense and enrage him. Then he would fly up into space and Hulk would jump into space and suffocate.
 
Lion Heart said:
I think we've had this exact thread with those exact superheroes. ANd supes.
eh, close enough.
Click to expand...
Narag said:
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=436100
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=474713
Slightly less relevant:
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=441728
Click to expand...

Id like to add this recent thread as well:
http://neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=488378

K.Sabot said:
Superman would appeal to Hulk's sense of not having any sense and enrage him. Then he would fly up into space and Hulk would jump into space and suffocate.
Click to expand...
HAHAHA:
XoGJM.jpg


Space cant hold Hulks Rage!
Hulk is more Doomsday than Doomsday and Doomsday killed Superman.....to answer the question it depends on the plot...if one of them is more right than the other thats who will win.
 
RealDeadOne said:
He doesn't have to kill him to beat him. He can be thrown into space, although that could lead to a World War Hulk scenario years down the line. There are ways to incapacitate the Hulk, or cause him to be "knocked out" and turn back into Banner. But of course the problem with comics is that's never really consistent.
Click to expand...

Yeah kinda like how Frieza knew he couldnt beat Super Saiyan Goku so he tried to blow up the planet because if the planet blew up there would be no more air for him to breathe.

Superman could even just throw Hulk into the Sun.
 
Supes won't win by virtue of being a goody two shoes, unless he is pushed to the limit and try to lobotomize Hulk.
 
Finaika said:
Why does he need a sword?
Click to expand...

To cut shit up!

teruterubozu said:
Kill him while he's Dr. Bruce Banner and unaware (sniper rifle).
You can't even kill Clark Kent.
Click to expand...

Kill Banner and you get Hulk with no Banner to hold him back....might as well give superman a Krytonite Sandwich.

Hulk just wants to be left alone, Superman being such a goody two shoes he would want to make sure the monster is contained....this would further enrage the hulk making him stronger....Superman would then be more determined to put hulk down.....this would enrage the hulk some more and now tha planet is too soft to contain the fight.
 
So Hulk has plot armor then?

Also if Supes learned that Hulk regenerates from almost nothing and anger gets him, then he can reason with him and use those facts. Supes isn't just a flying brick, he's actually intelligent.
 
Ookami-kun said:
So Hulk has plot armor then?

Also if Supes learned that Hulk regenerates from almost nothing and anger gets him, then he can reason with him and use those facts. Supes isn't just a flying brick, he's actually intelligent.
Click to expand...

You think Hulk wouldn't get angry if someone tried to reason with him? I think he would probably get more angry that the person isn't fighting him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

  • Poll
Superman (1978) vs Batman (1989) vs Spider-Man (2002)
2
81
876
MrCunningham replied
New " Check out my Hyperscape scan" thread. It's incredible
26
1K
jason10mm replied
  • Poll
Peppermint vs. Spearmint
19
261
Dr.Morris79 replied
  • Poll
Let's settle this. How do you pronounce 'gif'.
2 3
104
1K
Catphish replied
  • Poll
Was Hulk Hogans greatest accomplishment on earth...
34
803
Dithadder replied
Top Bottom