-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
The giant spider trope in games has to stop
- Thread starter Forkball
- Start date
If someone is that scared of innocent animals than he has bigger problems than video games.
Replace all spiders with Rachnera
Yes.
I agree OP. I'm mildly aracnaphobic, and the building infested with spiders leading up to the final boss of the Brightstone Cove Tseldora area had me pretty freaked out. When you have to navigate your way across webs down to the bottom, I had to shut the game off, and come back later. I just couldn't do it. That's not great game design IMO. On the other hand, the actual "giant spider" boss of the area didn't bother me at all from a phobia standpoint. It was the least believable giant spider I had seen, with lasers coming out of her lady parts, and all. Now, her minions scurrying around were not pleasant, but the giant boss herself was ok.
Same with Rom in Bloodborne. Didn't even look like a spider, and really didn't behave like one. But bloodborne had it's own spider themes, and they gave me the creeps on more than one occasion in the chalice dungeons.
Bottom line, just don't need to see anymore of this type of enemy. It's overdone.
Same with Rom in Bloodborne. Didn't even look like a spider, and really didn't behave like one. But bloodborne had it's own spider themes, and they gave me the creeps on more than one occasion in the chalice dungeons.
Bottom line, just don't need to see anymore of this type of enemy. It's overdone.
Baron von Loathsome
Member
Fine Ham Abounds
Member
Get rid of packs of wild rats and dogs first. The only way someone could think spiders are a more overused trope than dogs and rats (in video games, I'll give you that cobwebs and spiders are overused in PG-13 horror movies) is if they had arachnophobia.
Personally, I want more arachnids, make them intelligent shapeshifters like dragons and make the dragons dumbass lizards for a change.
Personally, I want more arachnids, make them intelligent shapeshifters like dragons and make the dragons dumbass lizards for a change.
cm osi
Member
i'll take sir Daniel Fortesque over those 2 buffoons everyday
JumpCancel
Banned
"I don't want these unrealistic fantasy/scifi creatures in my unrealistic fantasy/sci fi video game."
It's tough to create genuinely original designs. Spider-like creatures, monsters or beasts have an innate fear factor and are accessible. I just accept them as part of the culture in fantasy works or science fiction.
I think what you want is original designs or simply original creations. This late into humanity that'll be tough to find. Zombies are done to death, Nazis the same, dragons to an extent, skeletons, robots. May differ in their aesthetics but the basis is the same.
It's tough to create genuinely original designs. Spider-like creatures, monsters or beasts have an innate fear factor and are accessible. I just accept them as part of the culture in fantasy works or science fiction.
I think what you want is original designs or simply original creations. This late into humanity that'll be tough to find. Zombies are done to death, Nazis the same, dragons to an extent, skeletons, robots. May differ in their aesthetics but the basis is the same.
Fuck, I want to play that expansion. Wonder how much weed/other stuff I have to take.
TheChewyWaffles
Member
Spiders are fine.
GinoFelino
Member
I'm down, as long as it's a more creative interpretation than 'It's a spider, but much bigger than a normal one!'
EvilKatarn
Member
I'm incredibly arachnophobic and Rom, Amygdala and Brightstone Cove don't affect me a single bit.
Don't call it bad design. It's all individual and I enjoy killing spiders in video games.
Actually, I'm more or less "trypophile", I love staring at all these holed things.
Don't click if you are arachnophobe and trypophobe.
The thing that bothered me about spiders in souls-esque games was the element of surprise. Navigating that spider infested room in BCT, it was dark, and I had no idea where the spiders were. If one of them dropped on my head I would have had a heart attack. Once I played through that section once, it no longer bothered me.
I feel like it's a Tolkeinian thing. And most of these games just glom onto a generic fantasy trope and that kind of imagery is already there.
Plus, sure, arachnophobia. Spiders are fucking scary as fuck. Anything with multiple limbs and fangs and a lack of sclera.
Couple weeks back I dreamt a spider was crawling on my head and I smashed it on my face and then I thought nothing of it, but when I later got up for work, THERE WAS CRUSHED SPIDER ON MY FACE.
Y'know what would terrify me? An orangutan with 8 arms and 8 eyes, all burning red. Riding a giant yellow jacket. That's some horseman (horseape?) of the apocalypse shit.
Plus, sure, arachnophobia. Spiders are fucking scary as fuck. Anything with multiple limbs and fangs and a lack of sclera.
Couple weeks back I dreamt a spider was crawling on my head and I smashed it on my face and then I thought nothing of it, but when I later got up for work, THERE WAS CRUSHED SPIDER ON MY FACE.
Y'know what would terrify me? An orangutan with 8 arms and 8 eyes, all burning red. Riding a giant yellow jacket. That's some horseman (horseape?) of the apocalypse shit.
How about playing as one?
That "spider" only has 6 legs...
Manmademan
Member
I don't have a problem with these enemies but holy hell was the giant teleporting spider in Darksiders a nightmare boss
Spiders are the only enemies for which i will close my eyes and mash attack buttons or set my party to auto attack and come back a few minutes later. Fuck everything about them forever. I don't even like the spider pokemon .
I understand they have a place in gaming and there are some great examples of uniquely crafted boss fights but they are way too often just shoved into games for no reason as a filler enemy . It'd be nice to play more games without the persist thought that eventually I'm going to have to fight a giant spider.
