• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Teddie vs Morgana

MiguelMexMIstery said:
Wait weren't you the one that had Morgana w Opa-Opa in his avatar?
Click to expand...

Haha yeah! I was just super excited for P5 and Soejima drawing Opa Opa.

But to be clear I do like Morgana, but while Teddie could be annoying at times, usually it felt like he was just a child. Morgana is far more "normal" and is purposely mean which got tiring fast. Also him being smarter and more or less knowing about boundaries made the instances where he acts like a perv way creepier.

I'm also not a fan of how they made him a mascot just because, that was super disappointing.
 
Antiwhippy said:
latest


You rang?
Click to expand...
Still the GOAT
hqdefault.jpg

Opa-Pa said:
Haha yeah! I was just super excited for P5 and Soejima drawing Opa Opa.

But to be clear I do like Morgana, but while Teddie could be annoying at times, usually it felt like he was just a child. Morgana is far more "normal" and is purposely mean which got tiring fast.

I'm also not a fan of how they made him a mascot just because, that was super disappointing.
Click to expand...
I knew it was you! Ahhh haha I can understand the excitement xD I was also dissapointment with Morgana's character and actions during the game. Hopefully they tone down the next mascot character
 
MigueelDnd said:
At first, I thought you were shitting on Koro-chan. Was getting ready to defend him and all.

This is just plain unfair, though. Most of P3's characters were way more interesting and complete than the ones from 5.
Click to expand...

Hell naw. Who can hate on koromaru?
 
Antiwhippy said:
latest


You rang?
Click to expand...

Basically.

For the topic at hand though, it's hard for me to say. They're both kind of problematic for similar reasons, mostly being overly pervy and dragging scenes down with it, but hey, they try. Generally.

Morgana was a way better party member though. Pretty much never used Teddie.
 
Don't know much about Teddie but Morgana is pretty much the MVP in the group. Healing just about everyone saving my ass so many times. I also really like the character.

tumblr_ootctsjanu1vwvx0xo1_500.gif
 
Teddie, easily.

All of P5's characters were underdeveloped, and Morgana's main character moment was
an outburst than didn't make sense for both him and Ryuji. His separation from the team never tracked.

Also Teddie is a shadow turned good, Morgana is a forgetful mystical aid. Teddie got the way cooler twist.

Plus, the bear puns are great, no matter how people try and make them out as polarizing.
 
Liked both, however Morgana more than Teddy. She (yes, for me Morgana is definitely a she with that voice, despite what the game wants me to believe) is more introspective, and does not have a weird alternative form.

After I was done with the game, I took my plush Morgana from the CE and acted out plot points. An effective way of coping with the loss of having no more P5 to play.
 
Aztechnology said:
How is a character stripping away your freedom for arbitrarily structured reasons a meme?

Persona 5 is the only Persona game I've played... but I hate that stupid crap.
Click to expand...

Antiwhippy said:
Because he just replaces your character thinking to himself that he's tired lol.
Click to expand...

He's the physical representation of a supremely annoying game decision. Which is only there, to add some kind of replay value later in that by the end of the game for NG+ you can have more freedom and options. I dislike that immensely. Therefore I harbor a grudge against Morgana.
 
Teddie is great and I love his bear puns and humor in general. He's a fun source of comic relief.

e1uN5Mu.jpg
Click to expand...

However, he is frankly useless. Morgana has much more utility. Being able to turn into a cat bus for easy travel is incredible. Morgana is also a great character and has an admirable progression throughout the story. Him posing as the voice in your head that tells you what you can and can't do is a complete non-issue. Besides, some of things he says when you interact with things are pretty funny.

34183922301_ae1c790f1a_o.png
Click to expand...

His interpretations of human behavior are cute.
 
Teddie is way better

Morgana is shamelessly derivative of Teddie and his character arc goes nowhere

Probably my single biggest disappointment with P5, character-wise
 
i never played p4 but i have played p5 and i can tell you that morgana is a pest. what an annoying little shit character
 
I like P4 much better than 5 and even I say Morgana is better. I didn't even mind him telling me to go to bed. I found that whole thing way too overblown.
 
Blasphemy.

Morgana is like a million times better than Teddy. His voice and character is way more appealing.

Plus, FREAKING CATBUS!!!
 
Lord of Ostia said:
Morgana is honestly a way better character. I love that you carry him around in your bag and that he comments on your daily life. Honestly, of all the characters in P5, he feels like the MC's closest friend.
Click to expand...

Yeah, that moment where (ending spoilers)

Instead of remaining in Tokyo with the gang he chooses to go to live with Joker truly felt earned. The rest of the team were friends, Morgana is your companion through the whole ordeal and while it's never shown you can almost feel the lenghty discussions they would have regarding their daily situation before going to bed
 
I prefer teddy mostly because I feel that Morgana always being with you and commenting on every little thing you do undermines player agency.
 
sasliquid said:
I feel that Morgana always being with you and commenting on every little thing you do undermines player agency.
Click to expand...

I agree with this somewhat. Some of the things he says when you're interacting with things in the overworld are charming, but in other instances when you're just trying to get simple things done, like playing a video game, it's just more uninteresting text to skip through.

EDIT: Ugh. I'm really sorry for the double post. I overestimated how fast the thread was moving.
 
What's even Teddie's deal as
a Shadow? Shadows are repressed or subconscious aspects of a personality. Instead, Teddie is a conscious individual with his own personality.
 
Honestly I found both of them pretty annoying. Morgana commenting about every single thing and how it is important for the phantom thieves felt like he was micromanaging you at every step. I like his moveset tho.

Teddie hitting on everyone was just really weird since the joke runs its' course far before he stops doing it, neither his Japanese nor English voice do the characters any favors and it feels like the story could have been told more or less without him. I like his puns tho.

All in all, I'd say my vote goes to Koromaru.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

  • Locked
DLSS5 vs PSSR vs FSR vs XESS etc
3
313
daninthemix replied
  • Poll
Tainted Grail vs. Hell is Us vs. Cronos vs. Dying Light Beast
46
552
xenosys replied
Decomps vs static recomps vs pc ports vs hybrid emulation recomps...a tricky thing!
0
247
VGEsoterica replied
Invincible VS | Review Thread
Analysis Review 
0
286
Draugoth replied
Resident Evil 7 - PS4 vs Switch 2 vs PS5 graphics comparison
30
1K
Ryseer replied
Top Bottom