I understand they have a place in gaming and there are some great examples of uniquely crafted boss fights but they are way too often just shoved into games for no reason as a filler enemy . It'd be nice to play more games without the persist thought that eventually I'm going to have to fight a giant spider.
PeskyToaster
Member
What better way to get over arachnophobia than fucking up some giant ass spiders.
Palculator
Unconfirmed Member
Money was tight.
Incendiary
Banned
Giant spiders are fine when they aren't realistic. But the Nightmare Apostles in Bloodborne legit creep me out and scare me more than any other enemy in the game because they're too much like real spiders. Duke's Dear Freja? No problem, it's a weird spider that shoots lasers. But those Bloodborne spiders, ugh.
I do have an arachnophobic friend who can't play games with serious spider enemies, too. So I get that.
I do have an arachnophobic friend who can't play games with serious spider enemies, too. So I get that.
Shake Appeal
Member
I wouldn't mind seeing more inventive giant spiders, especially an actual Shelob-style encounter where you are being hunted and trapped by one spider. But they're usually just reskinned giant rats with an added poision debuff.
Dr. Black Jack
Member
also what's up with the "all the sandwiches have crusts" trope in video games
some people don't like that
some people don't like that
Lord British
Member
How about playing as one?
brb, buying Watch_Dogs.
Beren the Empty-Handed
Member
It's just not the same.
cm osi
Member
there's a nsfw version (the original one), in case you're interested you know
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Ivan Amiibo
Banned
Im in ur dojo, killin all ur dudes
CLACKCLACK CLACKCLACK CLACKCLACK
Yeah, I'd think people who are afraid of spiders would love killing them in the safe confines of a video game.
Only extreme arachnophobics and wussies are afraid of digital spiders!
Yeah I really didnt enjoy playing Bloodborne, but damn the monster design is in a league of its own!
OP, stay away from EDF
Daaaaw. She's so cute.
illmatic22
Banned
I get the feeling that OP wouldn't get along with Jon Peters.
Ivan Amiibo
Banned
Limbo and the spiders from Legend of Grimrock are the two that got me the most. Spiders are inherently evil. They make great enemies.
Is this a mod or is Watch_Dogs way more crazy then I was ever led to believe.
How about playing as one?
Is this a mod or is Watch_Dogs way more crazy then I was ever led to believe.
Portugeezer
Member
Nah, giant spiders are cool.
OniBarubary
Banned
I always had an idea for a level in an RPG or Souls game as life went on about a library staffed entirely by spiders. It'd be like the Duke's Archives in DS, just wall to wall books and the giant spiders would go around carrying books and putting them on shelves and taking them off and organizing stuff and they'd all have these neat little patterns they'd follow. And if you came in and left them alone they'd just carry on their business but if you attack them they'd drop all their books and just kinda skitter back terrified of you and not understanding why you're hurting them.
Or if it was an RPG some character tells you the book can be found in the Spider Library and your characters are like "...excuse me wat" and you go and they're super friendly and helpful and just normal NPCs just giant librarian spiders. And all the time your party members are just so freaked out and trying not to scream and the spider is all "I found your book! Hoo boy it was really lost in the back there. You can return it any time!" It'd be so cute! :3
...also I want Giant Spider party member. It would get depressed no one wants to do team attacks with it and keep trying to win the favor of the girl who's terrified of it. And then when the evil villain is going to wipe the party the spider sacrifices himself to save everyone and the girl finally accepts all the shit they've been through together and his friendship and flashes back through all the times she treated him bad and flips out and swears revenge and her most powerful attack is "Super Spider Strike" except with a cooler name. And she stabs the villain in his fucking FACE. For spiderbro!
Dammit, where's Robert from Zeboyd?! Gimme a spider party member the main girl is tsundere for! You're the only company that does nonhuman party members right!
I may...have spent too much time thinking about this.
Or if it was an RPG some character tells you the book can be found in the Spider Library and your characters are like "...excuse me wat" and you go and they're super friendly and helpful and just normal NPCs just giant librarian spiders. And all the time your party members are just so freaked out and trying not to scream and the spider is all "I found your book! Hoo boy it was really lost in the back there. You can return it any time!" It'd be so cute! :3
...also I want Giant Spider party member. It would get depressed no one wants to do team attacks with it and keep trying to win the favor of the girl who's terrified of it. And then when the evil villain is going to wipe the party the spider sacrifices himself to save everyone and the girl finally accepts all the shit they've been through together and his friendship and flashes back through all the times she treated him bad and flips out and swears revenge and her most powerful attack is "Super Spider Strike" except with a cooler name. And she stabs the villain in his fucking FACE. For spiderbro!
Dammit, where's Robert from Zeboyd?! Gimme a spider party member the main girl is tsundere for! You're the only company that does nonhuman party members right!
I may...have spent too much time thinking about this.
oh yea! Monster Hunter goodness!!
boondock18
Member
I am tired of people throwing the word trope around. It has quickly become the cliche go to word when complaining about something in entertainment.
Corronchilejano
Member
there's a nsfw version (the original one), in case you're interested you know
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Can't link to that, can you? It interests me... for science...
0ptimusPayne
Member
I thought fighting that spider demon thing in the first DMCry was actually pretty cool lol